Film details

Carnage  2011

The God of Carnage / Le Dieu Du Carnage

Cast

Synopsis

Two couples, living in Manhattan, meet to discuss an incident between their two young sons which has left one of them with a broken tooth, Ethan, the son of hosts Penelope and Michael Longstreet, claiming that Zachery, the son of visitors Nancy and Alan Cowan, violently attacked him with a stick during an argument in the school playground. Their meeting is calm and overly polite, no one apportioning blame, or discussing whether the boys should sort it out between them. As they talk over cake and coffee, Alan, a lawyer, repeatedly has to take calls regarding a newspaper's investigations into a drug produced by one of his company's clients, a pharmaceutical giant. The reason for the playground fight turns out to be Ethan not allowing Zachery into his 'gang'. Nancy is infuriated by Alan repeatedly having to leave to take calls, claiming he doesn't want to face up to his family problems, and stuns Penelope when she is suddenly violently sick after eating the cake Penelope has made, vomiting over a rare book on the coffee table. Michael gets a call from his mother, who has heard about the controversy concerning the disputed drug, and it is one she is taking as part of her medication. Michael tells her to stop taking the drug, and argues with Alan, who he thinks is working to cover up the true extent of the scandal. Trying to dissipate the increasing tension, Michael opens a bottle of Scotch, hoping a drink will calm people's tempters, but it only does the complete opposite. Penelope turns against her husband, accusing him to abandoning his ambition and goals and instead setting for comfortable mediocrity, while he claims that most marriages are only unions of mutual convenience anyway, Alan airs the opinion that violence has been used to settle arguments throughout man's history, and it won't change. Penelope starts to lecture Alan and Nancy about poverty and suffering in Africa, causing Michael to force her to be quiet and provoking her into hitting him. Driven to the edge of her patience by the ceaseless phone calls, which she claims are ruining her family life, Nancy takes Alan's mobile and drops it into a vase of water. Trying to calm the escalating situation, Nancy suggests that both boys were equally to blame for what has happened, but that is a compromise Penelope is unwilling to accept, and causes even greater aggression and outright hostility....

Production

Director
Roman Polanski
Producer
Said Ben Said
Art Director
Dean Tavoularis
Editor
Herve De Luze
Screenplay
Yasmina Reza and Roman Polanski, based on the play Le Dieu Du Carnage / The God Of Carnage by Yasmina Reza
Director of Photography
Pawel Edelman

Review

Yasmina Reza is obviously rather popular with stage producers, her three-handed one-set play Art being an immense international hit, while being comparatively cheap to mount, while her 2006 work The God Of Carnageraises the ante, increasing the cast by an entire third, having a cast of four instead of three, and, under the abbreviated title Carnage, boasts a tremendous cast line-up in the film version, comprising Jodie Foster (The Accused / Panic Room ), Kate Winslet (Titanic / The Reader), Christophe Waltz (Inglourious Basterds / Water For Elephants) and John C. Reilly (Chicago / Walk Hard), and being directed by Roman Polanski, which is an impressive combination. As with Art its' a prickly and increasingly uncomfortable comedy, anchored in one location and touching on some very sensitive areas, set in the Manhattan apartment of Penelope and Michael Longstreet (Foster and Reilly), since Zachery, the son of Nancy and Alan Cowan (Winslet and Waltz), has attacked their own son, Ethan, with a stick, breaking a couple of his teeth. What starts as an attempt at reconciliation and a civilised approach to settling any arguments soon slips away, as the four move from coffee and pastries to starting to drink. They let down their guard, let slip various sensitive remarks, remark on incidents which would seem to have little bearing with the matter in hand, such as lawyer Alan's incessant calls on his mobile, and air otherwise withheld and perhaps unairable opinions, and pretty soon what has begun as a civilised summit has virtually turned into a bloodsport, exposing the truths behind their own, far from perfect relationships and prejudices. Of course the cruelty and sheer appalling behaviour they start to display far outstrip anything their children may have done to each other, and Reza manages to keep the tone both very darkly funny yet acutely painful at the same time. Opened up slightly from its' stage origins simply by having Pawel Edelman's camera roam more freely through the apartment, shot on a Paris sound stage, Carnage is a great opportunity for a quartet of very fine actors to go through their paces, the script ranging from all-out humour to some far darker, more vicious scenes, even if some of the genuine shock moments of the stage version, such as having one of the actors suddenly and unexpectedly vomit, are less impactful on the screen, but still have the power to make the viewer squirm as social niceties are ruthlessly stripped away. Although some have compared this to Edward Albee's Who's Afraid Of Virginia Wolfe, Carnage is both less self-consciously confrontational and far intentionally funnier, although the sheer painfulness of what is revealed in some scenes may just be too coruscating for some. This is actually surprisingly fitting material for Polanski, several of whose films, from Knife In The Water to the bitterly dark The Tenant, have involved some elements of social anxiety and embarrassment, the true emotions seething under the surface, and the small-scale but perfectly crafted Carnage is a perfect vehicle for director and cast alike.