Film details

Comandante  2003

Film still

Cast

  • Fidel Castro
  • Juanita Vera
  • Fidel Castro Jr.
  • Fidel Castro III
  • Juan Almedia

Synopsis

Filmmaker Oliver Stone arrives in Havana, the capital of Cuba, in February 2002 for three days with Fidel Castro, the Cuban leader for over forty years, a film crew accompanying them at all times. The two men meet in Castro's office in Havana, then take to one of his official cars for a trip through the city. Stone is shown a hospital and, told, through Castro's longtime interpreter Juanita Vera, that Cuba has the finest free health service in the world, and quotes impressive statistics, then they move onto a museum of modern art where new works by Cuban artists are displayed. Stone dines at Castro's home and meets his family, including his son Fidel Castro Jr, and his grandson Fidel Castro III. Stone asks questions, but seems not to be interested in pursuing the subject after the initial answer. Asking Castro about dictatorship, Castor claims to be a dictator to himself, a slave to the Cuban people. They talk about the history of Cuba in the forty years since Castro took power from the corrupt Batista regime. Castro claims that Cuba has free elections, Stone not reminding him that while that is true in a sense, there is only one party to vote for on the ballot papers. Talking about the Cuban idea that the revolution invented 'machismo', or masculinity, Stone does not bring up the fact that Cuba has been the only country in the world with enforced labour camps solely for those convicted for homosexuality. Stone does not bring up Cuba's continuing policy of the execution of political dissidents, which is believed by Amnesty International to be one of the highest anywhere in the world. When the subject of the assassination of John F.Kennedy is brought up, Oliver Stone having directed an entire film concerning it, Castro does not rise to Stone's hints that there was Cuban involvement, but agrees that there was a conspiracy, but of whom he knows not. They talk about a wide range of subjects, Stone seemingly unable to get much more out of Castro than that which has been previously revealed in earlier interviews, although he does confess to a liking for Sophia Loren and Ava Gardner when he was a young man. Stone does not seem to be fully listening to the answers, and Castro does not show a shred of humour at Stone's attempts at jokes. At one point the interpreter accidentally reveals that she has been working with 'El Comandante' so long that she now often predicts what he is going to say and translates that. After three days Stone is escorted to the airport, and is embraced by Castro before he flies to the USA, a luxury denied any Cuban citizen.

Production

Director
Oliver Stone
Producer
Fernando Sulichin and Oliver Stone
Editor
Alex Marquez and Elisa Bonora
Music
Alberto Iglesias
Screenplay
Original idea by Jose Ibanez and Alvaro Marcovich
Director of Photography
Rodrigo Prieto and Carlos Marcovici

Review

A truly great opportunity is missed by Oliver Stone in the making of Comandante, and although Stone himself may not agree, a lot of the audience will think that he is no match for Fidel Castro, since you don't overthrow a country and then run it, quelling all dissension with the cliched iron fist for forty years without being able to swat away the questions of a supposedly astute film-maker as though they were gnats and truly lead him where you want him. Although some of the footage is revealing, especially in seeing Castro's personal office and meeting his family members, Stone's line of questions resembles Richard and Judy rather than the Today Programme. Stone never follows up any of his most provocative questions, mild though they are, as if he were more interested in getting another question in rather than continuing a line of questioning, such as the labour camps for gay men or the execution of dissidents. Wincingly, Stone has to get the subject of JFK into this, and Castro gives a brilliantly non-committal answer. Hampered with a moustache which The Village People would envy, Stone becomes a gauche intrusive character, playing to the camera while Castro, well over seventy, not in the best of health and obviously having troubled writing through rheumatism is still compelling while on the screen, obviously toying with Stone. The fact that HBO pulled Comandante from its initial transmission date in the US in April 2003 due to more than seventy five dissidents in Cuba being given show trials and long prison sentences, three of them being executed for the crime of trying to leave the island, shows the yawning gulf between what Oliver Stone thinks he has achieved and the political reality of Cuba today.