Film details

You Instead  2011

Tonight You're Mine

Cast

  • Natalia Tena
  • Mathew Baynton
  • Alistair Mackenzie
  • Gavin Mitchell
  • Ruta Gedmintas
  • Sophie Wu
  • Kari Corbett
  • Al Green
  • Clare Kelly
  • Joseph Mydell
  • Jonny Phillips

Synopsis

Directed by Scottish helmer David Mackenzie, critics were perhaps expecting something rather different from the director responsible for such intense films as About Adam, Asylum and Hallam Foe, and the unfortunate Ashton Kutcher misfire Spread, You Instead being a far lighter and less serious pic, but it is also certainly one which has divided audiences, some getting into the film's distinctly upbeat vibe and others calling it a miscalculation on all counts. Shot entirely at the 2010 T In The Park Festival, Scotland's biggest music festival, held at Strathclyde Park in Balado near Kinross, British actor Luke Treadaway plays an American musician, Ada (and having played a similar character in his debut, Brothers Of The Head), part of an electro-duo The Make, along with his bandmate Tyko (Mathew Banyon - Telstar). On his way to see their manger, Bobby (Gavin Mitchell - TV's Still Game), Adam gets involved in an argument with Morello (Natalia Tena - Nymphadora Tonks in the latter Harry Potters), the lead singer of a raucous all-girl band, The Dirty Pinks, only to be overheard by an eccentric passing preacher (Joseph Mydell - Manderlay) who gives them a brief lecture about peace and understanding, before handcuffing the pair together and making off with the key. The preacher can't be found, so the pair have to try to get along while handcuffed together, and play their festival sets as such, and of course the ending is never in doubt that by the time the cuffs come off they'll be inseparable anyway. Ahhhhhhh. There are a few easily overcome obstacles in their way to true love, such both of them having partners, he in the form of the unbearable Lake (Ruta Gedmintas - TV's Spooks: Code 9), while Morello is involved with the fundamentally decent if rather dull Mark (Alistair Mackenzie, the helmer's brother), which may lose the couple some audience sympathy as she dumps this essentially well-meaning chap. Obviously low-budget and partially improvised, Mackenzie's intention is obviously to capture the madness and hedonism of a massive festival, and largely succeeds, complete with a small role for the excellent singer / songwriter Newton Faulkner, but some have said that, ironically in such a massive festival, the weakest bands on display are the fictional ones, The Make and The Dirty Pinks. Very different from the films which brought him to prominence, You Instead, an oddly oblique title, seems to be dividing audiences into two very separate camps, one accepting the film's whimsy and formulaic plot and others hating every single frame and note.

Production

Director
David Mackenzie
Producer
Gillian Berrie
Editor
Jake Roberts
Music
Various
Screenplay
Thomas Leveritt
Director of Photography
Giles Nuttgens

Review

Directed by Scottish helmer David Mackenzie, one is perhaps surprised to see something so different from the filmmaker responsible for such intense and indeed wrenching films as About Adam, Asylum and Hallam Foe, and the unfortunate Ashton Kutcher misfire Spread. You Instead being a far lighter and less serious pic, but it is also certainly a movie which divides audiences, some getting into the film's distinctly loose, upbeat vibe and others believing it's a miscalculation on all counts. Shot entirely at the 2010 T In The Park Festival, Scotland's biggest music festival, held at Strathclyde Park in Balado near Kinross, Mckenzie admits that the major 'dramatic' scenes involving the leads, British actor Luke Treadaway playing an American musician, Adam (and having played a similar character in his debut, Brothers Of The Head), part of an electro-duo The Make, along with Morello (Natalia Tena - Nymphadora Tonks in the latter Harry Potters), the lead singer of a raucous all-girl band, The Dirty Pinks, were shot at the beginning of the film's five-day shoot at the festival, establishing the dramatic core around which the rest of the film was melded, with much of the rest being completely improvised, shooting as the pair, handcuffed together, wandered around, with the crowds and backstage at the festival. With the pair being shackled together by an eccentric passing preacher (Joseph Mydell - Manderlay) who gives them a brief lecture about peace and understanding, before making off, when he can't be found the pair have to try to get along while handcuffed, Morello having to play her festival set as such, and of course the ending is never in doubt that by the time the cuffs come off they'll be inseparable anyway, having shed a couple of unsuitable partners, Lake and Mark (Ruta Gedmintas from TV's Spooks: Code 9, and Alistair Mackenzie, the director's brother) along the way, a full-time result which has never been in doubt. Mackenzie's intention is obviously to capture the madness and hedonism of a massive festival, which largely succeeds, complete with a small role for the excellent singer / songwriter Newton Faulkner, but some have noted that, ironically in such a massive festival, the weakest bands on display are the fictional ones, The Make and The Dirty Pinks. Very different from the films which brought him to prominence, You Instead, an oddly oblique title referring to The Make's 'most popular' song, seems to be dividing audiences into two very separate camps, one accepting the film's good natured whimsy and formulaic plot and others hating every single frame and note.