Film details

This Must Be the Place  2011

Cast

Synopsis

Cheyanne, a former US rock star, now in his early fifties and living in Dublin, stopped performing at the height of his success when two fans committed suicide, claiming to be inspired to do so by his songs. He lives in rock star style in an isolated castle with his wife Jane, a former firefighter. Keeping to his image, he still has a huge goth hairstyle and wears elaborate make-up every day. He has befriended a loyal female fan, Mary, a teenage girl whose brother Tony has unexpectedly left him, causing great distress to their mother. Cheyanne tries to console her, but gets a call from upstate New York, hearing that his estranged father, a Holocaust survivor, has died. He discovers that in his later years his father had become obsessed with tracking down one of the camp officers, Aloise Lange, who he called the cruelest of the cruel, and was his main tormentor and who he believed became a US resident. After going to Mordecai Midler, a high profile and self-regarding hunter of Nazi war criminals, Midler refuses to get involved, Lange not being famous enough to warrant his time, causing Cheyanne to decide to find Lange on his own. Going to Utah, he discovered that Lange married, and his wife Dorothy was a high school teacher, he pretending to be one of her former pupils in order to find out more about her and their married life. Finding they have a daughter, Rachel. More deception takes him, via Rachel's young son, to discover the Langes are now living in New Mexico. Discovering the address, Cheyanne, having acquired a gun, travels, there, prepared to kill the man who tortured his father, but arrives at the location only to find an empty house, but Midler has also been investigating Lange, and is waiting for Cheyanne's visit. Giving him a lift, the Nazi hunter drives Cheyanne deep into the desert, where Lange, now old and infirm, clearly with little time left, lives alone. Cheyanne is ready to use his gun, but before executing Lange he wants to know exactly what happened, all those decades ago.

Production

Director
Paolo Sorrentino
Producer
Francesca Cima, Nicola Giuliano, Mario Spedaletti and Andrea Occhipinti
Art Director
dooner
Editor
Cristiano Travaglioli
Music
David Byrne, lyrics by Will Oldham
Screenplay
Paolo Sorrentino and Umberto Contrarello, based on a story by Paolo Sorrentino
Director of Photography
Luca Bigazzi

Review

Having made a clutch of remarkable Italian films, including The Consequences Of Love, The Family Friend and Il Divo, and being at the forefront of a surge in domestic Italian filmmaking, writer and director Paolo Sorrentino makes his English language debut with This Must Be The Place, but no one would have possibly guessed what that project would eventually turn out to be, a strange and sometimes slightly uncomfortable comedy / drama, with Sean Penn playing the central character, Cheyanne, a reclusive, retired and distinctly eccentric rockstar, living out his off-stage days outside Dublin, in a castle, naturally, like a more dissipated version of The Cure's Robert Smith, or perhaps Edward Scissorhands having a mid-life crisis. Although retired, and living with his wife, Jane (Frances McDormand - Fargo), he still has his hair resembling a fright wig and still applies the slap every day to keep up the image, which is perhaps Sorrentino's swipe at Cheyanne's own belief in his image. Surely retired rockers don't go round like this every day? What happens when Roy Wood goes to the shops, or any member of Kiss needs a pint of milk? More irritatingly, and a major misjudgment in the character, is that he talks in a strange, falsetto whisper, rather like the extremely irritating Antony Hegarty of Antony And The Johnsons. Reluctantly returning to the US after he hears his estranged father, who he has not seen for many years, has died, finding that the old man was increasingly obsessed in his later years with the concentration guard who had tormented him, but once there finds himself engaging on a rambling road trip, seeing the country and those he once knew now through the eyes of an outsider. Balancing comedy and drama, even if Penn's appearance truly horrendous, this is seems the last sort of thing one would Sorrentino to be involved with, his previous Italian pics being far more sombre and grave, and the film alternates between encounters with various eccentrics, and rather more serous meetings and situations. What would seem to be interesting dramatic possibilities, such as his meeting with a dedicated Nazi hunter, Midler (Judd Hirsch - TV's Num3ers), do not develop as one would expect, although Midler later reappears in a patience-stretching development, and the final release print has been altered from the version shown at Cannes, reducing considerably large swathes of voiceover by McDormand, seemingly there to make her character seem less of a completely spurious spare wheel. Being compared by some to David Byrne's fascinating collection of loosely linked vignettes True Stories, in that the plot often seem to be the clothes line on which various incidents are hung, Byrne is also one of the many unexpected cameos, in a cast list which includes Shea Whigham (Splinter / The Conspirator), Kerry Condon (the hugely underrated BBC drama Five Days), and veterans Joyce Van Patten (The Falcon And The Snowman), and Harry Dean Stanton, again apt casting since Paris, Texas also seems to be an influence. Sorrentino has made a film, the title referring to both a song by Byrne's Talking Heads as well as a jazz album by Dick Morrissey and Jim Mullen, which is both unexpected and somehow strangely conventional, Cheyanne seeming to finally shed himself of his rock star guise in the final scenes, as the quest to which he has devoted himself proves to be both anti-climatic and also an act of closure. An ambitious attempt by the director to break away completely from what he had previously been associated with, the film is certainly inventive but not entirely successful, making a number of bizarre decisions along the way, and it is to the director's credit that he manages to make an unbelievably irksome central character watchable for so long.