Film details

Bobby Fischer Against the World  2011

Cast

  • Bobby Fischer
  • Garry Kasparov
  • Susan Polgar
  • Larry Evans

Synopsis

A documentary about Bobby Fischer, the self-taught chess master who became a symbol of the Seventies Cold War in his landmark 1972 World Championship against Boris Spassky, but whose increasing eccentricity and hostility to America and everybody around him eventually turned him into a stateless nomad two decades later, and a wanted man. Born to his parents, Hans-Gerhardt Fischer and Regina, in 1943, his mother, a Communist activist, divorced her husband when her son was two years old. Leaving him alone or with his older sister Joan for long periods, Bobby started to read chess books and became a protege, remarkably becoming a grandmaster in 1958, aged only fourteen. Becoming a celebrity, his relationship with his mother, always awkward, becomes intolerably strained, and when he turns sixteen he moves out of their apartment, having learned that the man he believed was his father, Hans-Gerhardt, was not, his real father being Paul Nemenyi, a physicist and Hungarian Jew whom his mother had an affair with, and who died when Bobby was nine. His 1972 World Championship with Boris Spassky, held in Reykjavik, was one of the first matches to truly bring chess to the world audience, US networks interrupting their usual evening programming to bring live coverage, but Fischer's bizarre behaviour and eccentric demands escalated as the tournament wore on, Fischer claiming everything from the Russians using new prototype surveillance devices hidden in his chair to claims they were poisoning his food and water. His behaviour very nearly caused the Russians to walk away and abandon the entire tournament, but they relented, Fischer eventually winning 12 1/2 games to 8 1/2. It was the last time for two decades that Fischer would play chess in public. Becoming increasingly reclusive, he started to issue increasingly bizarre and violently anti-Semitic statements periodically, the chess world simultaneously trying to persuade him back but also keep him at arm's length. He made a surprise return to tournaments, re-emerging in September 1992 for a rematch with Spassky in Belgrade, deliberately breaking a UN embargo relating to the Balkan War and causing the US Government to issue an arrest warrant for him for breaching a specific Government-issued Executive Order for him not to participate. Fischer finally won by ten wins to five losses, with fifteen draws, winning the lion's share of the $5 million purse, $3.35 million, but then never played competitively again. He started to move between countries, living in Hungary, Germany and the Philippines, and Fischer then hit the headlines when he wrote an open letter of support to Osama Bin-Laden after the 9-11 attacks, and publicly destroyed his own American passport, essentially making him stateless, and having to apply for asylum in Iceland after being arrested in Japan in July 2004 and ordered to be deported. Bobby Fischer died in Reykjavik on January 17th, 2008.

Production

Director
Liz Garbus
Producer
Stanley F. Buchthal, Liz Garbus, Matthew Justus and Rory Kennedy
Editor
Michael Levine and Karen Schmeer
Music
Philip Sheppard
Director of Photography
Robert Chappell

Review

The late Bobby Fischer is certainly a perfect subject for a documentary, or indeed several volumes of psychiatric studies, and this profile of the extremely talented but also genuinely increasingly disturbed human being deals with the life of the man many experts and rival chessmasters regard as possibly the greatest ever player of the game, but a man who also became increasingly bizarre in his views and behaviour, escalating after he deliberately broke a UN embargo to play in a chess tournament in Belgrade, Yugoslavia in 1992, causing the US Government to issue an arrest warrant for him, and more predictably Fischer to become yet more extreme and anti-US in his views and statements, causing him to essentially become an exile, knowing he could be prosecuted if he ever returned and becoming a nomad, moving from country to country and making ever more egregious public pronouncements, and anti-Semitic statements which would make Mel Gibson sound like a Rabbi, all the more surprising since Fischer himself was of Jewish parentage, although the fact that he only discovered in later life the actual identity of his father, not being the man he had always believed, must have been a psychological shock. Fischer certainly made some milestones in the world of chess, his 1972 World Championship with Boris Spassky, held in Reykjavik, being the first time chess became a global event, and one interviewee remembers going into a bar in New York at the time and being amazed to find people actually watching it on the TV as they would baseball or gridiron. The archive photographs of the young Fischer show a surprisingly handsome young man, and for a while it was believed he was going to do well in high school sports, and those pictures of a fresh-faced, good looking Fischer contrast horrifyingly with the baleful, belligerent glare of his later years. Unfortunately there are so many myths and legends about Fischer that actually separating them from the truth becomes a difficult task, but his self-victimisation started very early in his life when in his late teens he claimed that no Russian grandmasters would meet him in a match, claiming that the major names were afraid of him, when in fact it was Fischer himself turning down the Russian overtures. There are obvious omissions, and the lack of any new input from Boris Spassky, apparently due to health issues, is regrettable, and certainly aspects of Fischer's tortuous later life, such as some unseemly paternity and inheritance issues are either skated around or simply ignored, and to some extent something like Liz Gardus' film, although superbly researched, is never going to be totally complete through the subject being dead, and being unable to defend or explain himself, since it would be fascinating to hear any explanation of the some of the more violent bile-filled rants, or the letter of support to Osama Bin-Laden. A life which is almost too fascinating and incident-packed to be contained in something feature-length, any sort of balance was always going to be hard to achieve, as while his achievements in the chess world are many, and bear out the impression of him being the greatest of all time, while his later life, bitter, angry and hate-filled as it was, and the messy squabbles over his estate, shouldn't be ignored, since to many it is the only side of Bobby Fischer they would have ever known.