Film details

Killing Them Softly  2012

Cogan's Trade

Cast

Synopsis

One of the most eagerly anticipated films at the 2012 Cannes Film Festival, Killing Them Softly reunites Brad Pitt with Andrew Dominik, the Australian helmer of the elegiac The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford, his first feature since that pic in 2007, and adapted from the very well regarded novel Cogan's Trade by the magnificent George V. Higgins, first published in 1974, was also one of the most talked-about not particularly for its' intrinsic quality but by the fact that it seemed so bifurcated, a tough crime thriller with an all-male central cast which also seemed to periodically diversify into semi-stultifying speeches concerning American politics, focusing on the asset-stripping and feather-bedding fiscal plans of the Republicans and the failed campaign promises of Barack Obama, which some found exhilarating and to others just confusing and anti-climatic. Updating the pic to the 2008 election, although the marketing images are strangely 70s indie, the first twenty minutes devote screen time to a pair of lowlife crooks, Russell (Ben Mendelsohn - Animal Kingdom) and Frankie (Scoot McNairy - Monsters), who have been involved in a heist on a Mafia-run and protected underground poker game, although several Mob grandees believe Markie (Ray Liotta - Goodfellas) is also involved, although he is wholly innocent. They set their toughest enforcer, Jackie Cogan (Pitt) on their trail although his mission is impeded by those who get in his way along the line, including a bitter and aging drunken hitman, several completely small-time local gangsters who believe themselves to be big Mob players and the man who was in charge of running the card game itself. Cannes critics were extremely mixed in opinion, some saying it was a fascinating mixture of noir and social statement, while others believed the statement was all too obviously hammered home, the final scenes in particular turning into sheer polemic, if wrapped up in a thriller guise, but the seriously strong cast, including Richard Jenkins (The Cabin In The Woods), Sam Shepard (Safe House / Blackthorn), James Gandolfini (TV's The Sopranos) and Garrett Dillahunt (Oliver Sherman), as well as the very provocative script would seem to make this one of the more interesting and controversial films of the year.

Production

Director
Andrew Dominik
Producer
Dede Gardner, Brad Pitt, Paula Mae Schwartz and Steve Schwartz
Editor
Brian A. Kates and John Paul Horstmann
Screenplay
Andrew Dominik, based on the novel by George V. Higgins
Director of Photography
Grieg Fraser

Review

A thriller which, while having all the standard tropes, from vengeful hitmen to small-time hoods realising they have robbed the wrong people when they hit a Mob-run high-stakes poker game, Killing Them Softly reunites Brad Pitt with Andrew Dominik, the Australian helmer of the elegiac The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford, his first feature since that pic in 2007, and adapted from the very well regarded novel Cogan's Trade by the magnificent George V. Higgins, first published in 1974. Instead of a straightforward thriller, Dominik has made a peculiar and fascinating hybrid, a 2012 pic with heavy echoes of the 70s, from the style of clothing, hairstyles and cars, but very consciously updating the pic to the 2008 election, constantly being referenced in radio ad and announcements, snatched glimpses of TV ads, and newspaper headlines, and Dominik is making an remarkably ambitious crime movie here by specifically tying it in with the American economy, the asset-stripping and feather-bedding fiscal plans of the Republicans and the eventually failed first campaign promises of Barack Obama, begin tied into the whole hive-like structure of the Mob, suggesting a corruption of American business from top to bottom, from the obviously commercial and high-profile to the very depths of the underworld. The first twenty minutes devote screen time to a pair of lowlife crooks, Russell (Ben Mendelsohn - Animal Kingdom) and Frankie (Scoot McNairy - Monsters), who carry out the heist on a Mafia-run and protected underground poker game, although several Mob grandees believe organiser Markie (Ray Liotta - Goodfellas) is also involved, although he is wholly innocent. They hire a hitman / enforcer, Jackie Cogan (Pitt), to track down the robbers, although his mission is impeded by those who get in his way along the line, including a bitter and aging drunken hitman, 'New York' Mickey, an interestingly vulnerable performance from Tony Soprano himself, James Gandolfini, several completely small-time local gangsters who believe themselves to be big Mob players and Johnny Amato (Vincent Curatola, another ex-Soprano), the dry cleaner behind the heist. Interestingly Dominik's approach is almost totally contrary to Higgins' own, whose novel The Friends Of Eddie Coyle, superbly filmed in 1973 by Peter Yates with Robert Mitchum in the lead, consisted entirely of dialogue, but was a compelling and gripping piece of a narrative. Here the director is layering everything with politicking, with endless election broadcasts almost becoming a layer of white noise behind the still-smart dialogue, and although containing a couple of surprisingly violent set-pieces, largely implies the violence, or visits it after the fact, and there is a bitter cynicism about almost everything it sees, such as the Mob character, listed in the credits on as 'driver' and played by the superb character actor Richard Jenkins (The Cabin In The Woods), Cogan's Mob contact and indistinguishable from any middle-mananger in any occupation anywhere in the world, and who delivers the final twist when Cogan has carried out the assignment and is waiting to be paid. Jenkins is also responsible the smart and clever scene where he explains how order has to be re-established and the public's minds put at rest, even in something as illegal as the poker game, to give the impression that everything is under control again, exactly the same argument a politician would give in any number of situations. The seriously strong cast includes Sam Shepard (Safe House / Blackthorn), Garrett Dillahunt (Oliver Sherman) and Trevor Long (Jack Goes Boating), and Dominik's film is dense and multi-layered, a fascinating piece of intelligent filmmaking which may annoy those looking for a more straightforward thriller / Mob movie, but one suspects that George V. Higgins himself, who sadly died in 1999, would very much approve.