Film details

The Five Year Engagement  2012

Cast

  • Jason Segel
  • Rhys Ifans
  • Alison Brie
  • Chris Pratt
  • Dakota Johnson
  • Kelvin Hart
  • Mindy Kaling
  • Mimi Kennedy
  • David Paymer
  • Jackie Weaver
  • Jim Piddock

Synopsis

Tom Solomon, a San Francisco chef with ambition and promise, proposes to his English girlfriend, Violet Barnes, who has just completed her PhD in psychology. As the two begin to start thinking about marriage, Violet's sister Susie, gets to the altar first, having been accidentally made pregnant by Alex Eilhauter, Tom's best friend. They decide to delay their own nuptials for a while, but find repeated obstacles suddenly appearing in their way from there on in. Finding she cannot pursue her studies at the local university, Violet is offered a place at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbour, Tom agreeing to postpone their wedding and also turning down a very promising job opportunity in order to follow her, and being forced to take a job at a down-market delicatessen. Violent continues her studies, specialising in the supposed psychological rewards of delayed gratification, and becoming close to her head of department, professor Winton Childs. Tom starts to lose both his ambition and self-respect, growing mutton-chop sideburns and generally not taking pride in his appearance any more, starting to think of himself as an outdoorsman rather than a talented chef. Fearing Tom is losing interest in her, even though they are still engaged, while on a drunken night out with Professor Childs, she kisses him. Having finally made a date for their wedding, she confesses to Tom about her tryst with Childs on the eve of the ceremony, he furiously storms out, breaking off their engagement. After having a fling with a co-worker at the deli, he moves back to San Francisco, finds a younger, insatiable girlfriend, Audrey, quickly moving in with her. Violet moves in with Childs, but both Tom and Violet know they have done the wrong thing. Time passes, and when Tom is invited to the funeral of Violet's last surviving grandparent, who he knew and liked, he knows she will be there, and wonders just how they will feel about each other when they eventually meet again.

Production

Director
Nicholas Stoller
Producer
Judd Apatow, Nicholas Stoller and Rodney Rothman
Art Director
John B. Josselyn
Editor
William Kerr and Peck Prior
Music
Michael Andrews
Screenplay
Jason Segel and Nicholas Stoller
Director of Photography
Javier Aguirresarobe

Review

Having made a couple of pretty unappealing comedies in the pair of Forgetting Sarah Marshall and Get Him To The Greek, director Nicholas Stoller decides to free himself from the embrace of Russell Brand and instead to concentrate on his writing partner and Marshall co-star Jason Segel, the undervalued comic actor who, also being responsible for the 2012 Muppets reboot, oddly plays the character with the christian name of Marshall in TV's seemingly endless How I Met Your Mother. The amiable Segal, who also has surprisingly deft comic timing, here finds himself involved in another matrimonial tale, which could almost be entitled What Happened In The Five Years After I Met Your Mother But Before We Got Married, but that might be a bit unwieldy on a poster, as Segal and Emily Blunt (The Young Victoria / The Adjustment Bureau) play an engaged couple, promising chef Tom and post-graduate psychology student Violet, whose marriage is first delayed after the rapid arrangement of her pregnant sister's wedding, then finding, as the title suggests, multiple obstacles in their way, the extended hiatus and move to Michegan from San Francisco, presumablydue to film rpoduction incentives ofgfered by Michigan, eventually driving the couple further apart, as Violet becomes more involved in her studies, and her choce of subject being delayed gratification is one of the more grindingly obvious gags, and Tom starts to feel less and less needed, his natural role usurped, he starting to lose first his ambition in the culinary field and then both his self-worth and self-respect. Produced by Judd Apatow but with less wearying reliance on pop culture and celebrity references as touchstones, and with a kinder appraoch to women in general, both Segal and Blunt are both talented and likeable company, the audience actually being drawn into their relationship, and finding themselves becoming unexpectedly involved when it seems as if nothing can actually save this relationship, which has not entirely proved itself worth saving, but one should remember the title, and as the film runs over two hours more than one critic has said that one feels as if one is going to get a blow-by-blow account of every month of every year, and Stoller could have been a bit more rigourous with the editing software, especially as, considering the stars and audience demographic, its' never actually concievable that the two are going to split up permanently. Vying for places on the invite list for the reception are a very mixed bunch, including Rhys Ifans (Notting Hill) as Violent's uncomfortably suave head of department, Alison Brie (TV's Mad Men), David Paymer (Redbelt / Drag Me To Hell) and Christopher Guest regular Jim Piddock, and the result, if overlong, is a Judd Apatow production which for once doesn't make one shudder with apprehension at the mere thought, a true accolade to Stoller and the underrated Segal.