Cast
-
-
-
Joanna Kulig
-
Samir Guesmi
-
Delphine Chuillot
-
Julie Papillon
-
Geoffrey Carey
-
Mamadou Minte
-
Mohamed Aroussi
-
Jean-Louis Cassarino
-
Judith Burnett
-
Marcela Iacub
Synopsis
The fourth feature by Polish-born, British-based filmmaker Paweł Pawlikowski, after the well received My Summer of Love and Last Resort, The Woman In The Fifth has been getting some exposure on the festival circuit and has been severely polarising opinion, dividing critics and audiences alike into two camps - those who believe it to be a complex, intricate work of art, and those who believe it is the most unbelievable old tosh possible, so one knows the accepted opinion will probably be somewhere between the two. Shot in Paris and based on a 2007 novel by Douglas Kennedy, writer of The Big Picture and The Pursuit of Happiness, with Ethan Hawke (Hamlet / Daybreakers) as Tom Ricks, an American college lecturer and writer who travels to Paris to try to get back together with his estranged wife and daughter. When this fails he stays in the city, living in a cheap and seedy hotel and working a bizarre job as night security guard, observing men on a monitor as they approach a door and, if they utter the correct phrase, Tom presses a button to admit them. He doesn't know who they are, where indeed the door leads to or why they have to thus identify themselves, but it all adds to the very off-kilter feel of the piece. The title character is Margit Kadara (French fixture Kristin Scott Thomas), a woman he meets at a social gathering for writers, she being fascinated that he's a novelist, albeit an unsuccessful one, while she has travelled all over the world and was a translator for her late Hungarian husband, also a writer. The other significant character is the barmaid at the hotel, Ania (Joanna Kulig - Hansel And Gretel: Witch Hunters) who takes an interest in Tom, developing a relationship with him as he travels to see Margit, check up on his wife and daughter discreetly, and spend night shifts at that bizarre job, which starts to develop distinctly sinister undertones. Tom starts to look more and more drained, and the audience is very much allowed to lose track of time, meaning they no longer know just how long Tom has been in Paris, living that gruelling and unsettling routine. Audiences have said that things develop in an unexpected way on almost all fronts of Tom's life, his relationship with the barmaid and Margit, and that damn job, as well as bringing in a series of murders, and Hawke gives a convincing performance as a man slowly falling apart as the audience watches, but the narrative apparently takes such unexpected turns, or perhaps completely expected to judge by some reviews, and some will completely accept the narrative or utterly reject it, which makes for a divisive experience but also one which at least gives the viewer something to talk about afterwards, and how many recent blockbusters can you also say that about.
Production
- Director
- Paweł Pawlikowski
- Producer
- Caroline Benjo and Carole Scotta
- Art Director
- Benoit Barouh
- Editor
- David Charap
- Music
- Max de Wardener
- Screenplay
- Paweł Pawlikowski, based on the book by Douglas Kennedy
- Director of Photography
- Ryszard Lenczewski
Review
The fourth feature by Polish-born, British-based filmmaker Paweł Pawlikowski, after the well received My Summer Of Love and Last Resort, The Woman In The Fifth is the sort of ambitious / pretentious (delete according to opinion) drama / fantasy which will divide viewers into two distinct and separate camps - those who believe it to be a complex, intricate work of suspense and deception, and those who believe it is quite remarkable tosh which cheats the audience by not revealing vital facts, causing one to remember the old caveat of paying your money etc. so one knows the accepted opinion will probably be somewhere between the two. Shot in Paris and based on a 2007 novel by Douglas Kennedy, writer of The Big Picture and The Pursuit Of Happiness, Ethan Hawke (Hamlet / Daybreakers) the central character, Tom Ricks, an American college lecturer and writer who travels to the French capital to try to get back together with his estranged wife and daughter, a task which fails and initially tips the viewer off that what Hicks may be accepting as reality may not be as such, seeing at the bafflement and confusion experienced by his wife, Natalie (Delphne Chuillot - A Perfect Couple / Mozart's Sister), Ricks obviously believing there is still some chance of reconciliation, where Natalie's reaction makes it clear that it is never going to happen. When this fails and he is robbed, convoluted circumstances see him living in a cheap and seedy hotel and working a bizarre job as a form of night security guard, observing men on a CCTV monitor, the details of which are never explained but it all adds to the very off-kilter feel of the piece. The title character is Margit (French fixture Kristin Scott Thomas), a woman he meets at a social gathering for writers, she being the widow of a writer, and his affair with her, as well as a dalliance with the mistress of a crime boss, who he also happens to be working for, come together when Ricks is arrested for the murder of another hotel resident. He starts to look more and more drained, and the audience is very much allowed to lose track of time, meaning they no longer know just how long Ricks has been in Paris, living that gruelling and unsettling routine but despite the film being what may be to some just wilfully confused, the script actually takes away several of the book's subplots, as well as the reason why Ricks is so keen to get out of the US, which one realises would only make things yet more confusing, and he comes across as a sinister character almost from the off, reduced to spying on his own child from behind trees in the park, When the final reel adds an plot twist which initially doesn't seem to have much to do with the rest of the script, one can start to believe that Ricks has indeed fooled everybody he has dealt with, until an ambiguous, cop-out ending. Hawke gives a convincing performance as a man slowly falling apart as the audience watches, his naturally gaunt features certainly helping, but the narrative takes such unexpected turns some will either accept it completely or dismiss it entirely, which is what some may feel about the entire enterprise.