Film details

J. Edgar  2011

Cast

  • Naomi Watts
  • Armie Hammer
  • Ed Westwick
  • Damon Herriman
  • Josh Lucas
  • Ken Howard
  • Lea Thompson
  • Stephen Root
  • Jeffrey Donovan
  • Miles Fisher
  • Dermot Mulroney
  • David A. Cooper
  • Amanda Schull

Synopsis

December 1963. John Edgar Hoover, known to all as J. Edgar, has been head of the FBI, known as the Bureau of Investigation until 1935, since 1924, a position he has attained and maintained through his ruthless and through gathering of sensitive information and secrets not only on suspected criminals, but also high-placed members of both the Democrat and Republican parties as well as other public officials and high-profile people. He is planning to bug the hotel room of civil rights leader Martin Luther King, who Hoover believes is a Communist with as he sees them dangerous political connections. Coming personally under fire from Robert Kennedy, the Attorney General, due to his inflexible and autocratic approach to law enforcement, Hoover decides to dictate his memoirs in order to tell his side of the story. 1924, and Hoover, then twenty-four years old and the deputy head of the Bureau, sees the house of the Attorney General, General A. Mitchell Palmer, become the target of an anarchist bomb. Hoover takes part in the operation against the anarchist cell, called The Palmer Raids, and is noticed for his zeal and determination, beginning his inexorable rise through the ranks of the Justice Department. Aided by his personal secretary, Helen Gandy, and wanting to impress Annie, his ailing but indomitable mother, Hoover starts to become involved in high profile publicity stunts, such as the promotion of the Bureau staff as 'G-Men', always catching their man and coming down hard on organised crime, emphasising the Communist threat in the Red Menace scares and publicity campaign, and is involved with the Lindbergh baby kidnapping case in 1935, securing a conviction which sees Bruno Hauptmann sent to the electric chair for the abduction and murder of the American aviation hero's infant. Hoover develops a close relationship with his Assistant Director, Clyde Tolson, which leads to gossip and rumour about the pair's relationship, although Hoover publicly is vehemently anti-homosexual, often saying that he believes the practise should be made illegal, with severe penalties. His mother dies in 1938, and he and Tolson's relationship becomes a frustrated, unconsummated love affair, although Hoover continues on his publicly anti-gay stance. He, Tolson and Gandy run the Bureau as a protectorate, allowing few others to become involved with policy or procedure, with Hoover amassing more and more wire-taps and bugged recordings to use against those he believes to be his enemies, particularly Presidents Harry S. Truman and John F. Kennedy, both of whom he believes will try to have him removed from the Bureau.Whenever opposition is raised against his autocratic rule, Hoover uses the FBI and its' resources to discredit or intimidate those who have protested. Hoover dies of a heart attack at home on May 2nd, 1972, aged 77. On the morning of his death Helen Gandy goes into his office and systematically starts to shred his personal files, a job which takes days, and of which afterwards she never spoke. At Hoover's state funeral, at which President Richard M. Nixon, the sixth President in Hoover's reign at the FBI, gives a eulogy, while privately volubly truly detesting the man and mocking his supposed sexuality, Clyde Tolson accepts the flag.

Production

Director
Clint Eastwood
Producer
Brian Grazer, Clint Eastwood and Robert Lorenz
Art Director
Patrick M. Sullivan Jr.
Editor
Joel Cox and Gary Roach
Music
Clint Eastwood
Screenplay
Dustin Lance Black
Director of Photography
Tom Stern

Review

After an already remarkable career, there's also no doubting that Clint Eastwood, at a time where most filmmakers would be putting their feet up and very possibly watching their old films obsessively, is directing some of the most interesting films coming out of the US, with even his misfires being far more intriguing and often more adventurous than almost anything else coming out of the major studios. J. Edgar has Leonardo DiCaprio as J. Edgar Hoover, the first Director of the newly formed FBI in 1935, the reign over what became his own particular fiefdom only ending with his death in 1972, Hoover was a truly notorious character and one who is still fiercely divisive today, with some believing he was a brilliant and impassioned lawman and others saying he was a thoroughly corrupt political manipulator, perfectly willing to bend any law to his own ends and also keeping thousands of files on those who he saw as opponents and enemies, many of them being politicians, which he used as blackmail and leverage. Although Eastwood's film is scripted by Dustin Lance Black (Oscar-winner for Milk), the writer being openly gay, this combination of writer and director, Eastwood being a well-known Republican although his stance has certainly softened in recent years, the film almost unbelievably almost avoids what can only be described as the elephant in the room, the long rumoured private life of the man who delved into the personal lives of so many others, with the accepted story now being that Hoover, who was publicly fearsomely anti-gay and 'pro-family', was a gay man with a taste for cross-dressing, and involved in a long-term relationship with Clyde Tolson (Armie Hammer - The Social Network), his protege and the first Assistant Director of the FBI. Indeed at Hoover's death Tolson inherited his estate and house and, in a truly eccentric twist, even accepted the flag at Hoover's state funeral. Equally interesting is the character of Helen Gandy (the superb Naomi Watts - King Kong), Hoover's personal secretary for a remarkable fifty-four years and who showed quite remarkable devotion to her bosses' memory, as well as breaking many federal laws, by shredding his entire archive after his death. But while these are three fascinating characters, the screenplay keeps the relationship between Hoover and Tolson amazingly chaste, Black stating that since there was little concrete about the relationship that could be proved, he prefers not to speculate, thus the bond between them, which lasted decades, is reduced to lingering glances and furrowed brows, an unconsummated, unrequited love, although many said that the pair had a genuinely domestic relationship when living together, and that the claims that Hoover was a crossdresser came from the 'fact' that he was the 'female' of the relationship while they were in private, images which, if one has seen the original Hoover, and DiCaprio even under layers of latex isn't as lumpen and bull-necked as the real man, is a hideous image. The pic follows Hoover from his first high-profile crime case, the kidnapping of Charles Lindbergh's baby and subsequent capture of the kidnapper, Bruno Hauptmann (Damon Herrimann - TV's Justified), then following his rise through the ranks, his command of the Bureau, and his political dealings, becoming very involved with Dwight D. Eisenhower (Gunnar Wright - The Losers), Robert F. Kennedy (Jeffrey Donovan - TV's Burn Notice), who became a personal enemy, and Richard Nixon (Christopher Shyer - The Core), on whom it was believed he has some very powerful blackmail material indeed. The excellent cast also includes Ed Westwick (TV's Gossip Girl), Josh Lucas (The Lincoln Lawyer), Lea Thompson (TV's Jane Doe series). Dermot Mulroney (Flash Of Genius), Stephen Root (Red State), Ken Howard (Rambo), and a little surprisingly, as Hoover's manipulative mother, Judi Dench. The power Hoover held could be seen in the case of the maverick filmmaker Larry Cohen, who made the terrific 1977 pic The Private Files Of J. Edgar Hoover, with Broderick Crawford in the lead role, and very much being the first to cover a lot of the speculations about the man, who had died five years earlier, but Cohen's film found it hard to get bookings, being very rarely seen in the US with the rumour that the FBI had put pressure on cinema chains not to show the film, Hoover's shadow still looming long over the Bureau even then. Eastwood's direction is faultless, the period recreation superb and Di Caprio gives a compelling performance as the central character, although in later years even excellent prosthetics, by Sian Grigg and Duncan Jarman, cannot quite convince one that this 37 year-old actor is in fact an ailing and corpulent man in his late sixties, J. Edgar is splendidly mounted and played, with Di Caprio and Watts being particularly impressive, but its' odd reverence towards both its subject and only the strictly acknowledged details of his life mean that the opportunity to make a more insightful film has perhaps been lost.