Cast
-
-
-
-
-
Viola Davis
-
Thomas Horn
-
-
Adrian Martinez
-
Carmen M. Herlihy
-
Zoe Caldwell
-
Jenson Smith
-
Stephen McKinley Henderson
Synopsis
Based on the 2005 bestselling novel by the acclaimed Jonathan Safran Foer (Everything Is Illustrated, also made into a strange and unfocused film adaptation), Extremely Loud And Incredibly Close boasts a top-flight director in the form of Stephen Daldry (Billy Elliott / The Hours), and an excellent cast, but the subject matter, fitting into that strange sub-genre of 9-11 fiction, plus Foer's own quasi-magic realism style make this a difficult proposition, with the possibility of becoming either too whimsical or too overwhelmingly serious and sentimental. Either way, screenwriter Eric Roth (Forrest Gump / Munich / The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button) has a challenge on his hand in transferring this to the screen, the evocative title coming from one eye witnesses' description of seeing one of the hijacked planes flying overhead before the fateful impact with the WTC. The central character is Oskar Schell (Thomas Horn, making his screen debut after success on a US TV kid's quiz show), somewhat worryingly described in the synopsis as 'an amateur inventor, jewelry designer, astrophysisist, tambourine player and pacifist', which makes him sound utterly unbearable, but whose father, played in flashback by Tom Hanks, was killed in the attacks on the World Trade Center. Oskar has become increasingly distanced from his mother (Sandra Bullock - The Blind Side), and has a vivid and active imagination, convincing himself that his father left him a special message, hidden somewhere in the city, and finding a key in his father's closet, which doesn't seem to open anything in the house, starts to search the city for the lock which the key fits. Of course the search becomes a quest which gives him a greater understanding of the disaster which has happened around him, and makes him realise that he is not the only one who has been hurt by it. The undeniably strong cast includes John Goodman (The Big Lebowski), Viola Davis (Eat Pray Love), Max Von Sydow (The Seventh Seal / Sleepless), James Gandolfini (TV's The Sopranos) and Jeffrey Wright (Felix Leiter to Daniel Craig's 007). No one is doubting that Foer's book was written with sincerity, but what works so well on the written page, as seen with Illustrated, doesn't always transfer to the visual medium.
Production
- Director
- Stephen Daldry
- Producer
- Scott Rudin
- Art Director
- Peter Rogness
- Editor
- Claire Simpson
- Music
- Nico Muhly
- Screenplay
- Eric Roth, based on the novel by Jonathan Safran Foer
- Director of Photography
- Chris Menges
Review
Based on the 2005 bestselling novel by the acclaimed Jonathan Safran Foer (Everything Is Illustrated, itself made into a strange and unfocused film adaptation), Extremely Loud And Incredibly Close boasts a top-flight director in the form of Stephen Daldry (Billy Elliott / The Hours), and an excellent cast, but the subject matter, fitting into that strange sub-genre of 9-11 fiction, plus Foer's own quasi-magic realism style make this a difficult proposition, and the reviews in the US some of which could barely contain their genuine ire at such a film being made over a decade after the events which inspired it, show that the US is still largely unable to handle any film which handles the events of 9/11 in anything less than the most reverent tones. Screenwriter Eric Roth (Forrest Gump / Munich / The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button) always had a challenge on his hand in transferring this to the screen, the evocative title coming from one eye witnesses' description of seeing one of the hijacked 747s flying overhead before the fateful impact with the WTC, but in the turning of the aftermath into the story of one bereaved child's quest to discover what he, perhaps autistically, believes to be the final mystery his father left him, he and the film opens itself up to ridicule and genuine anger. The central character is Oskar Schell (Thomas Horn, a non-professional making his screen debut after success on a US TV kid's quiz show), described in the book's blurb as 'an amateur inventor, jewellary designer, astrophysicist, tambourine player and pacifist', which makes him sound utterly unbearable, but whose father, Thomas, played in flashbacks by Tom Hanks, taught him not to accept facts at face value, and to investigate and probe all he is told, an interesting 9/11 skeptics parallel. Thomas is killed in the attacks on the World Trade Centre. Oskar becomes increasingly distanced from his mother (Sandra Bullock - The Blind Side), convincing himself that his father left him a special message, hidden somewhere in the city, through finding a key in his father's closet, starts to search the city for the lock which the key fits. Of course the search becomes a quest which, eventually, gives him a greater understanding of the disaster which has happened around him, and makes him realise that he is not the only one who has been hurt by it, but it is perhaps the incidence, Oskar meeting a number of almost obviously off-kilter characters, one of whom, played by the superb Max Von Sydow (The Seventh Seal / Sleepless), who earned an Oscar nomination as his estranged, mute grandfather, which perhaps angered some, the tragedy of the Twin Towers being a starting-off point for the semi-whimsical journey of a not particularly likable youngster. There is an undeniably strong supporting cast, which includes John Goodman (The Big Lebowski), Viola Davis (Eat Pray Love), and Jeffrey Wright (Felix Leiter to Daniel Craig's 007), although scenes involving James Gandolfini (TV's The Sopranos) as a therapist trying to deal with Oskar and his reticent nature were deleted after previews in the US. No one is doubting that Foer's book was written with sincerity, but what works so well on the written page, as seen with Illustrated, doesn't always transfer to the visual medium, and despite the very best and very sincere efforts of director Daldry, who earned the remarkable accolade of earning three Best Director Oscar nominations with his first three features, Extremely Loud And Incredibly Close has touched nerves in the US which some Americans have found hard to cope with, despite being deferential to the real events to an almost reverential degree.