Cast
-
Abbie Cornish
-
James D'Arcy
-
Andrea Riseborough
-
Richard Coyle
-
Annabelle Wallis
-
Oscar Isaac
-
Natalie Dormer
-
Laurence Fox
-
-
David Harbour
-
Natalie Gal
-
Haluk Bilginer
Synopsis
Her first directorial outing, 2008's Filth And Wisdom, was essentially unreleased, being called by the few critics who saw it on its' few festival and art exhibition screenings little more than an expensive and disjointed vanity project, Madonna, who is apparently a film director now, probably wishes her second feature W.E., remained unseen as well after the utter lambasting it received when finally unveiled at the 2011 Venice Film Festival. Co-written by Alex Keshishian, who helmed the fawning hagiography In Bed With Madonna two decades ago, and also directed a couple of her pop videos, the film essentially tells two stories, the real-life one of the momentous relationship between King Edward VIII (James D'Arcy - Flashbacks Of A Fool) and American divorcee Wallis Simpson (Andrea Riseborough - the Brighton Rock remake), he eventually abdicating the throne for the woman he loved, and a contemporary one, six decades later, concerning the bizarrely-named Wally Winthrop (the excellent Abbie Cornish - Candy / Bright Star), a New Yorker, married to a wealthy psychiatrist (Richard Coyle - The Libertine) in scenes set in 1998, and who has given up her job at Sotheby's auction house in order to get pregnant, although so far has failed. She becomes obsessed with the story of Edward and Wallis, piqued when the jewellery which Wallis had, the Windsor Estate, is put up for auction in Sotheby's, and as she does her own research into the pair's relationship, finds that their life after they essentially went into exile in France was not as blissfully happy as everyone believed, despite the massive amount of books, papers and academic research already carried out on the pair, and incredibly their story seems to completely mirror her and her husband's, so much so that trade paper Variety were prompted to point out 'if [the film] were prose, it would be italicised and in bold caps, so banally does it transpose events in Wally and Wallis' lives', and while some critics agreed that the Edward and Wallis side of the story was reasonably well done, mostly because of the remarkable story, the other half of the film was completely uninvolving when it wasn't verging on the ludicrous, and Madonna seems to have done something remarkable with an actress of Abbie Cornish's talent, Variety calling her performance 'almost catatonic', which really is an achievement, although not a particularly impressive one. Critics really laid in, with some also complaining about the technical side, filmed on 8 and 16mm transferred to 35mm, some sequences looking like outtakes of a beginner's pop video, and some unexpected thanks in the final credit scroll including now-disgraced fashion designer John Galliano and even Nazi filmmaker Leni Riefenstahl, which seems to be an unfortunate combination of names at best. With a cast which includes the redoubtable Geoffrey Palmer as PM Stanley Baldwin, James Fox (Performance / Sexy Beast) as King George V, Judy Parfitt (Wilde) as Queen Mary and the gorgeous Natalie Dormer (Captain America) as Elisabeth Bowes-Lyon, much later to be the Queen Mother, one has to wonder who the actual audience is for this, since The King's Speech crowd won't be interested given the Madonna connection, and her fans are not going to be that interested in something their idol does not appear in, and the Venice reviews may be the final blow.
Production
- Director
- Madonna
- Producer
- Kris Thykler and Madonna
- Art Director
- Mark Raggett (supervisor)
- Editor
- Danny B. Tull
- Music
- Abel Korzeniowski
- Screenplay
- Alex Keshishian and Madonna
- Director of Photography
- Hagen Bogdanski
Review
Her first directorial outing, 2008's Filth And Wisdom, was essentially unreleased, being called by the few critics who saw it on its' festival and art exhibition screenings little more than an expensive and disjointed vanity project, and Madonna at least received slightly better reviews for this, which can be seen as her genuine first feature, although to be strictly fair it wouldn't have been particularly hard to exceed those of F And W, and neither should she be hailed as some sort of filmmaking discovery, the likes of Scorsese and Spielberg not having to worry about their positions in the pantheon of great filmmakers just yet. Co-written by Alex Keshishian, who helmed the fawning hagiography In Bed With Madonna two decades ago, and also directed a couple of her pop videos, the film essentially tells two stories, the real-life one of the momentous relationship between King Edward VIII (James D'Arcy - Flashbacks Of A Fool) and American divorcee Wallis Simpson (Andrea Riseborough - the Brighton Rock remake), he eventually abdicating the throne for woman he loved, and a contemporary one, six decades later, concerning the bizarrely-named Wally Winthrop (the excellent Abbie Cornish - Candy / Bright Star), a New Yorker, married to a wealthy psychiatrist (Richard Coyle - The Libertine) in scenes set in 1998, and who has given up her job at Sotheby's auction house in order to get pregnant, although so far has failed. She becomes obsessed with the story of Edward and Wallis, piqued when Wallis' jewellery, the Windsor Estate, is put up for auction at Sotheby's, and the two timelines run together as her life, in an unbelievably contrived way, starts to parallel that of Wallis and Simpson, and does so increasingly obviously, to the point of having the dazzling Cornish wear her hair in that slicked down, dyed-black style which became a Wallis trademark, and Madonna seems to have done something remarkable with an actress of Abbie Cornish's talent, having her give a performance in which at times she seems virtually catatonic, or at least slightly retarded, and as the film progresses, less and less of what she does is convincing, from her awkward relationship with security guard Evgeni (Oscar Isaac - Sucker Punch / Drive) to a meeting with Mohammed Al Fayed, who owns some of Wallis' letters, and British viewers are going to have a damn good chortle when the character arrives on screen, portrayed by Turkish actor Haluk Bilginer, and being rather taller, slimmer and more dignified than the real thing. The technical side is a melange, some scenes filmed on 8 and 16mm transferred to 35mm, some sequences looking like outtakes of a beginner's pop video, with an anachronistic scene of Wallis dancing to PiL's Pretty Vacant only reminding one of the similar use of music in Sofia Coppola's far more assured Marie Antoinette, and there are some unexpected thanks in the final credit scroll including now-disgraced fashion designer John Galliano and even unrepentant Nazi filmmaker Leni Riefenstahl, which seem to be unfortunate choices at best. With a cast which includes the redoubtable Geoffrey Palmer as PM Stanley Baldwin, James Fox (Performance / Sexy Beast) as King George V, Judy Parfitt (Wilde) as Queen Mary and the gorgeous Natalie Dormer (Captain America) as Elisabeth Bowes-Lyon, much later to be the Queen Mother, one has to wonder who the actual audience is for this, since The King's Speech crowd won't be interested given the Madonna connection, and her fans are not going to be that interested in something their idol does not appear in, and for something which claims to be so thoroughly researched there are some terrible errors, such as events in the life of George III being confused on a number of occasions with George V, and even getting the final resting places of Edward and Wallis wrong come the end. At times resembling nothing more than an extended perfume commercial in the period scenes, one has to suspect that instead of the redundant story of the enormously annoying Wally, whose very name is a plot contrivance, Madonna should perhaps just stuck with the tale of Edward and Wallis, since combining the pair only diminishes rather than enhances the two very different stories.