Cast
-
Freida Pinto
-
Riz Ahmed
-
Roshan Seth
-
Kalki Koechlin
-
Anuraq Kashyap
-
Neet Mohan
-
Aakask Dahiya
-
Harish Khanna
-
Leena Madhauram
-
Lakshman Madhauram
-
Pratiksha Singh
-
Sam Hastings
Synopsis
Jay, the British-raised son of an Indian father and English mother, is touring the Indian region of Rajasthan with three friends when they stop at Stopping at a small village he notices a young woman, Trishna, dancing at their hotel, and strikes up a conversation with her. The next morning Trishna is helping her father load vegetables onto their jeep to take to market, but when they are on the raid the jeep collides with a truck after her exhausted father falls asleep at the wheel. Trishna breaks her arm and her father is seriously injured. Jay hears of what has happened just as he and his party are about to leave the village, and realises that Trishna's family are now on the verge of ruin. He offers her a job at a hotel near Jaipur, one of the many owned by his father, a business magnate and property developer. Trishna accepts the job, becoming a waitress at the hotel, where Jay also lives. Jay's father, who is blind, arrives from London and has a meeting with Jay, urging him to focus on his future and follow him into the hotel business. His father returns to London, and Jay suggests to Trishna that she should take a course in hotel management. Jay rescues her from being threatened by a pair of aggressive youths while she is returning from a wedding, taking her away on his scooter, and on the way back to the hotel they stop in the woods and make love. Trishna is stricken by guilt over what she has done, and the next days leaves the hotel, returning to her home village. Weeks later she discovers she is pregnant, and is pressured by her father into having an abortion. Jay, who has moved into film production, tracks her down, and invites her to come to live with him in Mumbai. The relationship blossoms, and Trishna starts to believe that they have a future together, being captivated by the social whirl and high society of the city, but Jay's father has a stroke and he is summoned to London. As he prepares to leave, Trishna tells him of her pregnancy and abortion, which he takes badly. When he returns from London he seems to be a changed man, and moves her to another hotel, telling him that in order to stay she has to become an employee again so as to avoid scandal. With Trishna forced to work as little more than a servant, and Jay's treatment of her becoming ever more callous and degrading, the mixed passions between them drive Trishna to a desperate act....
Production
- Director
- Michael Winterbottom
- Producer
- Melissa Parmenter and Michael Winterbottom
- Art Director
- David Bryan
- Editor
- Mags Arnold
- Music
- Shigeru Umegayashi, songs by Amit Trivedi
- Screenplay
- Michael Winterbottom, based on the novel Tess Of The d'Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy
- Director of Photography
- Marcel Zyskind
Review
One can usually rely on Michael Winterbottom doing the unexpected, such as making a modern-day love story which was largely concert footage interspersed with hardcore sex scenes, wonder who saw that coming, or an equally gritty film noir in The Killer Inside Me which was so genuine and true to the book on which it was based that it actually shocked some viewers and appalled more than a few critics merely through putting onto the screen what was always on the printed page rather than producing some sort of stylised romanticised pastiche. Trishna is also a decided left turn, adapting the classic 1891 novel Tess Of The d'Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy to modern-day India, in a move which is not exactly all that original, since Gurinda Chadha did much the same with Bride And Prejudice back in 2004, and which didn't exactly ignite the planet. Late Nineteenth Century Wessex instead becomes Rajasthan, where Jay (Riz Ahmed - Four Lions / Centurion), the son of a wealthy property developer, goes to work on one of his father's latest properties, a heritage hotel. There he meets Trishna (Freida Pinto - Slumdog Millionaire), the beautiful daughter of a local driver, when her father is hurt in an accident and unable to work, Jay offers her a job at the hotel and the two predictably fall in love. Those familiar with the novel, or indeed the remarkably faithful and evocative film version by Roman Polanski, will be surprised that Winterbottom, apart from shifting continent and period, makes a genuinely seismic change in amalgamating two central characters, Jay being an amalgam of both Angel Clare, the man she falls in love with, and the villainous squire Alec d'Urbanville, who forces himself upon Tess and makes her pregnant, and as those who have read the book will know, it certainly doesn't have a happy ending, which must have come as a genuine shock when Hardy first published his book, and Winterbottom, although keeping to the spirit of the tale, alters the details if not the overall outcome. The problem with the approach is that it not only makes the character suddenly inexplicable in his sudden and utter volte-face, going from a kid and compassionate lover to a snarling, cruel psychopath, who suddenly seems to want to degrade and abuse Trishna in every possible way, Winterbottom also hinting heavily at various brutal sexual shenanigans. But for such a transformation to be convincing one needs a very talented actor, and frankly Riz Ahmed isn't as versatile as the Jekyll / Hyde character needs to be convincing, or even credible, and in some ways his portrayal is so broad and villainous that it almost returns the film to the lurid melodramas of the time in which the book was written. It should be said that this is the third time Winterbottom has adapted Hardy, firstly with his 1996 Jude, taken from Jude The Obscure, and 2000's The Claim, which transposed The Mayor Of Casterbridge to California during the Gold Rush, but the problem doing anything sort of updating like this is that critics so often damn the project with faint praise, referring the viewer back to the original work, which makes some believe however good the film is, Winterbottom is in no position to win. Photographed by his regular DoP Marcel Zyskind, the film manages to capture perfectly both the placid plains of Rajasthan and the bustling, frantic streets of Jaipur and Mumbai, showing both sides of modern-day India, and the bridge in Indian society which trishna attempts to cross. Winterbottom has to be praised for his refusal to stick within any particular genre or film conventions, yet seems to be constantly unappreciated, but his adventurous attitude is to be admired even when the results can be so inconsistent.