Cast
-
Anna Paquin
-
-
Mark Ruffalo
-
-
J. Smith-Cameron
-
-
Olivia Thirlby
-
Kieran Culkin
-
Rosemarie DeWitt
-
Allison Janney
-
Krysten Ritter
-
Matt Bush
Synopsis
2005. Lisa Cohen, a seventeen-year-old student living in Manhattan with her divorced mother, Joan, a stage actress, the pair being close even though their relationship is sometimes difficult. One the street one day Lisa distracts a bus driver who goes through a red light, killing a pedestrian, Monica Patterson. Hearing the driver, Maretti, may lose his job because of the accident, Lisa makes a statement to the Police insisting the traffic light was green, the driver going along with her claim. Joan starts to date Ramon, a successful businessman with a love of opera. Still hurt and conflicted about the accident, Lisa starts to see one of her teachers, geometry tutor Mr. Aaron, outside school hours in order to talk about it. Although knowing one of her classmates is besotted with her, Lisa instead gives up her virginity to another student who has a reputation as a ladies' man. Wanting to apologise to Monica Patterson's family, Lisa contacts a cousin, Abigail, who was estranged from Monica and isn't interested, but points her towards Emily, Monica's best friend. Starting to be tormented by her guilt, she asks Maretti to go to the Police, but he refuses. She amends her own statement to imply that Maretti was driving recklessly, but finds he still won't face charges. Going to Emily, the pair agree to work together on a civil suit against Maretti, but when Lisa's two conflicting statements are revealed the suit is thrown out. Investigating his employment records, the pair discover that Maretti had previously been disciplined for careless driving, so sue the bus company, claiming that he was unfit and should have been fired. The bus company, wanting to avoid more adverse publicity, decide to settle out of court, but after the decision Lisa becomes furious that the company decide to keep Maretti as a driver and the damages are awarded entirely to Abigail. Meeting Mr. Aaron to talk about how the case has gone, Lisa deliberately seduces him. Making a decision about her future, and believing that her mother is getting more and more seriously involved with Ramon, Lisa tells Joan that she plans to leave New York and goes to live with her father in California, but shortly afterwards Ramon has a sudden and fatal heart attack. After receiving a phone call from her father, in which he tells her she can't live with him and not to move to California, Lisa realises that she has more bad news to deliver to those she knows, and how nothing can be the same ever again and has to change.
Production
- Director
- Kenneth Lonergan
- Producer
- Sydney Pollack, Scott Rudin and Gary Gilbert
- Art Director
- James Donohue
- Editor
- Anne McCabe
- Music
- Nico Muhly
- Screenplay
- Kenneth Lonergan
- Director of Photography
- Ryszard Lenczewski
Review
That Kenneth Lonergan's Margaret is getting released at all is coming as somewhat of a surprise to some in the industry, since the film was actually declared 'unreleaseable' in early 2009 due to the ongoing problems Lonergan, helming only his second feature after 2000's very well received You Can Count On Me, was facing during an extended editing process, including lawsuits from both Fox Searchlight, who sued a financier on the film through his not paying the expected production costs, and one of the film's financiers, Gary Gilbert, suing Lonergan for refusing his 'help' during the editing process, even though the director was being assisted and advised by the likes of Martin Scorsese, Martha Schoonmaker and Sydney Pollack, Pollack being one of the producers, and the fact that he died in mid-2008 indicates how old the film actually is, Margaret being shot between September and November 2005, and has been in post-production hell ever since. Indeed when Lonergan found both Fox and Gilbert refusing to pay for any more of the post-production, it was one of his friends, Matthew Broderick, who has a small role and who continued to pay to have the film worked on and not just be abandoned. After all this the finished article is still somewhat of a compromise, coming at a few seconds under 150 minutes, as per one of the production contracts although it is known that Lonergan wanted to release a longer version but was forced to edit his own final cut. The premise is certainly promising, with Anna Pacquin (The Piano / TV's True Blood) playing Lisa Cohen, a 17-year-old New York City high-school student who inadvertently causes a traffic accident in which a woman is killed, hit by the bus whose driver, Maretti (Mark Ruffalo, returning from You Can Count...), she distracted shortly before he jumped a red light. She is determined to set things, right, to find forgiveness and redemption, not to put too fine a point on it, but finds her efforts to apologise and make amends repeatedly blocked. When she tries to contact the deceased's family she is rebuffed and passed onto a friend, and when she decides to stand up for the bus driver finds that he has far from a perfect record and perhaps should not have been driving had the company been more diligent. She is also desperate to find some sort of approval from those around her, she and her mother having an uncomfortable relationship and her plans to live with her father in California also end in failure. Informal out-of-hours meetings with a sympathetic teacher, played by a surprisingly young-looking Matt Damon, which begins as an attempt to give her emotional support but, is soon turned, by her own instigation, into something dangerous and damaging to both of them. The cast is almost perversely eclectic, including Allison Janney (TV's The West Wing), Olivia Thirlby (No Strings Attached), Rosemarie De Witt (A Little Bit Of Heaven), Kieran Culkin (Lymelife) and the peerless Jean Reno, playing the suave opera-loving Ramon, someone else Lisa sees as an interloper in her already difficult relationship with her mother. With one probably never able to see Lonergan's complete version, the film being given marginal releases in both the US and UK, probably to fulfil contractual obligations and also 'punish' Lonergan for trying to exert his artistic freedom, what remains is often as gripping as it is at times irritating and it is clear that some characters, particular Damon's teacher and Reno's suitor have had their scenes at least pruned. It remains even in this version a fascinating and absorbing drama but its' ambitions also mean that it certainly isn't an easy film to watch, but a complex, brave and fiercely intelligent drama which deals with a lot of difficult subjects, from guilt and culpability to the error of mistaking sex for affection, and some will find it too rugged and over-stuffed to comfortably deal with. Sadly Lonergan's film may now only be seen through the prism of the extraordinarily extended production period and the off-screen problems, but You Can Count On Me attracted a lot of admiration and many discerning filmgoers will very much want to know how Lonergan followed it up, even if it took rather longer and was a much more agonizing journey than one would originally thought.