Film details

Hyde Park on Hudson  2012

Hyde Park on The Hudson

Cast

Synopsis

Scriptwriter Richard Nelson, adapting his own radio play, Hyde Park On Hudson, takes a number of genuine events, notably the secret love affair between President Franklin D.Roosevelt and his distant cousin Margaret Stuckley, centered around the weekend in 1939 when King George VI and Queen Elizabeth visited Roosevelt's upstate Hyde Park estate, New York, trying to secure American support on the brink of World War II, which was to break out only three months later, but this comedy / drama, interestingly shot in England by director Roger Michell (Notting Hill / Venus) has been attacked on a number of fronts, by some critics who believe this so much wants to be seen as some sort of follow-up The King's Speech, and presumably as award-winning, that its' almost embarrassing how obvious this is, and also for the central performance by Bill Murray, his first film lead since Jim Jarmusch's Broken Flowers, seven years ago, and which has been called eccentric by some and completely unbelievable by others, Murray giving a performance beset with quirks and odd mannerisms, when the man himself was a fascinating and individual character who really doesn't need Murray trying to turn him into some sort of eccentric clown, and whom Murray in no way resembles. The film is told in part from the perspective of Margaret 'Daisy' Stuckley (Laura Linney - Kinsey / TV's The C Word), FDR's distant cousin and confidante, with whom he began an affair while married to the formidable Eleanor, and the weekend was part of the efforts the King (played here by Samuel West, in a rare film appearance away from the stage) to try to persuade the USA to enter the War, which of course anybody with anything like a grasp of history knows did not happen for a number of years after the heavy lifting had been done, but very little background is actually given, with little being explained about any character or their relationships being given. Disappointingly the general opinion is also that when Murray stops clowning around, a pivotal scene with just FDR and the King, the crux of the film as the elderly, veteran politician tries to advise the young and callow King, is actually extremely good, and almost seems to be from a different film entirely. Most of the rest of the cast have been getting plaudits, from the always excellent Olivia Colman (Tyrannosaur) as the Queen, later to be The Queen Mother, and Olivia Williams (An Education / Hanna) as Eleanor Roosevelt, Michell has gone on record saying how he spent a year pursuing Murray for the film, and also of how his presence on set was sometimes, shall we say, disruptive, but oddly it is Murray who seems to be getting most of the brickbats, and one wonders how the film would have been with another, more controllable actor in the lead.

Production

Director
Roger Michell
Producer
Kevin Loader, Roger Michell and David Aukin
Art Director
Mark Raggett (supervisor)
Editor
Nicolas Gaster
Music
Jeremy Sams
Screenplay
Richard Nelson, adapted from his radio play
Director of Photography
Lol Crawley

Review

In what is inevitably going to be seen as some sort of belated sequel / cash-in to The King's Speech, scriptwriter Richard Nelson, adapting his own radio play, Hyde Park On Hudson, takes a number of genuine events, notably the secret love affair between President Franklin D. Roosevelt and his distant cousin Margaret Stuckley, centered around the weekend in 1939 when King George VI and Queen Elizabeth visited Roosevelt's upstate Hyde Park estate, New York, trying to secure American support on the brink of World War II, which was to break out only three months later, but while Nelson insists he was working on his own script long before the multi-Oscar-winner went into production, it is the approach of Hyde Park which most obviously distances it from its' more successful and assured predecessor. A comedy / drama based on real events, several of which were covered up at the time, and interestingly shot in England by director Roger Michell (Notting Hill / Venus), the film's central performance by Bill Murray, his first film lead since Jim Jarmusch's Broken Flowers, seven years earlier, as President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and the approach Murray takes to this fascinating, complicated man, who it should be remembered was largely crippled by childhood polio and was mostly wheelchair-bound, but in a remarkable detail of history, had an agreement with the American press not to print photographs of him in the wheelchair, just seated at desks or functions, showing a completely different to both politics and the press, something which would never be agreed upon today and would more be exploited by the press for their own political ends, and instead gives a performance which some may think eccentric by some and others completely unbelievable by others, Murray giving a performance beset with quirks and odd mannerisms, when the man himself was a fascinating and individual character who really doesn't need Murray trying to turn him into some sort of eccentric clown, and whom the actor in no way resembles. The film is told in part from the perspective of Margaret 'Daisy' Stuckley (Laura Linney - Kinsey / TV's The C Word), FDR's distant cousin and confidante, with whom he began an affair while married to the formidable Eleanor (Olivia Williams - An Education / Hanna), and the weekend was part of the efforts the King (played here by Samuel West, in a rare film appearance away from the stage) to try to persuade the USA to enter the War, which of course anybody with anything like a grasp of history knows eventually did not happen for a number of years after the heavy lifting had been done, but too little background is actually given, and certain elements, such as Daisy's discovery that she is just one of a number of women in FDR's life, including his secretary Kitty (Elizabeth Marvel - The Bourne Legacy / TV's Person Of Interest), may be true, but would he really be having affairs with two women on his own estate under the nose of his wife, even if the decorous treatment of daisy, shall we say, pleasuring the head of state in a car is discreet and undeniably funny, which is probably Michell's intention. When Murray stops clowning around, a pivotal scene with just FDR and the King, the crux of the film as the elderly, veteran politician tries to advise the young and callow King, both men having had to struggle against their own personal disabilities all their lives, is actually extremely good, and almost seems to be from a different film entirely. The cast are undeniably impressive, from the always excellent Olivia Colman (Tyrannosaur) as the Queen, later to be The Queen Mother, and the superb Eleanor Bron (the original magnificent Bedazzled), and the stagings, set design and art direction are all exemplary, the film being almost at times a more-comedicly adjunct to the gravity of The King's Speech, but which also means that West and Colman are struggling against better known recent interpretations of the same roles. Michell has gone on record saying how he spent a year pursuing Murray for the film, and also of how his presence on set was sometimes, shall we say, disruptive, but one has to wonder how the film would have been with another, more controllable actor in the lead.