Film details

Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger!  2012

Nativity 2: The Second Coming

Cast

  • David Tennant
  • Pam Ferris
  • Joanna Page
  • Ian McNiece
  • Ben Wilby
  • Wesley Udall
  • Alexander McGowan
  • Thomas Alinge
  • David Scullion
  • Rowan Evans

Synopsis

At the underachieving St. Bernadette's Primary School in the Midlands, supply teacher Donald Peterson struggles to deal with his rumbunctious, irrepressible pupils and his loose cannon classroom assistant, the flamboyant, loud and equally exhausting Mr Desmond Poppy, while also caring for his heavily pregnant wife. Donald has to live in the shadow of his domineering father, and his estranged identical twin brother, Roderick, the protege in the family, a world-famous composer and conductor, and very much preferred by his father over Donald. When Mr Poppy decides St Bernadette's should enter the national competition, he convinces Donald to sign the entry forms, purely by wearing him down through constant badgering, although Donald makes it clear that it is Poppy's project and not wants nothing else to with it, having enough worries of his own. On the day the pupils are due to travel to the competition finals to Christmas Castle in Wales, Mr. Poppy all but kidnaps Desmond, bringing him along on the road trip, but their bitter rivals from Oakmoor School sabotage the trip, ensuring that the St. Bernadette's party get hopelessly lost, being struck by disasters which lead to an impromptu hike across rough terrain, a bout of river-rafting and getting involved in a mountain rescue, eventually getting to the venue with a stray donkey in tow. Donald's brother Roderick is also competing in the competition, mentoring the choir of posh private St Cuthbert's College. As the competition commences, and St. Bernadette's find they have to put up with dirty tricks from all sides, the rivalry between Donald and his brother comes to a furious head when Roderick tries to sabotage both St. Bernadette's and Oakmoor School.

Production

Director
Debbie Isitt
Producer
Nick Jones
Art Director
Tim Stevenson
Editor
Nicky Ager
Music
Nicky Ager and Debbie Isitt
Screenplay
Debbie Isitt
Director of Photography
Tim Stevenson

Review

A somewhat surprise sequel to 2009's Nativity, which was only a moderate hit in cinemas, the film was successful enough on DVD and in TV and cable sales to warrant a sequel, helped by the fact that it wasn't exactly the most expensive pic to make in the first place, which all helps. Replacing Martin Freeman in this second helping of extremely family-friendly comedy, David Tennant (c'mon, you know who he is) playing Donald Peterson, a supply teacher who is sent to the underperforming primary school St. Bernadette's, the location of the first, having to try to care for both the pupils in his class and his heavily pregnant wife (Joanna Page - TV's Gavin And Stacey), and trying to cope with the rivalry between himself and his high-achieving identical twin brother Roderick (Tennant again), who teaches at St. Cuthbert's, an elite private school, and of course the brothers are brought face to face, thanks to digital compositing, when both schools enter the annual 'Sing A Song For Christmas' competition, being held at the fortuitously named Christmas Castle in Wales, but getting completely lost on the way to the competition is just one of a number of predictable disasters, but which eventually includes, hint hint, both a donkey and a birth. Pam Ferris (TV's The Darling Buds Of May / Rosemary & Thyme) as Mrs. Bevans and Marc Wotton, as the rather effete Desmond Poppy, return to reprise their roles from the first, and also adds Jessica Hynes (i.e. Stevenson, renewing her acquaintance with Tennant after the poignant World War One-themed Doctor Who two-parter, Human Nature and The Family Of Blood, one of the third series' highpoints) as a pushy and borderline obnoxious Welsh diva, and we just can't imagine who she's meant to be based on. As with the first Nativity, and her earlier film Confetti, much of this is improvised, working from notes and an outline provided by director Debbie Isitt, the actors largely coming up with their own dialogue, and at times this seemed more than a little strained, only Wotton's painfully enthusiastic Mr. Poppy seeming less than stilted in some scenes. Really being a surprising similarity to the film which spawned it, it has to be said that the first pic was painless enough, and ideal post-turkey Xmas afternoon viewing if there are kids around, as is this, although at 105 minutes a quite serious trim would make things a lot tidier.