Film details

The Paperboy  2012

Cast

Synopsis

Having already made one completely divisive pic, Precious (Based On The Novel 'Push' By Sapphire), writer and director Lee Daniels returns to the screen with a film version of Pete Dexter's novel The Paperboy, which certainly livened up the 2012 Cannes Film Festival, regarded as the one true steamer of the whole fortnight, and summed up by The AV Club who said 'No film festival is complete without an unmitigated disaster, and Cannes 2012 finally served one up yesterday morning in the form of Lee Daniels' The Paperboy, the most repugnant and inept movie to be inexplicably treated like high art since…whaddaya know, since Precious [etc.], the last film directed by Lee Daniels,' and that was actually one of the better ones, some others revelling in the fact that most of the cast were there for the red carpet screening, and looked utterly stunned at the terrible reception the pic received. Set in the Florida of 1969, Ward Jensen, a local reporter (Matthew McConaughey) and his much younger brother Jack (Zac Efron) investigate a possible wrongful conviction, having been asked by the sultry (well, -ish) Charlotte Bless (Nicole Kidman), who's fallen in love with the Death Row prisoner, Hillary Van Wetter (John Cusack), by mail and believes him innocent of having hacked a hateful, racist Sheriff to death with a machete. The set-up is interesting, and Dexter won the National Book Award for his earlier Paris Trout, very effectively filmed in 1991, but Daniels' heavy-handedness soon sends the film spiralling away into extremely leering absurdity, as Cusack's supposedly scary backwoodsman demands that Kidman expose herself to him and simulate a blowjob while he furtively jerks off, Bad Lieutenant-style as McConaughey and Efron do their best to avert their eyes and consider phoning their respective agents. This is just the beginning of a series of events which gave most critics pause, including a BDSM interlude (look it up, you innocent waifs), followed by a long vicious rape scene inexplicably intercut with random shots of dead swamp animals, and becoming immediately the one scene everybody remembered, Kidman weeing on Efron after he's stung by a jellyfish, the scene which apparently finally brought the house down in the Palais Des Festivals. What seemed to try most critic's patience, the kindest acknowledging that the leads try gamely but are terminally miscast, is that Daniels polarises everything, and goes so far as changing the ethnicity of several characters on the printed page so as to emphasise his message, and every single black character in Daniels' film is downtrodden, repressed and abused, or at least they are in the film version, the black characters not being half as supine in Dexter's book. As demented as this all sounds, the fact remains that many critics were genuinely angry that Daniels could make a film so manipulative, sleazy, leering and voyeuristic, yet so utterly self-righteous and sanctimonious, finger-pointing accusingly at everything but itself, and for all its' self-importance to most audiences it will only ever be the one where Nicole Kidman has a wizz on Zac Efron.

Production

Director
Lee Daniels
Producer
Ed Cathell III, Lee Daniels, Cassian Elwes and Hilary Shor
Art Director
Wright McFarland
Editor
Joe Klotz
Music
Mario Grigorov
Screenplay
Pete Dexter and Lee Daniels, based on the novel by Pete Dexter
Director of Photography
Roberto Schaefer

Review

Having already made one completely divisive pic, Precious (based on the novel 'Push' By Sapphire), writer and director Lee Daniels returns to the screen with a film version of Pete Dexter's novel The Paperboy, which certainly livened up the 2012 Cannes Film Festival, being regarded as the one true steamer of the whole fortnight, and receiving some truly coruscating reviews, some critics revelling in the fact that most of the cast were there for the red carpet screening, and looked utterly stunned at the appalling reception the pic received. Dealing with the same sort of deep-fried, down South milieu as featured in Dexter's earlier Paris Trout, which won the National Book Award and was also effectively filmed in 1991, Daniels seems to have taken the throttle off any scintilla of subtlety Precious may have had, the pic being set in the Florida of 1969, Ward Jensen, a formerly local reporter (Matthew McConaughey) returning to investigate a possible wrongful conviction, having been asked by the sultry (well, -ish) Charlotte Bless (Nicole Kidman), who's fallen in love with the Death Row prisoner, Hillary Van Wetter (John Cusack), by mail, become engaged to him, and believes him innocent of the murder for which he is convicted, Jensen, whose family has always been in papers, bringing in his much younger brother Jack (Zac Efron) to assist. The set-up has potential, Dexter, at last on the printed page, managing to effectively evoke the sleepy yet utterly malignant atmosphere of much of the South, but Daniels' leaden heavy-handedness soon sends the film spiralling away into extremely leering absurdity, as Cusack's supposedly scary backwoodsman demands that Kidman expose herself to him and simulate a blowjob while he furtively jerks off, Bad Lieutenant-style as McConaughey and Efron do their best to avert their eyes and consider phoning their respective agents. This is just the beginning of a series of events which would give most viewers pause, including the aftermath of a BDSM interlude (look it up, you innocent waifs), a long vicious rape scene inexplicably intercut with random shots of dead swamp animals, and becoming immediately the one scene everybody remembered, Kidman urinating on Efron after he's stung by a jellyfish, the sequence which apparently finally brought the house down in the Palais Des Festivals. What is most trying is that the undeniable talented leads try gamely but are terminally miscast, and that Daniels completely polarises everything, and goes so far as changing the ethnicity of several characters on the printed page so as to emphasise his message, and every single black character in Daniels' film is downtrodden, repressed and or at least they are in the film version, the black characters not being half as supine in Dexter's book. Worse yet for a filmmaking point of view, the film is bookended with interviews with a maid, Anita (singer Macy Gra0y), who tells the story of the Jensens and their dealing with Charlotte and the Van Wetters, even though she gives details she cannot possibly have known, is barely involved with any of the action, and even gives remarkably detailed interpretations of how some of the characters are feeling and what they are thinking at any given moment, a structure which would seem to cover up the fact that the pic obviously didn't hang together without a linking narration from a completely peripheral character. By the last ten minutes, where the film delves deep into Grande Guignol territory, any sort of attempts at realistic drama have been abandoned, resulting in an ending which wouldn't be out of place in a particularly crazed Italian giallo pic. As demented as this all sounds, the fact remains that Daniels has made a film which is extremely manipulative, sleazy, leering and voyeuristic, yet so utterly self-righteous and sanctimonious, finger-pointing accusingly at everything but itself, and for all its' bombastic self-importance, to most audiences it will only ever be the one where Nicole Kidman takes a wizz on Zac Efron.