Cast
-
-
-
Bryan Cranston
-
Christina Hendricks
-
-
Marcia Gay Harden
-
William Petersen
-
Blythe Danner
-
Tim Blake Nelson
-
Doug E. Doug
-
Sami Gayle
-
Isiah Whitlock Jr.
Synopsis
Directed by British commercials helmer Tony Kaye (American History X / Black Water Transit), a man who will never use a sledgehammer when a piledriver will get the message over all the more emphatically, Detachment features a surprisingly strong cast in a drama which, like most of his features and documentaries, has a very sincere message at its' core, but Kaye's thumpingly unsubtle handling makes even the most sympathetic viewer come away with the definite feeling they've been given a very strict and stern lecture by a shouty tutor. Adrian Brody (The Pianist / Giallo) plays Henry Barthes, a substitute teacher who is sent from school to school in the US 'public' school system, essentially meaning the state schools, exactly the opposite meaning from the phrase in the UK. He movies on from temporary assignment to temporary assignment, never really forming any attachments or friendships wherever he goes, until at his latest appointment he meets three women who, predictably, give him a different view of life, in the form of a young student called Meredith (Betty Kaye, the helmer's daughter), fellow teacher Sarah Madison (Christina Hendricks - TV's Mad Men) and Erica (Sami Gayle - TV's Blue Bloods), a hooker who he starts to feel sorry for. The school system Kaye shows is one in utter disarray, with dedicated teachers somehow managing it together through round after round of budget cuts, with some still having hope of turning it around for the sake of their students and others having resigned themselves to being time servers until they can either leave and go into tutoring or retire to a barely adequate pension, but he also wants to go further, and exterpolate the educational system and its' deficiencies to life as a whole, which is where the screenplay by Carl Lund, the first he has had produced, eventually falls apart. Kaye has managed to attract a quite terrific cast for this, including Marcia Gay Harden (Mystic River), James Caan (The Godfather), Lucy Liu (the Charlie's Angels duo), Blythe Danner (Meet The Parents series), Tim Blake Nelson (Oh Brother, Where Art Thou), Bryan Cranston (TV's Breaking Bad) and Isiah Whitlock Jr. (TV's The Wire), although some are in very minor supporting roles and those who are intrigued by the screen return of William Petersen, after many seasons as Gil Grissom on TV's CSI, will be disappointed that he is visible for literally seconds, with some critics mentioning that some Hitchcock cameos in his own pics are longer than Petersen's screentime, making some suspect that his is one of a number of roles which were largely left in the editing room. After some of Kaye's antics in Hollywood, including wanting to have his name taken off American History X and to be credited as 'Humpty Dumpty', then filing a $275 million lawsuit against the producers, understandably thrown out of court, or admitting to driving himself to a nervous breakdown with his abortion documentary Lake Of Fire, not to mention rather a lot of examples of plain old outrageous behaviour and ego trips, its' amazing that Kaye is still working at all, but if only he could manage to turn the volume knob down occasionally.
Production
- Director
- Tony Kaye
- Producer
- Bingo Gubelmann, Benji Kohn, Carl Lund, Chris Papavasiliou, Greg Shapiro, Austin Stark
- Art Director
- Jade Healy
- Editor
- Peter Goddard
- Music
- The Newton Brothers
- Screenplay
- Carl Lund
- Director of Photography
- Tony Kaye
Review
Directed by British commercials helmer Tony Kaye (American History X / Black Water Transit), a man who will never use a sledgehammer when a piledriver will get the message over all the more emphatically, Detachment features a surprisingly strong cast in a drama which, like most of his features and documentaries, has a very sincere message at its' core, but Kaye's thumpingly unsubtle handling makes even the most sympathetic viewer come away with the definite feeling they been given a very strict and stern lecture by a shouty tutor, several times. Adrian Brody (The Pianist / Giallo) plays Henry Barthes, a substitute teacher who is sent from school to school in the US 'public' school system, essentially meaning the state schools, exactly the opposite meaning from the phrase in the UK. He moves on from temporary assignment to temporary assignment, never really forming any attachments or friendships wherever he goes, until at his latest appointment he meets three women who, predictably, give him a different view of life, in the form of a young student called Meredith (Betty Kaye, the helmer's daughter), fellow teacher Sarah Madison (Christina Hendricks - TV's Mad Men) and Erica (Sami Gayle), a hooker who he starts to feel sorry for. The school system Kaye shows is one is utter disarray, with dedicated teachers somehow managing it together through round after round of budget cuts, with some still having hope of turning it around for the sake of their students and others having resigned themselves to being time servers until they can either leave and go into private tutoring or retire to a barely adequate pension, but he also wants to go further, and extrapolate the educational system and its' deficiencies to life as a whole, which is where the screenplay by Carl Lund, the first he has had produced, eventually falls apart, Barthes, not coincidentally named after not on but two revered French philosophers, Paul and Roland, seeming to want to change the lives of everyone he encounters, and by extension America itself, single-handedly, even if by the end he is made to seem and look impotent. Indeed almost every character is just inches away from despair, either professionally or personally, which takes a toll on the audience as well as the narrative, and there really is a limit to how much of Brody's hangdog, pained expression one can take. Kaye has managed to attract a quite terrific cast for this, including Marcia Gay Harden (Mystic River), James Caan (The Godfather), Lucy Liu (the Charlie's Angels duo), Blythe Danner (Meet The Parents series), Tim Blake Nelson (Oh Brother, Where Art Thou), Bryan Cranston (TV's Breaking Bad) and Isiah Whitlock Jr. (TV's The Wire), although some are in very minor supporting roles and those who are intrigued by the screen return of William Petersen, after many seasons as Gil Grissom on TV's CSI, will be disappointed that he is on screen for literally seconds, with some critics mentioning that some Hitchcock cameos in his own pics are longer than Petersen's screentime, making some suspect that his is just one of a number of roles which was largely left in the editing room. After some of Kaye's antics in Hollywood, including wanting to have his name taken off American History X and to be credited as 'Humpty Dumpty', then filing a $275 million lawsuit against the producers, understandably thrown out of court, or admitting to driving himself to a nervous breakdown with his abortion documentary Lake Of Fire, not to mention rather a lot of examples of plain old outrageously obnoxious behaviour and ego trips, its' a amazing that Kaye is still working at all, and Detachment is certainly one of his patented howls of anger and pain, but if only he could manage to turn the volume knob down occasionally.