Film details

Elles  2012

Der Bessen Leben

Cast

  • Anaïs Demoustier
  • Joanna Kulig
  • Louis-Do de Lencquesaing
  • Krystyna Janda
  • Ali Marhyar
  • François Civil
  • Pablo Beugnet
  • Valerie Dreville
  • Jean-Louis Coullo'ch
  • Arthur Moncia

Synopsis

Anne, a freelance Parisian journalist, is working for Elle magazine on a commission for an article concerning prostitution. Before leaving for work her husband Patrick reminds her that his boss and his wife are coming to dinner that evening. Getting her two sons, Florent, a teenager, and Stéphane, ten years old, to school, she does some shopping before returning to her work and going over some of the research she did for the piece, a number of interviews with two students, both of whom are involved with prostitution purely to supplement their incomes, Charlotte, who calls herself Lola when with tricks, and Polish teenager Alicja. Anne is surprised at how casually the pair treat what they do, regarding it as a perfectly acceptable and quite easy way to make money. Charlotte chose it over underpaid and gruelling student holiday jobs, while Alicja moved into it after she arrived in Paris and had all her money stolen, needing to earn cash to pay for her accommodation, supplied by Said, a North African student who rented her a room. Both girls talk of some of their clients, Charlotte recalling when one of them after they had sex, serenaded her on the guitar with a melancholic song, Les Feuilles Mortes, while Alijca tells of a client who wanted her to be the recipient of a 'golden shower', which Alicja has no problem with. Charlotte claims to have had mostly decent clients, but also recalls a horrific incident when she was brutalised with a wine bottle. As the interviews continue, Anne becomes more and more involved with the two girls, and starts to see uncomfortable parallels with her own life. When Florent returns home she confronts him about what she has heard from his school, that he has been playing truant and getting involved with drugs. Patrick arrives home, but makes no effort to support her either in her dealings with Florent or in organising the dinner party. When the guests arrive, Anne starts to think of the stories she has been told, of the girls, their pragmatism, and their clients, the strain of having to be a perfect wife and mother is starting to take its' toll on her.

Production

Director
Małgorzata Szumowska
Producer
Marianne Slot
Art Director
Pauline Bourdon
Editor
Jacek Drosio and Francoise Tourmen
Music
Pawel Mykietyn
Screenplay
Małgorzata Szumowska and Tine Byrckel
Director of Photography
Michal Englert

Review

Directed by Małgorzata Szumowska (Stranger) from a screenplay by Szumowska and Tine Byrckel, Elles boasts some very fine French talent in the form of Juliette Binoche (Cache / Certified Copy) and Louis-Do de Lencquesaing (Father Of My Children / House Of Tolerance), the pic being a French / Polish / German co-production, made with the participation of a couple of Lars Von Trier's Zentropa International arms, but while obviously made with a serious intent, even if the approach to the central idea of prostitution is handled unexpectedly, the bare synopsis makes it sound like the seemingly never-ending Schulmadchen-Report series of German soft-porn flicks made in the 70s and 80s, with which the film has a superficial but alarming resemblance, focusing as it does on the uncomfortable subject of student prostitution, a recurrent theme in the German series, even down to it being the subject of an investigative reporter, another much utilized plot device. The always watchable Binoche plays Anne, a successful journalist juggling her family life, being the mother of two children, with being an investigative reporter on Elle magazine. Given the assignment of investigating reports of female students turning to prostitution to fund their university courses, she becomes close to two young women, Alicja (Joanna Kulig - The Woman In The Fifth) and Charlotte (Anais Demoustier - Living On Love Alone) who are both involved, finding them strongly independent and determined, having entered the sex trade for the same reason, crucially, a desire for more cash, trying to deal with her reactions to the unflinching answers they give to her questions, have her then question her own attitudes to love, marriage and commitment, which is unfortunately unconvincingly stapled on to a dinner party being thrown for her husband's boss and his wife, a situation which surely becomes risible after Terry And June in the 70s. Szumowska insists on using this as a parallel to Anne seeing herself in the same sort of situation as the girls, her marriage merely being a form of legalised, state-sanctioned prostitution, a feminist attitude which surely died out in the eighties after the rantings of the likes of Andrea Dworkin finally lost their novelty value. What is both interesting and also largely sinks the film's central argument is the fact that the clients both Alicja and Charlotte have to deal are, largely, 'decent' men, if one can so use that word, although the scene of one violent clients, who abuses Charlotte with a wine bottle, is both alarming and upsetting, although she seems to recover from such a traumatic attack surprisingly quickly. A potentially sensitive subject, and one which has been in the headlines more than once in the present economic climate, Szumowska's pic at least tries to deal with the topic in a pretty unglamourous and pragmatic way, which may not be to everybody's taste, and perhaps making some confront the prejudices they may have. Binoche, as usual, gives a fine performance, but the subplot of Anne's sudden 'realisation' as to what he marriage has seemingly made her, undermines what has previously been a surprisingly balanced and nuanced drama.