Cast
-
-
Pio Marmai
-
Jean-Philippe Ecoffey
-
Marie-Sohna Conde
-
Marie-Christine Orry
-
Vinciane Millereau
-
Sophie Fougere
-
Jean-Louis Tribes
-
Laurent Cyr
-
Olivier Galliano
-
Noelle Boisson
-
Mic Cheminal
Synopsis
Funny how Kristin Scott Thomas seems to be so much more of a star in her French films, she now being a habitue of Paris, than her English language roles, and how the French productions also seem to be far more appealing to British distributors than some of the Hollywood movies she has occasionally appears in. In Your Hands, although a strict translation of the original French title Contre Toi would be the more vague Against You, is the second feature from Lola Doillon, the writer / director daughter of filmmaker Jacques Doillon, a drama / thriller starring KST as Anna Cooper, an egotistical and aloof surgeon, devoted to her work, and who lives alone in Paris, shunning friends and acquaintances. The film begins with her in a dilemma, returning home distressed, getting back to her upmarket apartment and immediately plugging her drained phone in, frenziedly checking her voice mail. She has been abducted and held prisoner for several days, but none seem connected to her predicament. No one has noticed her absence since she was meant to be on holiday anyway. Commencing a flashback which takes up most of the rest of the pic, we see what happened to her, being snatched by Yann Ochberg (Pio Marmai - Delicacy), a young man whose life was destroyed when his wife died after a botched Caesarean operation carried out by Anna. Despite being cleared by a court of all blame, Yann still blames her for the death, and also bitterly notes how she didn't even have common decency to turn up to the hearing. Keeping her in a small room with one bricked-up window, he starts to muse on what to do with her now that he has her, and a psychological power struggle begins, each trying to dominate the other, both of them threatening the other in various ways. A couple of the touches in the script are perhaps a little too clever-clever, Ochberg, the surname of the abductor referring to Frank Ochberg, the psychiatrist who first defined what is now known as The Stockholm Syndrome, how a captive can begin to sympathise and even fall in love with their captor, which may or may not be an element in the jailor / prisoner relationship, but the film runs a very tight 80 minutes, Doillon keeping the narrative moving swiftly, even if some of the plot developments in the final scenes have been described by some critics as straining logic to the limit, but the leads have received suitable praise, KST giving another of her by now trademarked ice queen portrayal, if perhaps yet more glacial than ever, while Marmai's damaged and wounded Yann elicits the necessary sympathy but also exudes some real menace when he remembers exactly how this situation has come about.
Production
- Director
- Lola Doillon
- Producer
- Saga Blanchard
- Art Director
- Stephanie Guitard and Stanislas Reydellet
- Editor
- Marie Da Costa
- Music
- Anthony Leroy, Dominique Leroy and Sandra Moubarak
- Screenplay
- Lola Doillon
- Director of Photography
- Mathieu Nadepied
Review
Strange how Kristin Scott Thomas seems to be so much more of a star in her French films, she now being a habitue of Paris, than her English language roles, and how the French productions also seem to be far more appealing to British distributors than some of the Hollywood movies she has occasionally appears in. In Your Hands, a strict translation of the original Gallic title Contre Toi being Against You, is the second feature from Lola Doillon, the writer / director daughter of filmmaker Jacques Doillon, and although initially seeming to be some sort of abduction thriller, then into almost a two-hander drama when Thomas as Anna Cooper, an egotistical and aloof obstetric surgeon, devoted to her work, and who lives alone in Paris, recalls the events of the last few days after the audience has seen her escape from a house in the far flung suburbs of the city and return to her apartment, where phone messages establish that she was supposed to be on holiday, and has not returned, causing her friends and work colleagues to worry. The film begins with her in a dilemma, returning home distressed, getting back to her upmarket apartment and then going to the Police, then recalling the events of the last few days, commencing a flashback which takes up most of the rest of the pic, we see what happened to her, being snatched by Yann (Pio Marmai - Delicacy), a young man whose life was destroyed when his wife died after a botched Caesarean operation carried out by Anna. Kept in a room without windows, Yann is initially the one in control, his rage over his wife's death being compounded by the fact that Anna could not even be bothered to attend the hearing which eventually cleared her, a perfect example of the iciness this actress almost cannot help but exude, and it seems that Yann may extract some sort of violent revenge, but the balance of power starts to shift when it becomes apparent that Yann is perhaps incapable of hurting her, and instead just wants what he never received - a sincere apology, but is Anna capable of providing even that? A couple of the touches in Doillon's script are perhaps a little too clever-clever, Ochberg, the surname of the abductor referring to Frank Ochberg, the psychiatrist who first defined what is now known as The Stockholm Syndrome, how a captive can begin to sympathise and even fall in love with their captor, which may or may not be an element in the master / captive relationship, but the film runs a very tight 80 minutes, Doillon keeping the narrative moving swiftly, even if some of the plot developments in the final scenes become confused, making Anna a confused character, the film seemingly wanting to try out several endings to see which one fits best, and its' interesting to see Thomas as a victim, and at the mercy of another, rather than the by now trademarked ice queen portrayal, while Marmai's damaged and wounded Yann elicits the necessary sympathy but also exudes some real menace when he remembers exactly how this situation has come about. Doillon's film may ultimately be unsatisfying, perhaps trying to show ambivalence and sympathy towards both main characters when one may not deserve it, but the two central performances are excellent, and one can sympathise with both characters, even if, in the case of the initially aloof and imperious Anne, one may not actually want to.