Film details

Romeo & Juliet  2012

Romeo E Giulietta

Cast

  • Hailee Steinfeld
  • Douglas Booth
  • Damien Lewis
  • Laura Morante
  • Ed Westwick
  • Stellen Skarsgard
  • Paul Giamatti
  • Tomas Arana
  • Kodi Smit-McPhee
  • Lesley Manville
  • Christian Cooke

Synopsis

Originally set for release on 14th February 2013 (wonder why that day in particular?) this version of Romeo And Juliet, directed by Carlo Carlei (The Flight Of The Innocent / Fluke) estimated at being around the ninety-fifth film or TV take on the timeless tale, give or take a few, but the fact that the screenplay is credited to the (unfortunately) seemingly tireless Julian Fellowes (Gosford Park / TV's Downton Abbey), in that despite the play being form the finest playwright who ever lived, and containing some of his most memorable lines, the script is Fellowes' own, inventing new dialogue, and only using the actual story as a rough framework. What was also meant to be a more mature and tragic version was also considerably lightened with the casting of Hailee Steinfeld (the True Grit remake), sixteen at time of shooting, meaning that some of the original plot developments, such as the young couple actually spending the night together, were very quickly chucked out the window. Fellowes graciously retains the rough outline of the tale, and the setting remains the same, Renaissance Verona, as the warring Montague and Capulet families are embroiled in a long-running feud, but when Romeo Montague (Douglas Booth - TV's The Pillars Of The Earth) attends a Capulet ball in disguise, he falls in love with the beautiful Juliet (Steinfeld), the daughter of his family's sworn enemy. Already engaged to a man she does not love, Juliet vows instead to marry Romeo. They ask the kindly and compassionate Friar Laurence (Paul Giamatti - Sideways) to perform the ceremony in secret but of course there's no happy ever after for this pair, but then again in Fellowes' version who knows? What one can take solace in is the quite remarkable cast which has been assembled, with Damien Lewis (The Sweeney reboot / TV's Homeland) and Natascha McElhone (Solaris / TV's Californication) as Lord and Lady Montague, Tomas Arana (Bodypuzzle / Gladiator) and the beautiful Laura Morante (The Son's Room / The Dancer Upstairs) as Lord and Lady Capulet, Stellen Skarsgard (Ronin / Mamma Mia) as the Prince of Verona, Ed Westwick (TV's Gossip Girl) as Tybalt, Kodi Smit-McPhee (The Road) as Benvolio and Lesley Manville (The Queen) as the all-important Nurse. The cast is fascinating, and the film is largely shot on the actual locations which Shakespeare wrote of but, it is believed, never actually visited. A quality prioduction of this is always going to be welcome, but jettisoning the original lines, and allowing Fellowes, who as Downton Abbey has shown can write some of the clunkiest, most unnatural-sounding dialogue when trying to actually forward the plot, to rewrite it just seems like utter short-sighted folly.

Production

Director
Carlo Carlei
Producer
Simon Bosanquet, Lawrence Elman, Julian Fellowes, Alexander Koll, Ileen Maisel, Doug Mankoff and Andrew Spaulding
Art Director
Torino Zera
Editor
Peter Honess
Music
Abel Korzeniowski
Screenplay
Julian Fellowes, adapted from the play by William Shakespeare
Director of Photography
David Tattersall

Review

Originally set for release on 14th February 2013 (wonder why that day in particular?), but eventually delayed several months, this version of Romeo And Juliet, directed by Carlo Carlei (The Flight Of The Innocent / Fluke) estimated at being around the ninety-fifth film or TV take on the timeless tale, give or take a few, but the screenplay is credited to the (unfortunately) seemingly tireless Julian Fellowes (Gosford Park / TV's Downton Abbey), and despite the play being from the finest playwright who ever lived, and containing some of his most memorable lines, the script is Fellowes' own, inventing new dialogue, obviously believing somehow he can do a better job than the Bard. What was also being promoted as a more mature and tragic version of the original, the casting of Hailee Steinfeld (the True Grit remake), sixteen at time of shooting, meant that some of the original plot developments, such as the young couple actually spending the night together, were very quickly chucked out the window, although she remains engaged to Count Paris (Tom Wisdom - 300). Fellowes graciously retains the plot of the tale, and the setting remains the same, Renaissance Verona, as the warring Montague and Capulet families are embroiled in a long-running feud, but when Romeo Montague (Douglas Booth - TV's The Pillars Of The Earth) falls in love with the beautiful Juliet (Steinfeld), the daughter of his family's sworn enemy. Already engaged to a man she does not love, Juliet vows instead to marry Romeo, despite their family's objections, which turn deadly when Tybalt (Ed Westwick - TV's Gossip Girl) kills Romeo's friend Mercutio (Christian Cooke - Cemetery Junction), and is then himself slain by Romeo, but of course everyone knows there's no happy ever after for this pair, but then again in Fellowes' rewrite anything seems possible. What one can take solace in is the quite remarkable cast which has been assembled, with Damien Lewis (The Sweeney reboot / TV's Homeland) and Natascha McElhone (Solaris / TV's Californication) as Lord and Lady Montague, Tomas Arana (Bodypuzzle / Gladiator) and the beautiful Laura Morante (The Son's Room / The Dancer Upstairs) as Lord and Lady Capulet, Stellen Skarsgard (Ronin / Mamma Mia) as the Prince of Verona, Kodi Smit-McPhee (The Road) as Benvolio, Paul Giamatti (Sideways) as Friar Lawrence, and Lesley Manville (The Queen) as the all-important Nurse. The cast is fascinating, and the film is largely shot on the actual locations which Shakespeare wrote of but, it is believed, never actually visited. A quality production of this is always going to be welcome, but jettisoning the original lines, and allowing Fellowes to rewrite it just seems like utter short-sighted folly, the fact that he largely writes period piece seemingly being through he just cannot write lines which sounds natural in any way, and in Downton Abbey has shown can produce some of the clunkiest, most unnatural-sounding dialogue possible when trying to actually forward the plot. Romeo And Juliet 2013-style may be a valiant attempt to try to attract a larger, younger audience, but by replacing some of the most famous lines in English literature with Fellowes' lumpen cliches is a terrible step backwards.