Film details

Hit So Hard  2011

Cast

  • Patty Schemel
  • Melissa Auf der Maur
  • Kurt Cobain
  • Eric Erlandson
  • Kristen Plaff
  • Larry Schemel
  • Gina Schock
  • Debbi Peterson
  • Kate Schellenbach
  • Nina Gordon
  • Roddy Bottum

Synopsis

Music documentaries get ever more esoteric, so much so that we are any day now expecting feature-length docs on Don Spencer, Lou Christie, The Little Heroes, First Choice, The New Marquettes, Meko, The Oliver Onions or Don Partridge (look those up when you've got a minute, all worth it), and to prove this ubiquity of music documentaries comes Hit So Hard, a documentary directed, edited and co-written by P. David Ebersole (TV's Desire / Wicked Wicked Games), whose subject is even more esoteric than most, Patty Schemel. Yes, exactly, and frankly unless you were a fan of Courtney Love's Hole (here we go.....) the name won't mean anything, Hole being the band formed after... (takes phone call from lawyers, alters copy considerably)... Love discovered her husband's body, he being Kurt Cobain of Nirvana, having had a fairly fatal close encounter with the business end of a shotgun. Ebersole seems to have fully bought into the myth-making of Schemel's part, telling her story from how she realised that she was gay in the farm town she grew up in just outside Seattle, to getting into music and becoming the drummer of Hole, and whoever was responsible for the film press release which called Hole 'seminal' deserves either a slap or a beer. Schemel inevitably got caught up in the drugs world, becoming a hard user, and seeing a fellow member, bassist Kristen Plaff, die of heroin addiction, aged only 27, and Schemel herself came close several times, but since she is still around, and running a dog care business, this almost seems to become another cautionary tale being told by someone 99% will never have heard of. Hit So Hard has contributions from some of the usual suspects of the female rock market, such as Hole members Melissa Auf der Maur, former member of The Go-Gos Gina Schock, ex-Bangle Debbi Peterson, and former part-time drummer for The Beastie Boys, and now top-rated TV producer Kate Schellenbach, as well as the frankly frightening Phranc, a militant political singer who once campaigned for a completely sexually separatist USA, with men on one coast and women on the other, and ne'er the twain should meet, but Hit So Hard really seems to be an example of what seems to be a new and burgeoning sub-genre, the vanity music documentary, revolving around one musician and their music, career, life story etc, and which really is only ever going to appeal to a truly tiny, tiny section of the viewing public, seeming to be the visual equivalent of the vanity publishing industry, and made for the same self-agrandising reasons. Rock musician gets on drugs. Doesn't die. Not a story. Rock musician gets on drugs. Doesn't die, but now runs a dog walking, doggy daycare and vacation boarding business, different proposition.

Production

Director
P. David Ebersole
Producer
Todd Hughes and Christina Soletti
Art Director
Not credited
Editor
P. David Ebersole
Music
Roddy Bottum (original)
Screenplay
P. David Ebersole and Todd Hughes
Director of Photography
Larra Anderson, Mark Putnam and John Tanzer

Review

Music documentaries get ever more esoteric, so much so that we are any day now expecting feature-length docs on Don Spencer, Lou Christie, The Little Heroes, First Choice, The New Marquettes, Meko, The Oliver Onions or Don Partridge (look those up when you've got a minute, all worth it), and to prove this ubiquity of music documentaries comes Hit So Hard, a documentary directed, edited and co-written by P. David Ebersole (TV's Desire / Wicked Wicked Games), whose subject is even more esoteric than most, Patty Schemel, and unless you were a fan of Courtney Love's Hole (here we go.....) in the Nineties the name won't mean anything, Hole being the band fronted by Love while husband Kurt Cobain held the same position in Nirvana, until having a slightly fatal close encounter with the business end of a shotgun. Ebersole seems to have fully bought into the myth-making of Schemel's part, telling her story from how she realised that she was gay in the farm town she grew up in just outside Seattle, to getting into music and becoming the drummer of Hole, Schemel inevitably getting caught up in the drugs world, becoming a hard user, and seeing a fellow member, bassist Kristen Plaff, die of heroin addiction, aged only 27. Schemel herself came close several times, and indeed lost every thing, forced to trying to score on the streets and at one point already being reported as dead in a mistaken music press article based on hearsay. Hit So Hard has contributions from some of the usual suspects of the female rock market, such as Hole members Melissa Auf der Maur, former member of The Go-Gos Gina Schock, ex-Bangle Debbi Peterson, and former part-time drummer for The Beastie Boys, now top-rated TV producer Kate Schellenbach, as well as the frankly frighteningly Phranc, a militant political singer who once campaigned for a completely sexually separatist USA, with men on one coast and women on the other, and ne'er the twain should meet. There also isn't even the fact that female drummers are particularly rare now, bands ranging from Babes In Toyland, Yo Le Tango, Krunk, The Butthole Surfers, Sleater-Kinney and many others all having females whacking the skins, and that's not even including retired exponents of the craft such as Meg White and the late Karen Carpenter. Hit So Hard really seems to be an example of what seems to be a new and burgeoning sub-genre, the vanity music documentary, revolving around one musician and their music, career, life story etc, and which really is only ever going to appeal to a truly tiny, tiny section of the viewing public, seeming to be the visual equivalent of the vanity publishing industry, and made for the same self-agrandising reasons. Rock musician gets on drugs. Doesn't die. Not a story. Rock musician gets on drugs. Doesn't die, but now runs a dog walking, doggy daycare and vacation boarding business, different proposition. One would really have to be a staggeringly dedicated Hole fan and compleatist for this, but there will be some, somewhere.