Cast
-
Mark Whalberg
-
-
Catherine Zeta-Jones
-
-
Kyle Chandler
-
Justin Chambers
-
Griffin Dunne
-
Judd Lormand
-
Alona Tai
-
William Ragsdale
-
Natalie Martinez
-
Michael Beach
Synopsis
NYPD Detective Billy Taggart is on trial for the shooting of a suspect, Mikey Tavarez, who raped and murdered the sixteen-year-old sister of Taggart's girlfriend Natalie Barrow, under unclear and suspicious circumstances. When condemning evidence is unearthed, the office of the Mayor, Nicholas 'Nicky' Hostetler, accepts Taggart's resignation in exchange for ruling the death as self defence. Seven years later, and Taggart is a down-at-heel private eye, just about making a living, while Mayor Nicholas 'Nicky' Hostetler is standing for re-election. Taggart is surprised to be hired by Hostetler to find out with whom his wife, Cathleen, is having an affair. With his assistant, Katy Bradshaw, Taggart quickly finds that Cathleen is involved with Paul Andrews, the campaign manager of Jack Valliant, Hostetler's rival in the upcoming election. Taggart attends a fundraiser for Hostetler's campaign, where Cathleen tells him she knows he is following her, and strongly advises him not to become involved with, or trust, her husband. Taggart delivers the envelope with the pictures that he has of Cathleen meeting with Andrews to Hostetler. Paul Andrews is found shot dead shortly afterwards. Taggart is called in by Carl Fairbanks, his former Captain on the force, who brokered his original deal with the Mayor, and admits he had been hired by Hostetler. They talk with Valliant, who reluctantly reveals that Andrews had been meeting Todd Lancaster, the son of Hostetler's associate, wealthy and powerful contractor Sam Lancaster, their investigations also uncovering that Andrews was the secret partner of Valliant, a closeted gay man who knows that to reveal his sexuality would end his Mayoral chances. Meeting with Cathleen, she reveals that Andrews actually provided her with information about Hostetler's plans for the high-profile and expansive Bolton Village Housing Project, a major city redevelopment scheme. Hostetler wanted to uncover Cathleen's source, and hired Taggart under false pretences to lead him to whoever it was. Taggart investigates Lancaster's construction business, finding that Hostetler has secretly sold the Bolton Village in order to have it demolished and replaced by office buildings, leaving hundreds of the city's poorest people homeless, while making an immense profit for himself. Taggart is attacked by Hostetler's thugs, who destroy the evidence he has accumulated. Tracking down Todd Lancaster, Taggart interrogates him, forcing him to reveal he disagreed with Hostetler's plans and intended to give Paul Andrews the demolition contract as evidence against Hostetler the night he was murdered. He gives it to Taggart, who confronts Hostetler, threatening to expose him, but the Mayor reminds him that he has evidence of his own, evidence which could lock Billy Taggart up for premeditated murder.
Production
- Director
- Allen Hughes
- Producer
- Randall Emmett, Aaron Milchan, Allen Hughes, Stephen Levinson, Teddy Schwartzman, Remington Chase and Mark Whalberg
- Art Director
- Christina Eunji Kim
- Editor
- Cindy Mollo
- Music
- Atticus Ross, Leo Ross and Claudia Sarne
- Screenplay
- Brian Tucker
- Director of Photography
- Ben Seresin
Review
Written by Brian Tucker, the script for Broken City made the prestigious industry 'Black List' of best unproduced screenplays in 2008, and while it has now finally made it to the screen, under the direction of Allen Hughes, one half of the Hughes Brothers directorial team (Menace II Society / Dead Presidents / From Hell), the result isn't quite what may have been expected from an already garlanded project, which very much wants to be a modern-day Chinatown blending political machinations and high-level corruption with a formerly straight-arrow disgraced alcoholic former cop seeming to be the only good, honest man in a dirty, grubby, vicious conspiracy. The film certainly has pretensions towards gravity and 'making a statement', when really its' just a glossy, efficient and entertaining cop movie, and really nothing more despite a cast which includes Mark Whalberg (The Other Guys / The Fighter), Russell Crowe (thankfully not singing after Les Misérables, not that he actually technically singing in that) and Catherine Zeta-Jones (Chicago / The Mask Of Zorro), Whalberg playing Billy Taggart, the carbon-copy dedicated cop whose career ended the moment he went beyond the law and killed a rapist and murderer who had been set free on a technicality. Years later, struggling as a cheap private detective, snooping around windows hoping to snap pictures of cheating souses in 'compromising positions', things change when he is approached by New York Mayor Nicholas Hostetler (Crowe), who wants a PI to investigate his wife Cathleen (CZ-J) and identify her mystery lover, in the days leading up to a tense mayoral election between Crowe and his popular, liberal challenger, the almost comically-named Jack Valliant (Barry Pepper - Flags Of Our Fathers / the True Grit remake), Taggart owing Hostetler for getting him off the hook for the death years earlier. As will surprise nobody, the job reveals a whole lot more than a simple incidence of adultery, and Taggart predictably finds himself having to piece together a far-reaching conspiracy which seems to revolve a dubious and hugely profitable land deal. Professionally handled by Hughes, who certainly has a handle on both the dialogue and performances, the characters are a little too on-the-nose at times, with little coming that is particularly unexpected although certain touches are interestingly edgy, such as the sheer varnished nastiness of Crowe's character, which actually makes one wonder how he ever got elected in the first place, never mind holding onto the post, and the fact that Whalberg's Taggart is really far more flawed than he initially seems, but the pic seems to jettison any real ambition about halfway and becomes a rather more conventional, predictable conspiracy thriller, despite promising to offer some interesting observations on guilt and conscience, and how the very rich are safely insulated from suffering from either. Hughes keeps it all rather low-key, with the action scenes being brief but impactful, and the ending is neatly melancholic, if perhaps a little too neat and circumspect, but remains a smart, good-looking thriller, shot by Ben Seresin (Unstoppable), which just doesn't live up to the serious promise of its' first third.