Film details

Keyhole  2011

Cast

  • Udo Keir
  • Louis Negin
  • Brooke Paisson
  • David Wontner
  • Suzanne Pringle
  • Kevin Macdonald
  • Daniel Enright
  • Theodorus Zegeye-Gebrehiwot
  • Brent Neale
  • Johnny Chang

Synopsis

One has to say that in the forty-one features and assorted shorts since his 1989 debut Tales From The Gimli Hospital, and continuing on through such pics as Arcangel, Careful and The Saddest Music In The World, the writer and director has remained consistent, meaning that given a couple of minutes of almost any Maddin film will immediately indicate who the filmmaker involved is, which also indicates that most of Maddin's films resemble each other. Some will claim that his heavily stylised technique, usually black and white photography, and unconventional use of period-sounding music, exaggerated acting styles, with a strange and almost prissy regard to set decoration and design, as well as some truly eccentric plots make his productions resemble random scenes from some bizarre 20's East European saga, re-edited together, while others will argue that not only do all his films resemble each other to a degree where they become almost interchangeable, but that Maddin valuers style over substance. Keyhole is a slight, but only slight, variation, some critics calling it a pastiche of hard-boiled 30's noir thrillers, a gangster pic with overtones of Italian sword-and-sandal epics in its' naming of characters and adding a setting which could very well be a haunted house, as underworld hood Ulysses (Jason Patric - Speed 2 / Narc) and his gang are cornered in a crumbling mansion which seems to be populated by ghosts from Ulysses' murky past. As Ulysses searches for his wife (Maddin regular Isabella Rossellini) in the maze of rooms, the sheer grotesquerie of the house reveals itself as elderly, almost naked people stumble through the rooms and corridors, a naked old man is chained to a bed in one of the rooms, and another room harbours a bicycle-powered electric chair. Those who are fans are bound to be delighted, by some critics on the festival circuit save noted that this, almost more than any of his films, needs more discipline in the script, which meanders all over the place, to try to tie at least some of the narrative together, some believing that once again Maddin has produced something extremely visually distracting, at least initially, before returning self-indulgently of his familiar tropes, themes and tricks and anyone, who can direct a film entitled Odilon Redon, Or The Eye Like A Strange Balloon Mounts Towards Infinity really should be sat down and given a talking to.

Production

Director
Guy Maddin
Producer
Jean Du Toit and Jody Shapiro
Art Director
Ricardo Alms
Editor
John Gurdebake
Music
Jason Steczak
Screenplay
Guy Maddin and George Toles
Director of Photography
Benjamin Kasulke

Review

One has to say that in the forty-one features and assorted shorts since his 1989 debut Tales From The Gimli Hospital, and continuing on through such pics as Arcangel, Careful and The Saddest Music In The World, as well as the filmed ballet Dracula: Pages From A Virgin's Diary, writer and director Guy Maddin's style and technique has remained largely consistent, meaning that given a couple of minutes of almost any Maddin film will immediately indicate who the filmmaker involved is, which also reinforces that most of Maddin's films very much resemble each other, both a strength and a weakness. Some will claim that his heavily stylised technique, usually shot in black and white, with unconventional use of period-sounding music, exaggerated acting styles, with a strange and almost prissy regard to set decoration and design, as well as some truly eccentric plots make his productions resemble random scenes from some bizarre 20's East European saga, re-edited together, while others will argue that not only do all his films resemble each other to a degree where they become almost interchangeable, but that Maddin values style over substance above all. Keyhole is a slight, but only slight, variation, resembling initially a pastiche of hard-boiled 30's noir thrillers, a gangster pic with overtones of Italian sword-and-sandal epics in its' naming of characters and adding a setting which could very well be a haunted house, as underworld hood Ulysses (Jason Patric - Speed 2 / Narc) and his gang return to the city of Winnipeg, Maddin's default location, a crumbling mansion which seems to be populated by ghosts from Ulysses' murky past. As Ulysses searches for his wife Hyacinth (Maddin regular Isabella Rossellini) in the maze of rooms, the sheer grotesquerie of the house reveals itself, as elderly, almost naked people stumble through the rooms and corridors, a naked old man, Hyacinth's father, is chained to a bed in one of the rooms, and another room harbours a bicycle-powered electric chair. Gangsters who have been fatally shot in an opening and largely off-screen shoot-out also seem to be rather reluctant to actually die, also becoming meandering occupants, for reasons which, like so much of the pic, are never explained. Although Maddin fans are bound to be delighted, especially since Keyhole has been one of the few Maddin movies to get any sort of actual theatrical release rather then being limited to the festival circuit, this, almost more than any of his films, needs more discipline in the script, which meanders all over the place, to try to tie at least some of the narrative together, the ending hinting that this is just part of some ecliptical cycle, bound to repeat time and again, a quite nightmarish thought for those who do not fall under its' carefully manufactured spell. Once again Maddin has produced something extremely visually distracting, at least initially, before returning self-indulgently of his familiar tropes, themes and tricks, which shows consistency if nothing else, but anyone who can direct a film entitled Odilon Redon Or The Eye Like A Strange Balloon Mounts Towards Infinity really should be sat down and given a talking to.