Film details

Laurence Anyways  2012

Cast

  • Melvil Poupaud
  • Suzanne Clément
  • Monia Chokri
  • Susan Almgren
  • Yves Jacques
  • Sophie Faucher
  • Magalie Lépine Blondeau
  • David Savard
  • Catherine Bégin
  • Emmanuel Schwartz
  • Jacques Lavallée

Synopsis

The 1990s. Laurence Alia, a schoolteacher in Montreal, is involved in a deep and passionate relationship with Fred, his pet name for Frédérique Bellair, who has a job in the film industry. Their relationship seems strong and close, but Fred is stunned when Laurence makes a sincere confession to her - he wants to be a woman, believing he is a woman trapped in a man's body, and hopes to have a sex-change operation. She is staggered by what he tells her, but he manages to persuade her that, whatever gender he may be, he is still the same person inside, and still loves her, she deciding to stand by him as he embarks on what ever path he decides to take. He begins to arrive at school wearing women's clothing, and has a colleague commend him for his honesty and bravery. He goes to his mother, Julienne, to tell her that he is now wearing women's clothing, and seems not to be surprised, telling him coldly that he never felt like a real son to her. After complaints are made to the school board, Laurence is sacked from his teaching post, but becomes friendly with a group of drag artists, who give him tips on dress, appearance and behaviour. Time passes. Fred marries another man, Michel, and lives in Trois-Riviéres. She is surprised when a published book of poems, written by Laurence, arrives in the post. Her shock gives way to a tide of emotion, and she makes contact with him again, finding that he now cross-dresses full-time, but the two recommence their involvement, despite she being married, but Fred makes a painful confession, that when Laurence first made his revelation, she aborted the baby she was carrying, having not told him she was pregnant. It is a seismic shock for Laurence, and one their tentative affair cannot survive.

Production

Director
Xavier Dolan
Producer
Caroline Mondello and Lyse Lafontaine
Art Director
Pascale Deschénes
Editor
Xavier Dolan
Music
Eduardo Noia
Screenplay
Xavier Dolan
Director of Photography
Yves Bélanger

Review

With writer, actor and director Xavier Dolan making such an impact with his first two features, I Killed My Mother and Heartbeats, it has to be remembered that Dolan, precocious talent that he is, is still only 23 years old. His third film is his most ambitious yet, revolving around the relationship between literature teacher Laurence (Melvin Poupaud - 44 Inch Chest / Mysteries Of Lisbon) and Frédérique, or Fred (Suzanne Clément - L'Audition), the pair being happy together and looking forward to some sort of future with each other, but the audience knows otherwise, and the idyll is intact until Laurence tells Fred his most treasured ambition - to be a woman. This would probably be the deal-breaker for a lot of couples, in fact most, but Fred decides to stay with him, and encourages him in pursuing his dream, Laurence starting to cross-dress and she being generally supportive, even though he eventually loses his job at the school, but whereas for many filmmakers this would be the culmination of the film, for Dolan it is almost only the beginning, the film verging dangerously into camp territory when in each and every scene Laurence is seen in some new and fabulous outfit, making one wonder how he's even managing to afford all this, never mind what it is doing to his relationship with Fred, but it is this which seems to come secondary to Dolan. What he seems keener on doing is flaunting his technique, and it soon becomes clear that the writer / director isn't tremendously keen on grounding this in anything resembling the reality of the situation, but as a chance to pull off some bravura effects, Lawrence's appearances become all the more dramatic and showy as his self-assurance in this new identity grows, Poupaud's performance becoming more self-assured as does the character, Dolan adding shock-angles or blasts of music to emphasise his points and although a sub-plot of Laurence being mentored by a bunch of drag queens, is pretty unnecessary and only adds length to an already leisurely paced film, but the drama Dolan wants to bring in is emphasised in an extraordinary sequence when after receiving his book of poems, Fred is literally washed away by a tide of emotion in the most literal way possible, utterly implausible but visually brilliant, which is also a fine capsule review of the entire film. There are some notable names in the supporting cast, including the always luminous Natalie Baye (Venus Beauty / Tell No One) as Lawrence's dismissive mother, crushing what he sees as a major heart-rending confession to her with a skilfully-timed put-down, and Monia Chokri (also in Dolan's Heartbeats) as his equally confused and alarmed best friend Stéfanie, these are largely incidental characters, the film largely focusing on Laurence and his multiple costume changes over two and three-quarter hours, before a surprisingly dark reconciliation capped by a strangely ambivalent coda. Dolan's films have divided audiences, some thinking them to be daring and challenging black comedy / dramas, while others believe them too pretentious and precious for words, but his fan base is building steadily, even as the length of his movies is also expotentionally extending.