Film details

Maniac  2012

Cast

  • Nora Arnezeder
  • America Olivo
  • Liane Balaban
  • Morgane Slemp
  • Sammi Rotibi
  • Genevivre Alexandra
  • Sal Landi
  • Megan Duffy
  • Bryan Lugo
  • Jan Broberg
  • Steffinnie Phrommany

Synopsis

A Midnight Screening at the 2012 Cannes Film Festival, Maniac, the remake of William Lustig's notorious 1980 outing, directed by Franck Khalfoun (P2) and co-produced by French enfants terrible Alexandre Aja and Grégory Levasseur (Switchblade Romance / The Hills Have Eyes remake), achieved notoriety by managing to provoke some critics to say that it was even more brutal, sadistic and bleakly nihilistic than Lustig's film, which still, thirty-two years on, remains some sort of landmark in the slasher film canon. The story of a psycho, Frank Zito, played in the original by the late Joe Spinell, the withdrawn owner of a mannequin store, with a fetish for scalps, hunting and killing woman and scalping them, putting the 'trophies' on his dummies, Maniac was all the more shocking for being deliberatly artlessly directed, Lustig, a competant helmer, doing nothing to add suspence, tension or any sort of visual inventiveness, instead just letting the extended scenes of murder and scalping play out in horrendous, painful detail, the flat, rigid photography and Tom Savini's for-the-time stunning effects making the audience as complicit in Zito's killings as the man himself. One wonders what an auteur such as Dario Argento would have done with the material, and interstingly Argento's partner Daria Nicolodi was the original casting for the female lead, eventually played by Caroline Munro. With rumours that the pic would be in 3D being dispelled, Khalfoun plays much of the film from the killer's POV, he being barely seen in the first half hour, and then revealed to be Frodo himself, Elijah Wood, who is as far from the heavy, sweaty, pock-marked Spinell as could be imagined, but as the international trailer shows, this version is equally if not more unflinching in the violence stakes, the trailer having several segments which could redefine the acronym NSFW as Not Safe For Watching, the scene of a victim having her achilles' tendon cut being just the beginning. The casting of Wood at least makes the plot development of him becoming involved with a young artist, Anna (Nora Arnezeder - Safe House), making more sende than the Beauty And The Beast relationship between Spinell and Munro, and as with Spinell's take on the character he is plagued by flashbacks of the neglect he suffered at the hands of his late prostitute mother (America Olivo - Friday The 13th remake), with whom he remains obsessed. Described by even those who were more generally well disposed towards it as sadistic and relentlessly gruelling, trade paper Variety were not exactly amoured with it, calling it a 'merciless work of anti-entertainment is arguably admirable for being as disturbingly disgusting as it wants to be', but also points out the fact that to release it in the version screened in Cannes is unthinkable, the film having to be massively cut in order to secure the all important R rating, meaning either going out unrated, majorly limiting the number of possible bookings, or bypassing cinemas altogether. Wood's casting may actually be a clever touch, although he still looks pretty wacko in the footage seen so far, since one may not think him capable of what the film escalates towards, and Khalfoun's film has at least been praised for better technical qualities, the photography of New York alleys and subway stations by Maxime Alexandre (Catacombs / Silent Hill 3D) apparently being particularly effective, and far more visual than Lustig's overlit stagings, but this also looks to be very hard going indeed, and those not used to real hardcore horror should probably give this a mile-wide berth. (And is anyone else just irked by how Aja and Levasseur have an above-average number of pretentious one-namers involved in their films, composer Roy, art director dooner, editor Baxter, or is it just us?)

Production

Director
Franck Khalfoun
Producer
Alexandre Aja, Grégory Levasseur, Thomas Langmann and William Lustig
Art Director
Dooner
Editor
Baxter
Music
'Rob' (Robin Coudert)
Screenplay
Alexandre Aja and Grégory Levasseur, based on the original screenplay of the 1980 film Maniac, written by C.A. Rosenberg and Joe Spinell, directed by William Lustig
Director of Photography
Maxime Alexandre

Review

French writer / director Alexander Aja and writing partner Grégory Levasseur have established themselves in Hollywood after their superb if ultimately cheating Switchblade Romance, but seem to be stuck with remakes, retooling Wes Craven's The Hills Have Eyes, the Korean Mirrors and Joe Dante's Piranha, so it seems almost logical that their next move should be a French-produced, L.A-set remake of William Lustig's notorious 1980 slasher Maniac, handing the directing chores over to Franck Khalfoun, who helmed their 2007 underground car park thriller P2. The result is a very strange, very unpleasant film, but not without its' bizarre technical and modest artistic merits, which isn't something which could have been said of the Lustig original, which featured screen heavy turned cult actor Joe Spinell in his character defining role, and Spinell died in 1989 just as the proposed Maniac II was about to go into production. It's obvious that Aja and Levasseur love the original but also realise that the screenplay is dreadful, so ditch quite a bit of it, including the grisly if illogical scene of a couple being shotgunned in a car and the ridiculous graveyard climax, for a rather more believable scenario while still sticking to the basic story. Most interestingly 95% of the pic is from lead Elijah Wood's POV, he only being seen in mirrors, photos and reflective surfaces, except for a very vicious scene in a car park where the director obviously can't resist having Wood seen repeatedly stabbing his victim and then posing with the knife for a dramatic publicity still pose, and brief scenes which seem to be purely his romantic fantasies. At least with Wood and French actress Nora Arnezeder (Paris 36 / Safe House) as Anna, the photographer who becomes friendly with him, mostly through being fascinated by his dummies and the way he tends and mends them, the relationship between herself and 'Frank', only the credits reveal him as Frank Zito, the name of the original character, is actually believable, although Wood's googly eyes, like unset poached eggs, are becoming more and more disconcerting. The violence level is indeed relentless, the scalpings are graphic and in the case of the second victim, Lucie, played by Megan Duffy, who he hooks up with via the internet, horribly slow and tortuous. Its' obvious the film is trying to achieve something other than be a straight remake of the first, and the POV idea works particularly well at the end, when Anna fights back, but the pic also adds a very nasty twist to the original at the end which is very unexpected and just makes it all the more queasy. Khalfoun also cannot resist a scene where Wood, holding a just-removed scalp and knife, is reflected in a car door, perfectly recreating the notorious original US poster. The truly odd aspect comes in the final scenes, which largely replicate the end of the first but, and one has to suppose this counts as a spoiler, so beware, as Frank has his final meltdown, the mannequins which wear the scalps of his victims coming back to life in his mind, as they claw at him, disembowelling him, they rip his face off, which instead of a skull seems to become some sort of white, bleached face which is the image of Joe Spinell, and a lot of viewers are going to be trying to work that one out for a while, a truly odd, fantastical touch in a film which otherwise is grimily gritty, grounded and believable. Variety called it 'anti-entertainment', which is certainly valid, since although well made and ambitious, this is also a gruelling and unpleasant experience which some will just not be able to stomach. Just how violent is it? Well, the final, very bloody scene of the ruthless trailer is actually even before the main title, and there is just an aura of genuine nastiness about much of it. Even in these more relaxed times one is surprised that the BBFC have passed this uncut, since although there is no actual sexual violence, a couple of victims are nude when attacked, and the first half-hour includes some completely gratuitous nudity and topless shots, almost copying Aja's own odd, prurient and childish approach to nudity in his own films. In its' native France it has the '16' rating, the highest non-porn category, which is actually very rarely applied. One has to applaud the Gallic trio for trying to revitalise what they obviously see as a classic, and making a film with a lot more enterprise and endeavour than the 1980 version, which Lustig admitted had little ambition apart from genuinely shocking audiences, but the result is a film which is too arty for the gorehounds, and far, far too gruesome for the arthouse set, and is certainly a cinematic experience, even if it has to come with the strongest possible caveats.