Film details

Won't Back Down  2012

Cast

  • Viola Davis
  • Maggie Gyllenhaal
  • Oscar Isaac
  • Emily Alyn Lind
  • Rosie Perez
  • Dante Brown
  • Lance Reddick
  • Ving Rhames
  • Ned Eisenberg
  • Marianne Jean-Baptiste

Synopsis

Despite having an undeniably impressive cast, including Viola Davis (The Help), Maggie Gyllenhaal (Crazy Heart / Hysteria), Holly Hunter (The Incredibles / TV's Saving Grace) and Oscar Isaac (Drive), school-set drama Won't Back Down certainly made headlines during its' brief US theatrical run, being produced by Walden Media, owned by conservative billionaire Philip Anschutz, a major backer of private 'for profit' schools, a line the British government is now pursuing, and gaining some quite dumbfounded reviews, with many being surprised that not only should a film depict teachers and tutors as the villains of the piece, for having such seditious views as actually wanting a living wage for the job, but selectively displaying reviews in their publicity push which bore no resemblance to anything in the main stream press, eventually being revealed to have come from websites and been posted by staffers from the extreme conservative StudentsFirst organization, who did not identify their affiliation but were traced back to the association. Directed by Daniel Barnz (Beastly), the pic has two Pittsburgh mothers, barmaid Jamie Fitzpatrick (Gyllenhaal) and Nona Alberts (Davis), the latter being a teacher, wanting to transform the school their children go to, but finding their input is seen by interference by the teachers (boo!) and the teaching unions (double boo!) and, the very, very worst of all, other parents who don't share their viewpoint. They decide to 'take back' the school, and as the ad-line says 'Because this is for their children, they won't back down from the enormous challenge'. US reviews, even from mildly right-leaning papers, were pretty condemning, The New York Times believing the film casting the teachers as the bad guys reveals 'a political agenda in overdrive.… a mighty cataract of speechifying and breathless plot turns,' while The Los Angeles Times calls teacher's unions as 'the most pernicious of all the obstacles to healthy schools,' and as such 'makes perfect sense to companies that believe in unionless, private charter schools that increase profits by paying teachers whatever they can get away with.' And the film did set a remarkable record, opening with the lowest ever US total for a film opening on 2500+ screens, taking a detention-worthy $2.6m (@£1.61m) from 2515 screens, an average of $1,035 (@£641), staggeringly low for such a wide-release with the attendant heavy marketing push. Having completely misjudged the audience potential in this, Walden Media then almost did the unthinkable only four weeks later with the release of their Chasing Mavericks, a heavily Christian-slanted 'inspirational' tale, only fractionally bettering Won't Back Down, Mavericks taking $2.26m (@£1.4m) from 2002 screens for a dire average of $1,133 (@£706) in twelfth, suggesting that although there may be a market on certain cable and TV channels for these po-faced, Christian 'inspirational' dramas, there certainly isn't in cinemas.

Production

Director
Daniel Barnz
Producer
Mark Johnson
Art Director
Mark Kosko
Editor
Kristina Boden
Music
Marcelo Zarvos
Screenplay
Brin Hill and Daniel Barnz
Director of Photography
Roman Osin

Review

Despite having an impressive cast, school-set drama Won't Back Down certainly made headlines during its' brief US theatrical run, being produced by Walden Media, owned by ultra-conservative billionaire Philip Anschutz, a major backer of private 'for profit' schools, a line the British government is now pursuing, and gaining some quite dumbfounded reviews, with many being surprised that not only should a film depict teachers and tutors as the villains of the piece, for having such seditious views as actually wanting a living wage for the job, but selectively displaying glowing and gushing reviews in their publicity push which bore no resemblance to anything in the mainstream press, eventually being revealed to have come from websites and been posted by staffers from the extreme conservative StudentsFirst organization, who did not identify their affiliation but were traced back to the association. Directed by Daniel Barnz (Beastly), the pic has two Pittsburgh mothers, barmaid Jamie Fitzpatrick (Gyllenhaal) and Nona Alberts (Davis), the latter being a teacher, wanting to transform the school their children go to, but finding their input is seen by interference by the teachers and the teaching unions, very much portrayed as the villains of the piece, and, the very, very worst of all, other parents who don't share their viewpoint. They decide to 'take back' the school, and as the ad-line says 'Because this is for their children, they won't back down from the enormous challenge', and yes, that feeling is the bile rising in your craw. What is so surprising that such a cast should be involved in something so surprisingly uncinematic, the film's arguments being made in long, static scenes where there isn't dialogue as much as great slabs of polemic and speechifying, and the subplot, that all worker's unions are evil Communist cabals, determined to stop owners and managers squeezing everything they can out of resources and workers, while paying whatever they can get away with, isn't even particularly well shaded. What is a very political film with a very hardline right-wing message is here disguised as a heartwarming 'inspiration' film about struggling, caring, positively saintly parents, but the disguise is flimsy to put it mildly, even if it hides behind the 'Inspired by actual events' tag which becomes less and less credible with every use. And Won't Back Down did set a remarkable record, opening with the lowest ever US total for a film opening on 2500+ screens, taking a detention-worthy $2.6m (@£1.61m) from 2515 screens, an average of $1,035 (@£641), staggeringly low for such a wide release with the attendant heavy marketing push, a $20 million budget and a name cast. Having completely misjudged the audience potential in this, Walden Media then almost did the unthinkable only four weeks later with the release of their Chasing Mavericks, a heavily Christian-slanted 'inspirational' tale, only fractionally bettering Won't Back Down, Mavericks taking $2.26m (@£1.4m) from 2002 screens for a dire average of $1,133 (@£706) in twelfth, suggesting that although there may be a market on certain dedicated cable and TV channels for these po-faced, Christian 'inspirational' dramas, there certainly isn't in cinemas, where something as facile as Won't Back Down, pushing its' own agenda behind the facade of something else entirely, sets off audience's bullshit detectors immediately.