Film details

F for Fake  1975

Vérités Et Mensonges / F Wie Falschung / About Fakes

Cast

  • Oja Kodar
  • Elmyr de Hory
  • François Reichenbach
  • Clifford Irving
  • Paul Stewart
  • Joseph Cotten
  • 'Sasa Devcic' (Alexander Welles)
  • Richard Wilson
  • Gary Graver
  • Andrés Vicente Gómez
  • Françoise Widhoff

Synopsis

Orson Welles is the director and on-screen presenter of this documentary primarily dealing with the life and works of notorious Hungarian-born art forger Elmyr de Hory, known to be particularly adept at faking the works of Henri Matisee, among many others, and for whom it is believed his forgeries have been accepted as the real works of certain artists and which hang in most of the galleries and major private collections around the world, undetected. De Hory claims that his deception is nothing compared to that of art dealers, claiming to have sold over a thousand forgeries to major dealers and salerooms around the world, all of them knowing they were fakes, and claims that he is living in a villa in Ibiza due to a dealer wanting to show some sort of recompense. Welles is joined by writer and journalist Clifford Irving, his biographer, the author of the 1969 book Fake!: The Story Of Elmyr de Hory, The Greatest Art Forger Of Our Time. Between the original ending of filming of the Welles project, the involvement of Irving with the faked Howard Hughes 'authorised biography' scandal, causing Welles to recommence shooting, interpolating the story of Irving's own, discovered forgery. At the hour point Welles promises to the audience that everything to follow in the film is absolutely true, and tells of his lover and collaborator Oja Kodar, sitting for a series of nude portraits by Pablo Picasso, having him agree to give her the originals, and she then selling not the originals but forgeries based on them, painted by her grandfather, an infamous Yugoslav forger. Welles starts to suggest that if a forger, such as himself, responsible for the famous War Of The Worlds radio broadcast of 30th October 1938, promises to tell the truth, should he be trusted, and can any example of art, in almost any form, also ever be regarded as unimpeachibly genuine?

Production

Director
Orson Welles (uncredited - and Gary Graver, Oja Kodar and François Reichenbach)
Producer
Dominique Antoine (uncredited )
Art Director
Not credited
Editor
Marie-Sophie Dubus and Dominique Engerer (uncredited - with Orson Welles)
Music
Michel Legrand
Screenplay
Orson Welles (uncredited - with Oja Kodar)
Director of Photography
François Reichenbach

Review

Orson Welles' last major big-screen venture before his death in 1985, aged only 70, F For Fake is both a documentary, a narrative feature and, one starts to realise it includes a number of tricks, subtle and otherwise, played on the audience, all done with style and good humour, and resulting in a quite remarkable and engrossing piece of work. Although ostensibly dealing with the life and works of art forget Elmyr de Hory, already the subject of a seemingly unfinished documentary by François Reichenbach, much footage from which Welles interpolates here with Reichenbach's agreement and shooting his own new footage, F For Fake soon widens its brief to look at the idea of forgery and illusion, in art, literature, even architecture, Welles focusing not only on de Hory but also writer and journalist Clifford Irving, who with a beautiful symmetry was later exposed as a hoaxer himself with the faked Howard Hughes memoirs. One starts to take everything Welles is telling the audience on trust, and for a documentary dealing with such a potentially dry subject Welles makes it remarkably entertaining, as the man was, his gravelly gravitas hiding a genuinely boisterous good humour, as anyone who has seen the superb documentary The Orson Welles Story, made for the BBC Arena series in 1982, directed by Francis Megrahy, will attest, but when after an hour he introduces Oja Kodar, his then-lover and collaborator, the film takes a definite turn, telling a story of forgery and deception from her own past, the technique also altering, the editing speeding up, the photography, regular collaborator Gary Graver being one of the photographers, and one is cleverly reminded that Welles himself started his career by forgery and hoaxes, fabricating a resume which got him some of his first acting jobs, and then pulling off one of the hoaxes of the century, the 1938 War Of The Worlds radio broadcast, called by some 'the night which panicked America', which conveniently became the title of a 1975 TV movie about the broadcast and the genuine fear and distress it caused in some. The editing and pacing of the film is crucial, and it is believed that Welles and his collaborators worked for over a year on the final cut. F For Fake is a remarkably difficult film to summarise, mainly because of the false trails it lays, the diversions it takes, and the obvious sheer fun Welles is having, both on screen and with his audience, leading them by the nose. Some may find it too tricksy, too self-consciously arty and too clever for its' own good, but it is all redeemed by Welles, who is clearly enjoying himself, and is determined to eventually share that glee with his audience, even if they sould be warned to question everything. A 'free-form' documentary certainly, but a genuine reminder that Welles was not only a great actor but an amazing interlect, and it is to Hollywood eternal damnation that they just couldn't recognise genius when it was literally sitting on their doorstep.