Cast
-
Christopher Nolan
-
-
-
Steven Soderbergh
-
James Cameron
-
David Fincher
-
Robert Rodriguez
-
Danny Boyle
-
George Lucas
-
Lana Wachowski
-
Andy Wachowski
-
Robert Rodruguez
-
David Lynch
-
Vittorio Storaro
-
Michael Ballhaus
-
Anthony Dod Mantle
-
Anne V. Coates
-
Wally Pfister
-
Vilmos Zsigmond
-
Synopsis
Although written and directed by Christopher Kenneally, maker of the gloriously-named documentary Crazy Legs Conti: Zen And The Art Of Competitive Eating, it is Keanu Reeves, of all people who has been getting surprising praise in this fascinating-sounding documentary, being the film's narrator, on-screen interviewer, and perhaps the reason why so many directors who are usually a little camera-shy, such as Lana and Andy Wachowski, actually appear on screen to contribute. The subject matter is surprisingly provocative, the switch from celluloid film to digital, for photography and exhibition, and how filmmakers use and manipulate it, and whether it is ruining the moving image, or whether, like the progression from silent to sound, and black and white to colour, it is just a natural progression, and apparently reeves does very well with the task of Devil's Advocate, asking the right sort of questions to get thoughtful and evocative answers from the subjects. It goes beyond just the filming and showing of digital over celluloid, but whether using digital means that directors can film far more than they would on celluloid, since it costs noting to process and is immediate, and whether the extensive amount of post-production which can be done on computers, from colour correction to erasing blemishes and generally being able to alter any and every single pixel in the frame essentially cheating, since it takes away the director's necessity to actually try to get the right short the first time. The line-up of those involved is bordering on majestic, and all of them have something to say, particularly Christopher Nolan, who while promoting The Dark Knight Rises was very vehement about not only never using 3D or shooting a feature on video, but also claiming that the switch to digital is purely for the ease of convenience for distributors and cinema chains, and not for any particular advance in technical excellence or image quality; it just meant companies didn't have to send heavy cans of film up and down the country and cinemas didn't have to train and employ projectionists, since almost anyone, usually one of the front-of-house staff, who could operate a DVD player could now be a 'digital projectionist', and ironically during eh filming of TDKR it was announced that the last company actually making 35mm professional film cameras was finally closing down. There are of course a couple of regrettable interviewees, including Robert Rodriguez, who hails the digital image over the celluloid, but while it enables him to replicate the authentic look of the comic book with Sin City, it also allowed him to make Spy Kids 3 & 4, two films for which the critics were particularly condemning in their reviews about the filming, the digital image looking cheap, metallic and inherently low-grade. As well as having that enviable line-up of directors, most of whom deserve the dedicated documentary treatment themselves, there is a terrific array of veteran cameraman, including Nolan's regular DoP Wally Pfister, triple-Oscar winner Vittorio Storaro (Apocalypse Now / Reds / The Last Emperor), Michael Ballhaus (Goodfellas / Bram Stoker's Dracula) Vilmos Zsigmond (Close Encounters Of The Third Kind / The Deer Hunter), and interestingly Anthony Dod Mantle (28 Days Later... / The Last King Of Scotland), a DoP who has specialised in digital since the format was still new and relatively untested, as well as Anne V. Coates, the British veteran editor, now in her late eighties, who has worked on such landmark movies as Tunes Of Glory and Lawrence Of Arabia. Nolan may be in the minority, and will perhaps one day have to work with digital, but his arguments against it are, one has to day, unarguable, and that the film world is making the change simply because it reduces the bottom line all round, with little thought for the actual image itself, or the pleasure cinema is meant to give the audience.
Production
- Director
- Christopher Kenneally
- Producer
- Keanu Reeves and Justin Szlasa
- Art Director
- Not credited
- Editor
- Malcolm Hearn and Brendan Ryan
- Music
- Bill Ryan and Brendan Ryan, Ryan Bros. Music
- Screenplay
- Christopher Kenneally
- Director of Photography
- Chris Cassidy
Review
Although written and directed by Christopher Kenneally, maker of the gloriously-named documentary Crazy Legs Conti: Zen and the Art of Competitive Eating, it is Keanu Reeves, of all people who deserves praise in this fascinating documentary, being the film's narrator, on-screen interviewer, and perhaps the reason why so many directors who are usually a little camera-shy, such as Lana and Andy Wachowski, actually appear on screen to contribute. The subject matter is surprisingly provocative, the switch from celluloid film to digital, for photography and exhibition, how filmmakers use and manipulate it, whether it is ruining the moving image or, like the progression from silent to sound, and black and white to colour, it is just a natural progression, and Reeves does very well with the task of Devil's Advocate, asking the right sort of questions to get thoughtful and evocative answers from the subjects. It goes beyond just the filming and showing of digital over celluloid, but whether using digital means that directors can film far more than they would on celluloid, since it costs nothing to process and is immediate, and whether the extensive amount of post-production which can be done on computers, from colour correction to erasing blemishes and generally being able to alter any and every single pixel in the frame, is essentially cheating, since it takes away the director's necessity to actually try to get the right shot the first time. The line-up of those involved is bordering on majestic, and all of them have something to say, particularly Christopher Nolan, who while promoting The Dark Knight Rises was very vehement about not only never using 3D or shooting a feature on video, but also claiming that the switch to digital is purely for the ease of convenience for distributors and cinema chains, and not for any particular advance in technical excellence or image quality; it just meant companies didn't have to send heavy cans of film up and down the country and cinemas didn't have to train and employ projectionists, since almost anyone, usually one of the front-of-house staff, who could operate a DVD player could now be a 'digital projectionist'. There are of course a couple of regrettable interviewees, including Robert Rodriguez, who hails the digital image over celluloid, even when Reeves openly challenges his defence of an early model Sony camera, but while digital technology enables him to replicate the authentic look of the comic book with Sin City, it also allowed him to make Spy Kids 3 & 4, two films for which the critics were particularly condemning in their reviews about the filming, the digital image looking cheap, metallic and like a badly tuned-in TV, raising tangentally the notion that the ease of use and relative cheapness of digital equipment is essentially allowing films which really should not have been made, to come into existence, and the most ham-fisted hack to believe themselves to be a film director. As well as having that enviable line-up of directors, most of whom deserve the dedicated documentary treatment themselves, there is a terrific array of veteran cameraman, including Nolan's regular DoP Wally Pfister, who makes his opinion on digital 3D perfectly clear, triple-Oscar winner Vittorio Storaro (Apocalypse Now / Reds / The Last Emperor), Michael Ballhaus (Goodfellas / Bram Stoker's Dracula) Vilmos Zsigmond (Close Encounters of the Third Kind / The Deer Hunter), and interestingly Anthony Dod Mantle (28 Days Later... / The Last King Of Scotland), a DoP who has specialised in digital since the format was still new and relatively untested, and becoming the first to win a Best Cinematography Oscar for a feature shot on digital, for Slumdog Millionaire, as well as Anne V. Coates, the British veteran editor, now in her late eighties, who worked on such landmark movies as Tunes of Glory and Lawrence of Arabia, all resolutely shot on celluloid, with all its' alleged drawbacks, simply because there wasn't any alternative. Nolan may be in the minority, and will perhaps one day be forced to work with digital simply because celluloid won't be an option, but his arguments against it are, one has to say, unarguable, and that the film world is making the change simply because it reduces the bottom line all round, with little thought for the actual image itself, or the pleasure cinema is meant to give the audience. Kenneally and Reeves' oddly engaging film ends on notes of optimism, with most of the filmmakers believing the medium itself will continue to thrive because of the devotion and dedication of those involved, but it is also clear that many of those involved believe too much is being lost, and not enough gained.