Film details

Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence in the House of God  2012

Cast

  • Jamey Sheridan Voice
  • John Slattery Voice
  • Chris Cooper Voice
  • Matthew Ryan Hughes
  • Larry Hunt
  • Donagh Gleason
  • Antony Toron
  • Aaron Ballard
  • Brady Bryson
  • Kyle Donnery
  • Alexander Primavera

Synopsis

St. John's School For The Deaf, an institution run by the Catholic Church in the St. Francis district of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. 1972, and Terry Kohut, a former pupil and resident, writes to cardinal Angelo Sodano, informing him how he and a large number of other boys, all deaf, were repeatedly sexually abused by Father Lawrence Murphy, the Director of the school, asking him to take the matter forward to The Vatican and The Pope. He does not receive any sort of reply. With three other pupils who were similarly abused, Gary Smith, Pat Kuehn and Arthur Budzinski, repeated try to bring the matter to light, trying to get some sort of official action from church and civil bodies and authorities, over the next three decades, all to no avail. The Church repeatedly blocks and obstructs their efforts to publicise what happen and bring Father Murphy to justice, forcing them to make the dramatic gesture of printing 'Wanted' posters with Murphy's face on them and handing them out to passers-by. Over the years more cases of child abuse by Catholic priests come to light in the US and across Europe, the Church at first trying to suppress all coverage in the media, then responding by angrily denying all charges, blaming liberal and secular media for wanting to smear the reputation of the Catholic Church, and gradually and selectively admitting to certain instances. The case of Father Murphy and the St. John's School is taken up by others, within and separate from the Church, who persist in trying to get some form of recognition from the Vatican itself, which still resists all petitions and efforts to admit to the mounting abuse scandal. Murphy is forced to retire from the school, the cause being officially given as 'on health grounds', but is moved on by then Milwaukee Archbishop William Cousins to Superior, Wisconsin, where he worked in parishes, schools and a juvenile-detention centre. With the increasing publicity, The Vatican became increasingly aware of the sheer number of accusations against Catholic priests globally, Pope John Paul II being made aware of them, as was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later to become Pope Benedict XVI, who ordered that all accusations and details of such cases be reported directly to him. Before a canonical trial could be held against Murphy he died in 1998. He is believed to have molested more than 200 boys in various schools and Church-run institutions. Despite the increasing number of cases and charges being levelled at the Catholic Church, few priests are ever investigated, resulting in the carefully-worded statement made by Pope Benedict in 2010, which many critics said was neither an apology or explanation for why so little was done over decades of awareness. The Catholic Church in the US has so far paid out over $2 billion in damages to victims to the end of 2011, but refuses to accept or acknowledge that any of its' members was involved in any impropriety.

Production

Director
Alex Gibney
Producer
Alex Gibney, Jedd Wider, Todd Wider, Alexandra Johnes, Kristen Vaurio and Sara Bernstein
Art Director
Gonzalo Cordoba
Editor
Sloane Klevin
Music
Robert Logan and Ivor Guest
Screenplay
Alex Gibney
Director of Photography
Lisa Rinzler

Review

Alex Gibney is certainly one of the most impressive and committed documentarists currently working, with such memorable projects as Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room ('05), Who Killed The Electric Car ('06), Client 9: The Rise And Fall Of Eliot Spitzer ('10) and the Oscar-winning Taxi To The Dark Side to his credit, as well as being one of the most prolific, directing or producing more than forty documentaries since his first, The Ruling Classroom, in 1980, and in many ways Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence In The House Of God is one of the most horrifying Gibney has ever worked on, exploring the issue of paedophilia and decades of subsequent methodical cover-ups in the Catholic Church, beginning with one of the first known protests against clerical sexual abuse in the United States, which the Church effectively stifled, and following it all the way to the Vatican. The focus is on St. John's School For The Deaf in St Johns, Wisconsin, where the parish priest, Father Lawrence C. Murphy, abused deaf boys for more than 25 years, with as many as two hundred victims. Despite protests and deputations from the victims and their parents, as well as some American Archbishops, worried that the good Father could be an 'embarrassment', the Vatican refused to do anything, the official it was specifically brought to being the then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later to become Pope Benedict XVI, the story only being exposed by four deaf men who had all been his victims as young boys, and who vowed to bring him to justice. Gibney takes this glaring case of criminal omission to examine the whole fraught and hideous child abuse scandal, and how the Vatican has tried everything from persuasion to all-out threats to keep it covered up, and even issuing detailed instructions to priests and church staff how to deal with such accusations by not going to the Police or involving the forces of law and order in any way. With an impressive voice cast, including Jamey Sheridan (TV's Homeland / Arrow), John Slattery (TV's Mad Men), Chris Cooper (The Horse Whisperer / Breach) and Ethan Hawke (Gattaca / Sinister) giving readings of testimonies and legal documents pertaining to the cases, Gibney's film calmly and chillingly shows just how the Catholic Church was far more concerned with preserving its' image and more importantly its' assets rather than the care of vulnerable young children, going so far as to turn a blind eye to child molesting priests who in some cases abused generations of the same family, although the 'recreations' of some incidents in the boys' time in the school are perhaps a little overly melodramatic, the fact that they were not taken seriously when they complained because the school tacitly equated deafness with some sort of mental deficiency is yet something else which does the church no favours whatsoever. With remarkably apt timing, Gibney's film opened in the UK just as a Scottish Bishop admitted to 'inappropriate conduct' following complaints by a number of young priests, and Pope Benedict himself decided to break precedent and stand down, claiming ill health, many commentators reviving his history in the cover-up of sexual abuse in the church going back decades, emphasising that Mea Maxima Culpa delves into a truly appalling scandal which the Vatican seems to be in no hurry to either fully confront or apologise for except in the broadest, most facile and non-legally binding terms.