Film details

Stories We Tell  2012

Film still

Cast

  • Michael Polley
  • Diane Polley
  • Mark Polley
  • Joanna Polley
  • Rebecca Jenkins
  • Andrew Church
  • Seamus Morrison
  • Mairtin O'Carrigan
  • Alex Hatz
  • Justin Goodhand
  • Peter Evans

Synopsis

Early on in Stories We Tell, Joanna Polley, sister of the director, actress and filmmaker Sarah Polley, asks 'Who f*cking cares about our family?,' the film concerning itself with the Polley family and their network of close and distant relatives, encouraging them to talk about the complicated relationship between her parents, her father, British-born actor Michael Polley, and her mother, stage actress and later casting director Diane MacMillan, the pair having five children, of whom Joanna and Sarah are just two. Although one may be rightly skeptical about the validity, and indeed endurability, of such a project, Polley, director of the very creditable Talk To Her and Take This Waltz, gradually unveils a quite remarkable story of a relationship, the pair being together for more than a decade, Diane eventually dying of cancer two days after Sarah's 11th birthday in 1990, but as has been revealed by other sources, there is a major, startling twist involved in this story which was only discovered later, and which one suspects some of the family are still trying to cope with, and audiences are advised to 'go in blind' as it were so as not to derail Polley's careful building up to a event which many families would be completely unable to deal with. Although the real Diana appears in several real Super 8 home movies shot by the family, there are authentic-looking recreations, also shot on Super 8 and featuring actress Rebecca Jenkins as Diana, and seem to be there to provide visual accompaniment to some of the anecdotes, The film clearly revolves around Diane, but the way there are different memories of her from different relatives, some saying her impulsive nature was spontaneous, others saying she was calculatingly provocative, go to emphasise Polley's point that memories, even of those one is closest to, can be misleading, even in vital events, so while one interviewee insists that Diane knew she was dying, another insists that she had no idea. Coming to the point that the truth is always coloured by the point-of-view of those recalling it, a human quality used for dramatic events in such fictional works, when an event is seen from differing standpoints, each one being convinced that they have the definite account, although in this case the most authentic voice seems to be that of Michael Polley. More a film essay than any sort of factual documentary, and with Polley being obviously worried that revealing her family's secrets might seem to some to be an embarrassing act of narcissism, Stories We Tell is very far from that, a compelling story in which the fallibility of those involved, in several ways, is both fascinating end eventually moving.

Production

Director
Sarah Polley
Producer
Anita Lee
Art Director
Lea Carlson
Editor
Mike Munn
Music
Jonathan Goldsmith
Screenplay
Sarah Polley
Director of Photography
Iris Ng