Film details

11'09"01 - September 11  2002

Film still

Cast

  • <b>(1)</b> Maryam Karimi
  • <b>(2)</b> Emmanuelle Laborit
  • <b>(3)</b> Nour El-Cherif
  • <b>(4)</b> Dzana Pinjo
  • <b>(5)</b> Lionel Zizreel Guire
  • <b>(6)</b> Vladimir Vega

Synopsis

1 - A female teacher on the Iran / Afghanistan border tries to tell her class of youngsters of the significance of the WTC bombings, but they seem to fail to grasp the importance when she asks for a moment of silence for the victims.

2 - A deaf woman in New York on the morning of September 11 writes a letter to her lover, who works as a tour guide for deaf tourists. She writes that she feels their relationship has perhaps run its course, not knowing what has happened to the WTC. He arrives back home, covered in dust and still in shock, but they are reconciled.

3 - Egyptian film director Youssef Chahine watches the events of the day on television, then is visited by the ghost of Donald, a US soldier killed in the Beirut barracks bombing of 1983. Together they visit the family of a Palestianian suicide bomber whose parents are proud of his achievement and sacrifice. They later visit Donald's grave and plant flowers, and are joined by the ghost of the Palestianian bomber.

4 - On September 11 in Serbrnica in Bosnia a woman joins the monthly march to the town hall to protest a massacre which occurred on 11 July 1995. Once at the town hall she finds out what has happened in New York, but the demonstration happens as planned.

5 - Adana, a young boy in Burkina Faso needs to raise money for both medicine for his sick mother and to buy school books. In the aftermath of September 11 he believes he sees someone in town who is Osama Bin Laden, and, remembering the $25 million reward offered by the USA, follows his suspect around with a camera, desperate for evidence, while his friends plan to ambush the man with home-made bows and arrows.

6 - Chilean exile and sometime actor Vladimir Vega writes an open letter to the people of the USA, consoling them on the events of the fateful day but then concentrating on the events of September 11 1971 when Chilean President Salvadore Allende was overthrown in a government coup which Vega claims was CIA organised.

7 - A blank screen gradually fades to white, as Mexican prayer chants are heard on the soundtrack. Flashes of the news footage of bodies falling from the WTC is seen before an Arabic script text caption appears on screen before it reverts once again to black.

8 - After a car bomb detonates in Tel Aviv, a journalist arrives at the scene and relays a live TV broadcast as the emergency teams try to deal with the carnage. She does not know of the breaking news that the World Trade Centre has been attacked, and that her live broadcast has been taken off the air.

9 - Mohamed Salman, a young Pakistani / American disappears on September 11th, and is at first believed to have been one of the hijackers. Months later as the Ground Zero site is cleared his body is found, he having died in the Twin Towers, sacrificing his life to save others.

10 - A lonely widower, still grief-stricken at the death of his wife of many years lives in an apartment near the Twin Towers. After they are demolished for the first time in years light gets into his flat, the view from his window no longer blocked by the WTC. An ailing plant revives, and the old man wishes his wife was around to see what has happened.

11 - Yukichi, a Japanese soldier, arrives back at his village from World War II, but the horrors of war have made him believe he is a snake. The villagers put him in a cage but he escapes and, when his wife tracks him down to the river bank, Yukichi slips into the water and disappears from her sight

Production

Director
<b>(1)</b> Samira Makhmalbaf: <b>(2)</b> Claude Lelouch: <b>(3)</b> Youssef Chahine: <b>(4)</b> Danis Tanovic: <b>(5)</b> Idrissa Ouédraogo: <b>(6)</b> Ken Loach: <b>(7)</b> Alejandro González Iñárritu: <b>(8)</b> Amos Gitai: <b>(9)</b> Mira Nair: <b>(10)</b>...
Producer
(Supervising) Jean De Tregomain <b>(1)</b> Makhmalbaf Film House: <b>(2)</b> Tania Zazulinsky for Les Films 13: <b>(3)</b> Gabriel Khoury and Marianne Khoury for Misr International Films: <b>(4)</b> Cedomir Kolar for Studio Maj: <b>(5)</b> Nicolas Cand f
Art Director
(2) Benoit Cisilkiewick: (3) Hamed Hemdan: (4) Kenal Hristanovic: (5) Malick Boro, Yaya Senou and Marc Vicens: (6) Sarah Blunt, Billy Edwards and Tom Hamilton: (8) Miguel Markin: (9) Stephanie Carroll: (10)...
Editor
(1) Mohsen Makhmalbaf and Mastaneh Mohajer Rassanepouya: (2) Stephane Mazalaigue: (3) Rashida Abd El-Salam: (4) Monique Rysselinck, Gert Janssens and Ingrid Ralet: (5) Julia Gregory, Franck Nakache and Nicolas Cantin:
Music
(Title score) Alexandre Desplat (1) Mohamad Rezadarvishi: (5) Salif Keita, Guem Percussion: (6) Vladimir Vega: (7) Gustavo Santaolalla and Osvaldo Golijov: (9) Abida Parveen: (10) Heitor Periera: (11) Taro
Screenplay
Based on an original idea by Alain Brigand (1) Samira Makhmalbaf: (2) Claude Lelouch and Pierre Uytterhoeven: (3) Youssef Chahine: (4) Danis Tanovic: (5) Idrissa Ouédraogo: (6) Paul Laverty, Ken Loach and Vladimir Vega: (7) Alejandro González Iñárritu: (8) Amos Gitai and Marie-Jose Sanselme: (9) Sabrina Dhawan: (10) Sean Penn: (11) Diasuke Tengan
Director of Photography
(1) Ebrahim Ghafori: (2) Pierre-William Glenn: (3) Mohsen Nasr: (4) Mustafa Mustafic: (5) Luc Drion: (6) Nigel Willoughby, Peter Hellmich and Jorge Muller Silva: (8) Yoav Kosh: (9) Declan Quinn: (10)...

Review

When a Chinese UN official was asked what effect he thought the French Revolution had on the world he replied 'It's far too early to tell'. This would seem to be the obvious reaction to this French-originated project which, when viewed as a whole, smacks of cash-in, with the added gimmick that every 'episode' should last eleven minutes, nine seconds and one frame. The mix of styles is disorienting, from the sentimentality of the Claude Lelouch and Sean Penn episodes, through the barely disguised mocking bile of Ken Loach, the disillusionment of Danis Tanovic and Amos Gitai, at least trying to get some perspective on the events, and the baffling whimsy of Shoehi Imamura. Alejandro González Iñárritu's offering seems to be the sort of shock tactics which would be more at home in a pretentious video installation, and it is left to Mira Nair (Salaam Bombay) to tell the true story of Mohamed Salman, and provide the only evidence of real thought and reasoning in the entire, cobbled-together enterprise.