Film details

The Night of the Generals  1967

Cast

  • Peter O'Toole
  • Omar Sharif
  • Donald Pleasence
  • Tom Courteney
  • Joanna Pettet
  • Philippe Noiret
  • Charles Grey
  • John Gregson
  • Coral Browne
  • Nigel Stock
  • Juliette Greco
  • Michael Goodliffe
  • Gordon Jackson
  • Harry Andrews Uncredited

Synopsis

1942, German-occupied Warsaw, After a prostitute is found brutally murdered, Abwehr Major Grau, aligned with German Intelligence, instigates an investigation, whereas such crimes would usually be ignored by the German-controlled local Police, since the victim was also a German informer, relaying information about the city's resistance movement. Grau's interview with a witness, who partially saw a man leaving the scene of the crime, describes the killer's smart, uniform trousers, which lead Grau to believe the killer is one of three high-ranking Germans: General Herbert von Seidlitz-Gabler; General Klaus Kahlenberge, his chief of staff, or General Wilhelm Tanz, the only three in the city at the time of the crime. When news reaches the three that they are under investigation, they have Grau transferred from Warsaw to Paris and the case is closed.

July 1944. Paris is a hub of activity as the tide of war starts to turn against the Third Reich. There are rumours of a plot to assassinate Hitler and involving a group of senior officers. Von Seidlitz-Gabler, Kahlenberge and Tanz meet again in the French capital. Tanz is unaware of any plot against the Fuhrer and remains devoted to Hitler, but Kahlenberge is deeply involved with the other conspirators, believing Hitler has to die in order for Germany to secure a negotiated peace. Von Seidlitz-Gabler knows but remains uninvolved, waiting for further developments.

One night Tanz summons his driver, Lance Corporal Kurt Hartmann, to find him a prostitute and bring her back to his commandeered quarters. Tanz ruthlessly butchers her, but has committed the hideous crime in a way so as to frame Hartmann. Presenting Hartmann with the evidence, he offers him a way of deserting, vanishing into the maelstrom of occupied Europe, which Hartmann accepts. When the body is discovered, news reaches Grau, now a Lieutenant Colonel, who examines the evidence, realising that the killing was carried out in the same method as the Warsaw victim, and deduces through a process of elimination that the killer is Tanz.

The following day, July 20th, Grau arranges an interview with Tanz, and is about to accuse him of the murder, when news breaks of an assassination attempt on Hitler, a bomb placed in a briefcase exploding near him at The Wolf's Lair, the Eastern Front military headquarters near the East Prussian town of Rastenburg, but Hitler has survived, In the panic and confusion, Tanz turns on Grau, murdering him and claiming he was one of the assassination plotters. Tanz is believed, as thousands are rounded up in the following weeks and summarily executed.

1965. Interpol Inspector Morand investigates the death of a prostitute in Hamberg, convinced that it is connected to a murder investigated back in 1942 by Major Grau. Morand holds a debt of gratitude to the late German, who discovered his involvement with the French Resistance but did not reveal it to the authorities. He reopens the cold case, and uncovers a link to the 1944 Paris murder. He finds Grau had identified three main suspects, and starts to look at all three, determined to settle the debt of honour he owes the late Major...

Production

Director
Anatole Litvak
Producer
Anatole Litvak and Sam Spiegel
Art Director
Auguste Capelier
Editor
Alan Osbiston
Music
Maurice Jarre
Screenplay
Joseph Kessel and Paul Dehn, additional dialogue by Paul Dehn, based on the novel Die Nacht Der Generale by Hans Hellmut Kirst, based on an incident written by James Hadley Chase
Director of Photography
Henri Decaë

Review

A handsomely staged, high-budget hybrid of an occasionally deeply vicious thriller set against the background of occupied wartime Europe, and with a terrific cast of some of the best character actors of the Fifties and Sixties, The The Night of the Generals, is a languidly paced piece of work from veteran writer / producer Anatole Litvak (Sorry, Wrong Number / Decision Before Dawn), running nearly two and a half hours, and is also a very adult drama, not flinching from the rather grim subject matter. Co-produced by Sam Spiegel, responsible for such films as The African Queen ('51), On The Waterfront ('54) and The Bridge On The River Kwai ('57), the sort of big and flamboyant movie producer who just doesn't seem to exist any more, both leads Peter O'Toole and Omar Sharif were apparently initially uneasy at making the film, but did it as a favour to Spiegel, who had made them huge stars with his earlier production, the 1962 cinematic milestone Lawrence Of Arabia.

The script, beginning in occupied Warsaw in 1942 before moving to Paris in '44, and concluding some two decades later, covers genuine events, such as the von Stauffenberg plot to assassinate Hitler, an event which would have truly changed Western history were it not for some terrible instances of bad luck, with the fictional, the murder of a Warsaw prostitute being investigated by a German Intelligence officer (Sharif), since the victim was an informer, and narrowing the number of suspects down to three Generals – von Seidlitz-Gabler (Charles Gray – The Devil Rides Out / Diamonds Are Forever), Kahlenberge (the peerless Donald Pleasence) and Tanz (O'Toole). Once the killer is identified, and it really shouldn't be that hard for the average viewer, it becomes a matter of who else he is going to brutally kill and, like so many, will he get away with it in the chaos and confusion of WWII as it starts to turn against the Nazis.

Although based on a bestseller by the hugely successful German novelist Hans Hellmut Kirst, himself a war veteran, the screenplay by Joseph Kessel and Paul Dehn bears the bizarre addition, based on an incident written by James Hadley Chase'. The British writer Chase was one of the top-selling authors of all-time, writing dozens of fast-paced, lurid and hugely popular thrillers in a career lasting from his first published book in 1939 to his last in 1984. Kirst lifted a very recognisable character from Chase's 1952 novel, The Wary Transgressor, that of a crazed General, and used it in his novel Die Nacht Der Generale, first published in 1962. Although Chase was unaware of this he was alerted when the film version was in production and threatened a lawsuit which was eventually settled out of court by both Kirst and Columbia Pictures, and agreed on the rather unconventional addition to the credits.

Litvak gets good use out of an impressive supporting cast, including the excellent Tom Courteney (Billy Liar / 45 Years) as Hartmann, set up to be framed by the killer, Christopher Plummer (The Sound Of Music / Knives Out) as Erwin Rommel, Joanna Pettet (The Group / Robbery), and some very familiar faces from prestige British TV, including John Gregson (The Battle Of The River Plate / TV's Gideon's Way), Nigel Stock (The Great Escape / TV's Owen M.D.), Gordon Jackson (TV's Upstairs Downstairs / The Professionals) and Michael Goodliffe (A Night To Remember / TV's Judge Dee). In a switch from the original novel, Philippe Noiret (The Watchmaker Of St. Paul / Cinema Paradiso) plays the dedicated Inspector Morand from Interpol, whereas in the book the character is a member of the newly formed East German Volkspolizei.

The result is a gripping, grim drama, even at 148 minutes, with some excellent central performances and a constantly uncomfortable atmosphere, although it certainly isn't for everybody, with some extremely brutal scenes, and while now having a 15 rating for its uncut version, it originally was cut by the BBFC and still given the old 'X' certificate.

The pic was virtually remade, unofficially, as the 1988 thriller Saigon (entitled Off Limits in the US), with Willem Defoe and Gregory Hines on the trail of a murderously psychotic officer in the Vietnamese capital in the middle of the Vietnam War, and to a lesser extent as Bruno Mattei's similarly Saigon-set Cop Game, made the same year.