Film details

The Book Thief  2013

Cast

  • Sophie Nélisse
  • Ben Schnetzer
  • Nico Liersch
  • Heike Makatsch
  • Julian Lehmann
  • Barbara Auer
  • Joachim Paul Assböck
  • Sandra Nedeleff
  • Kirsten Block
  • Roger Allum Narrator

Synopsis

April 1938. The Angel of Death narrates his interest in a young German girl, Liesel Meminger, having to live with her foster parents Hans and Rosa Hubermann. Her mother, a Communist, is in danger from the upsurge in violence from the ruling Nazi party against dissenters so she puts Liesel and her brother up for adoption to keep them safe, her brother dies en-route to the Foster home leaving Liesel in a distressed state. Liesel makes an impression on a young neighbour boy, Rudy Steiner, when she arrives. He accompanies her on her first day of school where it is revealed she is unable to read or write and is taunted by her schoolmates, one of them, Franz Deutscher, challenging her to read just one word, Liesel responding by attacking him, which impresses Rudy and making them firm friends. When Hans realizes she cannot read he starts to teach her, using the book that she found at her brother's graveside, she soon becoming obsessed with reading anything she can find. WWII breaks out in September 1939 and Liesel and Rudy become members of the Hitler Youth, but at a book burning ceremony attended by Franz, Liesel is upset at the books being destroyed, and salvages a book from the pyre after everyone has dispersed, but she is seen by the Mayor's wife, Ilsa Hermann. When Hans discovers what she has done he insists she keeps it a secret. Running an errand to the Mayor's house for Rosa, a laundress, Liesel realises the woman who saw her at the bonfire is the Mayor's wife, but instead of betraying her, Ilsa takes her into the library, telling Liesel she is welcome at any time and can read whatever she wants. When the Mayor discovers this he not only forbids Liesel visiting the house, but stops using Rosa as their laundress. After the night of violence against Jewish businesses, known as Kristallnacht, Max Vandenburg and his mother, who are Jewish, are told by a friend that one of them can escape and Max's mother forces him to go to the Hubermann's house where Rosa and Hans give him shelter, Max being the son of the man who saved Hans' life in WWI. Max is allowed to stay in Liesel's room and they begin to become friends, both hating Hitler, as Liesel blames the Fuhrer for taking her mother from her. Max moves to the basement for more space, but falls ill, Liesel reading to him to help him recover. Rudy discovers that Liesel is still sneaking into the Mayor's house to secretly borrow books, and also discovers about Max, after believing her family are harbouring someone, but Franz overhears them and confronts them. Soldiers descend on the Hubermann's house to search for dissenters and they have to hide the young man, but are then told that their basement is being searched to be used as a possible bomb shelter, and find the soldiers were not searching for anyone. Seeing a neighbour and a friend being taken away by the Police because they say he is really a Jew, Hans tries to tell them that the man is a good German but his name is taken by them and he realizes what a mistake he has made, exposing he and his family to suspicion. Max realizes he must leave in order to protect them should they be searched again, just as Hans receives a telegram that he has been called into the Army and must leave immediately. With two people she cares about having to leave, for very different reasons, Liesel feels afraid and truly alone for the first time, especially when he believes she sees Max in a line of Jews being marched through their town on their way to a death camp, and having to be dragged home by Rosa after clashing with German soldiers, Hans returns home injured from a bomb blast which hit his unit's truck, but the family is reunited only for a brief time as the city is bombed with no air raid siren to alert the citizens, and the Hubermann's home is struck with a direct hit....

Production

Director
Brian Percival
Producer
Ken Blancato and Karen Rosenfelt
Art Director
Bill Crutcher
Editor
John Wilson
Music
John Williams
Screenplay
Michael Petroni, based on the novel by Markus Zusak
Director of Photography
Florian Ballhaus

Review

Based on a major and award-winning 'Young Readers' best seller by Marcus Zusak, translated into thirty languages and selling over eight million copies since first being published in 2005, The Book Thief, directed by Brian Percival (TV's The Ruby in The Smoke / Downton Abbey) and adapted by Michael Petroni, shows the problems of translating such a story to the screen, having to tell a story which includes such major and important themes without alienating or terrifying the intended audience, a challenge the film never quite manages to conquer. Dealing with the Holocaust in a story essentially meant for youngsters can be done, such as in the case of John Boyne's novel The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas and the subsequent 2008 film, but the more high-profile production here, complete with an Oscar winner, Geoffrey Rush (Shine) and a double Oscar nominee, Emily Watson (Breaking The Waves / Jackie & Hilary), in the leads, is more intent on focusing on the central character, nine-year-old Liesel Meminger (French-Canadian actress Sophie Nélisse), the illiterate youngster sent to live with her foster parents Hans and Rosa in Munich in 1938, as the path to war was becoming inevitable, and incidents such as the infamous Kristellnacht, the attacks on Jewish businesses and homes made the Third Reich's intentions perfectly clear. Not wanting to focus what is essentially a family film on the intricacies and the machinations of the Nazi party in the early years of the war is perfectly understandable, but director Percival and DoP Florian Ballhaus (The Devil Wears Prada / Hope Springs) perhaps make the warm, protective atmosphere of the Hubermann home, which also becomes a refuge for Jewish Max Vandenburg (Ben Schnetzer - TV's Happy Town), Liesel reading to him in the cellar to give him comfort while he recovers, almost too welcoming and protective, almost like a rather less opulent Downton Abbey Xmas special, and the word 'twinkly', pertaining to both the settings and the performances, has been aptly used by more than a few reviewers, not helped by the fact that the Hubermanns all look a little too well-fed and healthy to really be enduring the conditions they find themselves under, and a score by John Williams, who pointedly won the Oscar for Schindler's List in 1994 only emphasises what the film is trying to emulate but in a less impactful, more family-friendly way. Actors using the sort of 1950's zemi-German accents with the odd Ja and Nein chucked in is also a distraction. The use of Death, in the fruity but menacing tones of Roger Allam (V For Vendetta / TV's The Thick Of It) remains faithful to the book, where He / It is more of an integral narrator, observing the folly of the human race, remains faithful to the book, but also acts as an intrusion and, in many ways, a red herring, and the parallel of Liesel learning to read and having her eyes opened to the world of literature and knowledge, tied to her rejection of Naziism is a little too convenient and obvious. All involved are being almost painfully sincere in their intentions here, but the difficulty of trying to market this to a family audience and still retain the power of the book can be seen in the fact that the film is promoted with the ad-line 'From the studio which brought you The Life Of Pi', showing a complete misunderstanding of the story and allegory being told.