Cast
-
Chadwick Boseman
-
-
Christopher Meloni
-
Nicole Beharie
-
Alan Tudyk
-
John C. McGinley
-
Jon Bernthal
-
Ryan Merriman
-
Toby Huss
-
T.R. Knight
-
Brad Beyer
-
Lucas Black
Synopsis
Although having only a very limited audience outside the US, 42, written and directed by Brian Helgeland (A Knight's Tale / Payback), set a box-office record domestically by taking a strong $27.48m (@£17.88m) in its' opening weekend, the best opening ever for a sports-themed film. While Helgeland has an incredible story to tell, that of Jackie Robinson, the first black player ever to play in Major League Baseball, and the problems, prejudices and outright threats he faced, US critics seemed to agree that the film is so respectful, awe-struck and mythologising that it makes for a rather bland film, omitting many pivotal incidents and also sanitising Robinson's own turbulent private life, all to get the coveted US PG-13 rating. Opting not to choose a more established name but rather find the right man for the part, the makers found Chadwick Boseman, a TV and film bit player with an athlete's frame, and Boseman is getting good notices for his performance as Robinson, who in 1946, first playing for the Kansas City Monarchs of the Negro Leagues, then training with the Montreal Royals farm club, was signed for the Brooklyn Dodgers by the team's General Manager, Branch Rickey (Harrison Ford), made history when he signed Robinson to the team, breaking Major League Baseball's infamous colour bar. The deal also put both Robinson and Rickey in the firing line of the public, the press, other players and even a couple of Dodgers players. Facing unashamed racism from every side, Robinson had to demonstrate restraint by not reacting to any of the provocations, and also to prove his worth by performing on the diamond, knowing that his detractors were eager to pounce on any slip or misstep which could be used against him and Rickey. Helgeland has some solid supporting players, including Christopher Meloni (TV's Law & Order: SUV), Alan Tudyk (Dodgeball / Tucker And Dale Vs Evil) and John C. McGinley (TV's Scrubs), and apparently excellent period detail and observation, but is far too keen on portraying Robinson The Legend rather than Robinson The Man, 42 being the number on his jersey, and despite the circumstances also largely soft-pedals the real danger both Robinson and Rickey found themselves in, both receiving very genuine death threats. There are vignettes showing just what Robinson faced, a gas station attendant refusing to let Robinson and his Negro-league team-mates use the non-coloured bathroom, a Philadelphia hotel not allowing him to stay overnight on a road trip, and fans deluging the Dodgers front office with hate mail, but Robinson swats all these away with the ease of how he swatted away the baseball, avoiding the wider, more serious implications of the situation, and apparently turning what should have been a gritty and thought-provoking drama into hagiography.
Production
- Director
- Brian Helgeland
- Producer
- Thomas Tull
- Art Director
- Aaron Haye (supervisor)
- Editor
- Peter McNulty and Kevin Stitt
- Music
- Mark Isham
- Screenplay
- Brian Helgeland
- Director of Photography
- Don Burgess
Review
Although only drawing a very limited audience outside the US, 42, written and directed by Brian Helgeland (A Knight's Tale / Payback), set a box-office record domestically by setting the best opening ever for a sports-themed film in the US, and although the makers would argue that the film has an appeal simply beyond that of baseball, the fact is that one really has to know the name Jackie Robinson, and at least some baseball history, in order to really get anything out of it. While Helgeland has an incredible story to tell, that of Jackie Robinson, the first black player ever to play in Major League Baseball, and the problems, prejudices and outright danger he faced, the film is so respectful, awe-struck and mythologising that it all makes for a rather bland film, omitting many pivotal incidents and also sanitising Robinson's own turbulent private life, all to get the coveted US PG-13 rating, which all goes to make Robinson less of a determined and brave trailblazer and more of a candidate for canonisation. Opting not to choose a more established name but rather find the right man for the part, the makers found Chadwick Boseman, a TV and film bit player with a believably athletic frame, and Boseman does his best with an at times underwritten part, considering how pivotal Robinson is to the story, first playing for the Kansas City Monarchs of the Negro Leagues, then training with the Montreal Royals farm club, was signed for the Brooklyn Dodgers by the team's General Manager, Branch Rickey (Harrison Ford), made history when he signed Robinson to the team, breaking Major League Baseball's infamous colour bar. The deal also put both Robinson and Rickey in the firing line of the public, the press, rival players and even a couple of his own side. Facing unashamed racism from every side, Robinson had to demonstrate restraint by not reacting to any of the provocations, and also to prove his worth by performing on the diamond, knowing that his detractors were eager to pounce on any slip or misstep which could be used against him and Rickey. Unfortunately the film is far too keen on portraying Robinson The Legend rather than Robinson The Man, 42 being the number on his jersey, and despite the circumstances also largely soft-pedals the real danger both Robinson and Rickey found themselves in, both receiving very genuine death threats. There are vignettes showing just what Robinson faced, but Robinson swats all these away with the ease of how he swatted away the baseball, all backed by Mark Isham's over-emphatic score, avoiding the wider, more serious implications of the situation, and apparently turning what should have been a gritty and thought-provoking drama into hagiography. Helgeland has some solid supporting players, including Christopher Meloni (TV's Law & Order: SUV) and John C. McGinley (TV's Scrubs), with Alan Tudyk (Dodgeball / Tucker And Dale Vs Evil) as Ben Chapman, the coach in one of the most infamous attacks on Robinson during the Philadelphia Philies game, an event which had major repercussions and which years later Chapman said he was truly ashamed off, putting it down to being a 'different time', but even this powerful and hideous moment is diluted and de-clawed. Although notably doing nothing while the man was playing to protect him, the baseball authorities predictably went completely over the top in commemorating him after he was dead, retiring the '42' for all teams, making it the first number in sports to be universally retired, the only exception being April 15th, known as Jackie Robinson Day, commemorating the date of his first game as a Dodger, and on which day players from every team wear the number 42 in honour of the man. A noble gesture, But one suspects Jackie Robinson and his family would have appreciated such gestures far more when he were still alive.