Film details

Ain't Them Bodies Saints  2013

Film still

Cast

  • Rooney Mara
  • Casey Affleck
  • Nate Parker
  • Rami Malek
  • Charles Baker
  • Heather Kafka
  • Will Beinbrink
  • Kentucker Audley
  • Frank Mosley
  • Augustine Frizzell

Synopsis

More than one American critic likened the dreadfully-titled Ain't Them Bodies Saints, written and directed by David Lowrey (St. Nick), to the work of Terrence Malick, with lots of pastoral, dreamy, 'magic-hour' scenes, beautifully lit to the point where every frame could deserve with being framed, but also added that, like Malick's later works, this is also languid rather than lyrical, slow and eventually tedious, a crime drama which eventually becomes neither thrilling or dramatic. Lowrey may have the Malick technique cracked, but the talent which drove the early Malick films, such as Badlands (1973), which Ain't Them.... most closely resembles, seems to be missing here. Casey Affleck (the Ocean's series / The Killer Inside Me) plays Bob Muldoon, a wanted bank robber on the run, the period and setting appearing to be Texas in the 1970s, another parallel, to within a decade or so, of Badlands. Bob is arrested, and takes the rap for the wounding of Patrick Wheeler, a local lawman (Ben Foster - The Messenger / The Mechanic remake), when actually the real culprit is Ruth, his pregnant wife, (Rooney Mara - The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo / Side Effects). Four years pass, and Bob (off-screen) breaks out of jail, an indication of how the film is keener on atmosphere than incident, laying low at a friend's bar and planning his route home, where Ruth has raised their daughter Sylvie, who Bob has never seen, alone, and has become friendly with Patrick while politely rejecting his polite advances, and seemingly being watched intently with a neighbour across the street, Skerritt, an older man (Keith Carradine - TV's Deadwood / Dexter) who seems to be observing her with unexpected interest. The general reception from the critics in the US was that it was indeed a beautifully made piece of work, shot by Bradford Young (Pariah) and with a score by Daniel Hart (Save The Date) which reminded many of the work of Nick Cave, but the piece is so languid and dreamlike as to be utterly insubstantial, so more like a Malick film than he many have originally intended, although they were largely united in giving the acting nods to Ben Foster as the yearning, slightly tragic Patrick, giving by far the best performance in a film in which the director seems to be far more keen on capturing golden moments of sunset rather than actually creating convincing characters or drama.

Production

Director
David Lowery
Producer
Mark Burg, Cassian Elwes, Toby Halbrooks, James M. Johnson, Amy Kaufman, Lars Knudsen and Jan Van Hoy
Art Director
Jonathan Rudak
Editor
Craig McKay and Jane Rizzo
Music
Daniel Hart
Screenplay
David Lowery
Director of Photography
Bradford Young

Review

One has to start by saying that the eccentric title of Ain't Them Bodies Saints, written and directed by David Lowrey (St. Nick), is never explained or even mentioned, so unless the derivation of this has been excised in a deleted scene, to be included on some Blu-ray release, the title remains obscure, and not a little off-putting. More than one critic likened Lowrey's film to the work of Terrence Malick, with lots of pastoral, dreamy, 'magic-hour' scenes, beautifully lit to the point where ever frame deserve to be framed, but there is an additional resemblance wherein like Malick's later works, this is also languid rather than lyrical, slow and eventually tedious, what initially begins as a crime drama quickly becoming a character piece which is neither thrilling or dramatic. Lowrey may have the mechanics of the Malick technique cracked, but the talent which drove the early Malick films, such as Badlands (1973), which Ain't Them.... most closely resembles, appears to be missing here. Casey Affleck (the Ocean's series / The Killer Inside Me) plays Bob Muldoon, a wanted bank robber, the period and setting being Texas in the 1970s, another parallel, to within a decade or so, of Badlands. Bob is arrested, and takes the rap for the wounding of Patrick Wheeler, a local lawman (Ben Foster - The Messenger / The Mechanic remake), when actually the real culprit is Ruth, his pregnant wife, (Rooney Mara - The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo / Side Effects). Four years pass, and Bob (off-screen, a sign of perhaps the limited budget) breaks out of jail, an indication of how the film is keener on atmosphere than incident, laying low at a friend's bar and planning his route home, where Ruth has raised their daughter Sylvie, who Bob has never seen, and has become friendly with Patrick while politely rejecting his restrained advances, while being observed by a neighbour across the street, Skerritt, an older man (Keith Carradine - TV's Deadwood / Dexter) who was essentially their criminal mentor. Although these are potentially interesting characters in a situation which has promise, Lowrey never really does anything with them, leaving a lot of their motivations and histories a blank, which annoying when dealing with the principles, but more frustrating in the case of the excellent keith Carradine (Nashville / Southern Comfort) as the, as it transpires, morally dubious Skerritt, who later appears willing to turn on the fugitive Bob when three heavies with guns appear, looking for him, but again just who this trio are or why they are after is never explained. Lowrey has indeed produced a beautifully made piece of work, shot by Bradford Young (Pariah) and with a mordant score by Daniel Hart (Save The Date) which will remind many of the work of Nick Cave, but the piece is so languid, vague and dreamlike as to be utterly insubstantial, so more like a Malick film than Lowrey may have originally intended, but the acting nods go to Ben Foster as the yearning, slightly tragic Patrick, giving by far the best performance in a film in which the director seems to be far more keen on capturing golden moments of sunset rather than actually creating convincing characters, plot or drama.