Film details
The Butler 2013
Lee Daniel's The Butler
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Forest Whitaker
-
-
James Marsden
-
David Oyelowo
-
-
-
-
-
Terrence Howard
-
Mariah Carey
-
Minka Kelly
-
Lenny Kravitz
-
Liev Schreiber
-
Jesse Williams
-
Alex Pettyfer
Synopsis
2009. As an elderly Cecil Gaines waits in the White House, he remembers his life, and the many years he has spent here. Raised on a cotton plantation in 1926 in Macon, Georgia, Cecil is taken in by Annabeth Westfall, the estate's caretaker, after his father is shot dead in a confrontation with the farm's owner, and she trains Cecil to become a house servant. Learning advanced serving skills after being offered a position in a hotel pastry shop, he is recommended for a post in a top-class Washington DC hotel, where he meets and marries Gloria, having two children, Louis and Charlie. In 1957. Cecil is hired by the White House during the administration of Dwight D. Eisenhower, the maitre'd Freddie Fallows showing Cecil around and introducing him to Carter Wilson, the head butler and co-worker James Holloway. Eisenhower impresses Cecil by refusing to use troops to enforce school desegregation in the South, and racially intergrating Arkansas' Little Rock Central High School, enforcing the law which had been repeatedly ignored. Louis, his elder son, becomes a first generation university student at Fisk University in Tennessee, and soon becomes involved in student activism. Gloria, feeling neglected due to her husband's long working hours and devotion to his job, slides into alcoholism, beginning an affair with a neighbour, Howard. John F.Kennedy is elected President in 1961, and shortly afterwards Louis and a bunch of friends are attacked by the KKK in Alabama, forcing the young man to take part in an anti-racist march in Birmingham, Alabama, which leads to JFK giving the speech proposing the Civil Rights Act, Several months later he is assassinated, successor Lyndon B. Johnson signing the Act into law. Before she leaves the White House Jackie Kennedy gives Cecil one of the former president's neckties. Cecil realises he is living a comfortable and well-paid life when so many are struggling, and feels guilty, but remains devoted to his job. Following the assassination of Martin Luther King in April 1968, Louis visits and tells his family that he has joined the radical group The Black Panthers, causing Cecil to order his son and his girlfriend, Carol, to leave his house. Cecil's other son, Charlie, confides to Louis that he plans to join the Army to fight in Vietnam, infuriating his brother. A few months later, Charlie is killed and buried at Arlington. When the Black Panthers increasingly resort to violence, Louis leaves the organisation and returns to college, studying for a Master's degree. Realising the black White House staff receive unequal pay and are offered fewer chances of career advancement Cecil confronts his supervisor over the issue. President Ronald Reagan agrees and the rates and other working conditions are equalised, Cecil and his wife Gloria being invited by President and Nancy Reagan to be guests at a state dinner, but while honoured, it is unsettled by the massive class differences he sees at the White House. When Reagan refuses to support economic sanctions against apartheid South Africa, Cecil, having served for more than five decades under a number of different administrations, resigns. With his wife wanting him to become reconciled with Louis, telling Cecil that Louis has told her that he loves and respects them both, Cecil now understanding that his son's rebelliousness and activism is genuine and heroic, the pair coming together once more at a Free South Africa Movement protest. An elderly Cecil sees Barack Obama on the 2008 Presidential campaign. Gloria dies shortly before Obama is elected as the first African-American President. In 2009 Cecil is invited to the White House to meet the newly inaugurated President at the White House.
Production
- Director
- Lee Daniels
- Producer
- Lee Daniels, Cassian Elwes, Buddy Patrick, Pam Oas Williams and Laura Ziskin
- Art Director
- Lori Agostino, Erik Polczwartek and Jason Baldwin Stewart
- Editor
- Joe Klotz
- Music
- Rodrigo Leão
- Screenplay
- Danny Strong, based on The Washington Post article A Butler Well Served By This Election by Wil Haygood
- Director of Photography
- Andrew Dunn
Review
Bearing the title The Butler in the UK, as opposed to the US where the film was entitled Lee Daniel's The Butler due to a copyright clash, one wonders if the inclusion of the director's name was a major gamble by the producers, seeing as Daniels' previous two offerings were the divisive Precious and the howlingly derided The Paperboy, but to the amazement of many the film became a surprise hit in the US, taking just over $115m (@£71.2m) in eleven weeks of release, against a budget of $30m (@£18.6m), although almost all the good notices the film earned were more for the central performance of Forest Whitaker, some optimistically tipping him for another Oscar, as opposed to the film itself, which many derided for poor scripting, an overwhelming sense of melodrama, which seems to be Daniels' trademark, and what many called farcical casting in the number of actors who appear as various US Presidents, seemingly no matter how physically dissimilar or completely unsuitable in every sense. The fact that no fewer than 38 different producers in various capacities are credited with bringing this to the screen also adds to the almost surreal feel of large portions of the pic. Although based on a genuine character, Eugene Allen, a black butler who served eight U.S. Presidents at the White House, who died in 2010 at the age of 90, the screenplay, by Danny Strong, based on The Washington Post article A Butler Well Served By This Election by Wil Haygood, instead turns the real Allen into a fictional character called Cecil Gaines, and adds a largely completely fictional family life, and since it is a Lee Daniels film none of this can be anything like resembling normality, so his wife, Gloria (TV chat show host Oprah Winfrey), is given bizarre, rambling speeches about a black woman being in the White House, in a performance which makes one wonder if she was told that the film actually centred on her character rather than Gaines himself, and not only does his fictional eldest son, Louis (David Oyelowo - Lincoln / TV's Spooks), resent his father having what he sees as a menial job working for the white man, but then joins the Black Panthers as well, trying to jam some thriller elements into the middle of the film, then having his career having a remarkable volte face and having him take a career path which has him eventually standing for Congress. What the script turns Gaines into is some sort of everyman who just happens to have a front row seat at every major event in American Civil Rights history, from the violence meted out by sharecroppers to their black staff and tenants through the violence of the KKK, the marches against segregation, the passage of the Civil Rights Act through the Senate and the eventual election of Barack Obama, which the real Eugene Allen never lived to see. What is stranger is the treatment of the Presidents themselves, portrayed in examples of 'stunt casting' such as James Marsden (the X-Men series) as John F. Kennedy, John Cusack (Grosse Point Blank / Con-Air) as Richard Nixon, Liev Schrieber (Scream / Manchurian Candidate remake) as Lyndon B. Johnson and Alan Rickman (Die Hard / Sweeney Todd) as Ronald Reagan, partnered, in what is either delicious irony or just another example of bizarre peculiarity, by Jane Fonda as Nancy Reagan. Each portrayal shows the President as some sort of beatific benefactor, kind, warm, dedicated to good works and completely anti-racist, even Reagan, whose justifiably blemished reputation is probably the most inappropriately burnished here, even as he refuses to support economic sanctions against apartheid South Africa, the point where the fictional Cecil quits his job. Similarly cecil while in his employment is the very image of subservience himself, only becoming angry or passionate when under his own roof, as the personal problems in his life, from his wife's alcoholism and infidelity and the death of one son in Vietnam, just pile up one on top of the other. That Lee Daniels, in the space of only three features, has now achieved some sort of tenuous fame that now allows him his name above the title is bizarre and reprehensible in itself, and the comparisons with a marginally less moralising Tyler Perry, with better production values, are justified, but Whitaker aside The Butler appears to be a collection of truly strange casting, scripting and directing decisions which have somehow all ended up in the same, wearying 132 minutes.