Cast
-
Peter Mullan
-
Jason Flemyng
-
Antonia Thomas
-
Freya Mavor
-
-
George MacKay
-
Paul Brannigan
-
Kevin Guthrie
-
Daniela Nardini
-
Gayle Telfer-Stevens
-
Emily-Jane Boyle
-
Sarah Vickers
Synopsis
Actor Dexter Fletcher has certainly appeared in some interesting movies since he first appeared as a child actor, ranging from the impressively arty (Caravaggio) to the more popularist (Lock, Stock....) and the daftly exploitative (Doom), but for his second directoriual outing after 2012's Wild Bill he tackles something which one can't really see playing too well anywhere south of Carlisle, the film version of what is claimed to be a successful stage musical based on the music of The Proclaimers, twin Scottish brothers, Craig and Charlie Reid, who both frighteningly resemble Beaker from The Muppets, and the simple truth is that you're enjoyment of this may purely rest on just how much you can tolerate such as 500 Miles, Letter From America, and......and, er, all their other songs, one of them obviously being Sunshine On Leith, but we've never heard that one. Instead of using the original versions, Sunshine On Leith takes the Mamma Mia path of having the actual cast sing the musical numbers, these being studio recorded, and are largely mob-handed, rather than having them recorded live on-set in the manner of Les Miserables. Critics have noted that, like Mamma Mia and any number of stage 'jukebox' musicals, the plot is twisted into extremely tortuous shapes in order to accommodate the songs, the bones of the script following two ex-squaddies, Davy (George MacKay - For Those In Peril) and Ally (Kevin Guthrie - TV's The Field Of Blood / Case Histories), who return home to Edinburgh after serving in Afghanistan, the pair having to adjust to life after the Army and to have to cope with the everyday struggles of living with their families once again, getting a job and having to restart relationships once again after years away. As some have noted, the screenplay by Stephen Greenhorn, author of the original stage show, is so literal in parts it has someone say they will have to move five hundred miles away (cue 500 Miles), and has another travel to the US (cue....well, guess) in order to fulfil the demands of the band's fans. There are a couple of fine names in the cast, including Jane Horrocks (Little Voice), who can certainly carry a tune, Jason Flemyng (The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen / X-Men: First Class) and the very fine Peter Mullen (Tyrannosaur / N.E.D.S.), whose warbling is as yet an unknown quantity, but one's tolerance for this is purely based on how many Proclaimers songs being yelled at you in the name of a 'feelgood musical' you can take, a number we suspect is lower than the producers may think.
Production
- Director
- Dexter Fletcher
- Producer
- Andrew Macdonald, Arabella Page Croft, Kieran Parker and Allon Reich
- Art Director
- Lydia Farrell and Zoe Wight
- Editor
- Stuart Gazzard
- Music
- Original score by Paul Englishby, original songs by The Proclaimers
- Screenplay
- Stephen Greenhorn, based on his own stage play
- Director of Photography
- George Richmond
Review
Actor Dexter Fletcher has certainly appeared in some interesting movies since he first emerged as a child actor, ranging from the impressively arty (Caravaggio) to the more popularist (Lock, Stock....) and the daftly exploitative (Doom), but for his second directorial outing after 2012's Wild Bill he tackles something which one suspects may not play too well anywhere south of Carlisle, the film version of what is claimed to be a successful stage musical based on the music of The Proclaimers, the twin Scottish brothers, Craig and Charlie Reid, who both frighteningly resemble Beaker from The Muppets, and who have been knocking out tuneful, enthusiastic and lightweight singalongs which allow the audience to drunkenly bawl along since their formation in 1983, first having chart success, with Letter From America, in 1987. The real bellwether of how much one may enjoy this equates purely to your enjoyment of such as 500 Miles, Letter From America, and...... and, er, all their other songs, one of them obviously being Sunshine On Leith, but we can't remember ever having heard that one. Instead of using the original versions, Sunshine On Leith takes the Mamma Mia path of having the actual cast sing the musical numbers, these being studio recorded, and are largely mob-handed, rather than having them recorded live on-set in the manner of Les Miserables. Like Mamma Mia! before it, and any number of stage 'jukebox' musicals, the plot is twisted into extremely tortuous shapes in order to accommodate the songs, the bones of the script following two ex-squaddies, Davy (George MacKay - For Those In Peril) and Ally (Kevin Guthrie - TV's The Field Of Blood / Case Histories), returning home to Edinburgh after serving in Afghanistan, having to adjust to life after the Army, getting a job and having to restart relationships once again after years away, Ally resuming his relationship with Liz (Freya Mavor - TV's Skins / The White Queen), Davy's sister, who promptly sets her brother up with her English friend Yvonne (Antonia Thomas - TV's Misfits). Thus being a couple of will they / won't they relationships, and a strangely serious subplot of a father (the very fine Peter Mullen - Tyrannosaur / N.E.D.S.) discovering a daughter he never knew he had, but since the film is determined to remain 'feelgood' at all costs this is never plumbed for any sort of emotional pain or depth but just becomes another low-stakes problem to be triumphantly overcome in the last reel. The screenplay adapted by Stephen Greenhorn, author of the original stage show, is sometimes painfully literal in parts, so it will have someone say they will have to move five hundred miles away (cue 500 Miles), and has another travel to the US (cue....well, guess) in order to fulfil the demands of the band's fans. There are a couple of fine names in the cast, including Jane Horrocks (Little Voice), who can certainly carry a tune, and Jason Flemyng (The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen / X-Men: First Class), but a singing voice isn't actually a requisite here, as the songs are almost shouted rather than sung, and one's tolerance for this may be purely based on how many Proclaimers songs being yelled at you one can stand in the name of a 'feelgood musical', which wants you to enjoy it at the cost of threatening your hearing permanently.