Film details

One Chance  2013

Cast

  • James Corden
  • Mackenzie Crook
  • Julie Waters
  • Alexandra Roach
  • Jemima Rooper
  • Kathryn Drysdale
  • Valeria Bilello
  • Trystan Gravelle
  • Ewan Austin
  • Alex Macqueen
  • Stanley Townsend

Synopsis

Since the story of Paul Potts is generally known to those who watched the 2007 version of Britain's Got Talent, surely the major audience for this, one really has to wonder just why there is a film version of a story, or 'journey' as the combatants on this sort of thing always seem to be on, and if we were being more cynical we would say that it seems just another attempt by Simon Cowell to insinuate himself in yet more media, with this being followed up in a few months by Pudsey - The Movie, a film about another Cowell talent show winner, yes, the dog act, in all senses of the world, and a Susan Boyle bio-pic apparently being in the works, but apparently proving more difficult to script and cast, for pretty obvious reasons. Directed by David Frankel (The Devil Wears Prada / Marley & Me / The Big Year), whose CV doesn't instantly bolster one's confidence, and scripted by Justin Zackham (The Bucket List / The Big Wedding), ditto squared, the script is simplicity itself, as Paul Potts (James Corden - TV's Gavin & Stacey / The Wrong Mans), a shy shop assistant by day and an amateur opera singer by night, enters Britain's Got Talent, or BGT, seeming to be a novelty given the gruesome line-up of Robbie Williams and Beyonce imitators who appear to be its' staple, and wins. Tears all round, everybody round the pub. All very nice for a movie, but the reality is rather more difficult, Potts being in deep debt when he entered, with his relationship with his partner about to fall apart, and although Potts has made some money and recorded a few moderately-selling albums, he certainly hasn't hit the heights of the opera world since, quite simply, he's an amateur who struck amazingly lucky, opera singing being an anomaly in such a bottom-feeding programme that suddenly a man with not a particularly strong or trained singing voice was being compared to Pavarotti (who makes a slightly bad-taste ghostly cameo appearance here), Domingo and the opera greats, when in actuality Potts was a chorus singer at best, all these claims that he would soon be playing to packed houses at Milan's La Scala and The New York Met being just laughable., The supporting cast is notable, including the always entertaining Mackenzie Crook (TV's The Office), Colm Meaney (Con Air / A Belfast Story) as Potts' father Roland, Julie Waters (Educating Rita / the Harry Potter series), Alexandra Roach (The Iron Lady / TV's Utopia) and the inevitable self-promoting cameo from Cowell himself, but since every ticket bought will put yet more money into his pocket, Cowell's Syco Television being one of the production companies, one might rather consider what else is playing at the multiplex, or sitting on the DVD shelf.

Production

Director
David Frankel
Producer
Simon Cowell, Mike Menchel, Kris Thykler and Brad Weston
Art Director
Nick Dent (supervisor)
Editor
Wendy Greene Bricmont
Music
Theodore Shapiro
Screenplay
Justin Zackham
Director of Photography
Florian Ballhaus

Review

Since the story of Paul Potts is generally known to those who watched the 2007 version of Britain's Got Talent, surely the major audience for this, one really has to wonder just why there is a film version of a story, or 'journey' as the combatants on this sort of thing always seem to be on, and the more cynical we would say that it seems just another attempt by Simon Cowell to insinuate himself in yet more media, with Cowell licensing the stories of the winners of his various TV abominations, including Pudsey, the dog act, in all senses of the word, and a Susan Boyle bio-pic apparently being in the works, but apparently proving difficult to script and cast, for pretty obvious reasons. With an unexpected director in the form of David Frankel (The Devil Wears Prada / Marley & Me / The Big Year), whose CV doesn't instantly bolster one's confidence, and scripted by Justin Zackham (The Bucket List / The Big Wedding), ditto squared, the script is simplicity itself, as Paul Potts (James Corden - TV's Gavin & Stacey / The Wrong Mans), a shy shop assistant by day and an amateur opera singer by night, enters Britain's Got Talent, or BGT, Potts seeming to be a novelty given the gruesome line-up of Robbie Williams and Beyonce imitators who appear to be its' staple, and wins. Tears all round, everybody round the pub. All very nice for a movie, but the reality is rather more difficult, Potts being in deep debt when he entered, with his relationship with his partner about to fall apart, and although Potts has made some money and recorded a few moderately-selling albums, he certainly hasn't hit the heights of the opera world since, quite simply, he's an amateur who struck amazingly lucky, opera singing being an anomaly in such a bottom-feeding programme as Britain's Got Talent that suddenly a man with not a particularly strong or trained singing voice was being compared to Pavarotti (who makes a slightly bad-taste cameo appearance here), Domingo and the opera greats, when in actuality Potts was a chorus singer at best, all these claims that he would soon be playing to packed houses at Milan's La Scala and The New York Met being just laughable. James Cordon is amiable if extremely restrained as Potts, playing up the put-upon victim angle, but one wants more than just the lightweight, feelgood at all costs, 'inspirational' story this wants to be, turning it into the inevitable 'journey' indeed. The supporting cast is notable, including the always entertaining Mackenzie Crook (TV's The Office), Colm Meaney (Con Air / A Belfast Story) as Potts' father Roland, Julie Waters (Educating Rita / Harry Potter series), Alexandra Roach (The Iron Lady / TV's Utopia) as long-suffering wife Jules, and the inevitable self-promoting un-billed extended cameo from Cowell himself, but since every ticket bought will put yet more money into his pocket, Cowell being one of the producers, one might rather consider what else is playing at the multiplex, or sitting on the DVD shelf.