Cast
-
-
-
Vera Farmiga
-
-
Vincent D'Onofrio
-
Leighton Meester
-
-
-
Sarah Lancaster
-
Dax Shepard
-
Balthazar Getty
-
Ken Howard
Synopsis
Very much a Robert Downey project, his wife producing for their Team Downey production company, The Judge has been noted as being very much 'Oscar bait' from the American critics who have seen the and also the marketing push being put behind it, very much positioning it as a 'prestige' production, a John Grisham concept starring Iron Man. What most critics agreed on was that it was a strangely 90's-style idea, Grishamesque with a superb cast, but also strangely dated, with Downey as Hank Palmer, a tough hotshot Chicago lawyer, who returns home to defend his virtually estranged father, a hardline former small-town judge Joseph Palmer (Robert Duvall - Tender Mercies / Jack Reacher), against a charge of murder, accused of intentionally running over a man he'd once convicted for murder. The screenplay, by Bill Dubuque and Nick Schenk, from an original story by Schenk and director David Dobkin, combines two button-pushing genres, the courtroom drama and the small-town homecoming movie, eventually settling down to a father / son bonding story, usually catnip to the Academy judges, which apparently remains watchable even over an extended running time of 141 minutes, edging towards the weepie-style ending, made less painful by the impressive camerawork of Janusz Kaminski (Saving Private Ryan / Lincoln), and even more surprising when one considers the director is David Dobkin (Shanghai Knights / Fred Claus), an unexpected choice not exactly known for his stylistic nuances. Critics noted that the various other characters are the expected stereotypes and stock templates, such as Billy Bob Thornton (TV's Fargo) as the smarmy, devious local DA; Vera Farmiga (Up In The Air) as Samantha, Hank's ex who still happens to live in town; Vincent D'Onofrio (TV's Law And Order: Criminal Intent) as the one-time athlete who missed his chance to make it in sport and get out of the rural 'berg, and Dax Shepard (TV's Parenthood) as the well-intentioned but out-of-his-depth small-town lawyer, the cast also including Oscar-winner Melissa Leo (Frozen River), David Krumholtz (TV's Numb3rs) and Leighton Meester (TV's Gossip Girl). A classy, very professional and polished production, but some critics found it to be far too calculating and engineered overall, and at times completely losing sight of the actual plot, the courtroom case and murder trial, in favour of the tearful father / son reunion scenes, as good as both Downey and Duvall are, and at over two hours and twenty minutes was stretched too thin over the running time.
Production
- Director
- David Dobkin
- Producer
- Robert Downey Jr., Susan Downey and Jeff Kleeman
- Art Director
- Shadya H. Ballug and David Swayze
- Editor
- Mark Livolsi
- Music
- Thomas Newman
- Screenplay
- Bill Dubuque and Nick Schenk, based on an original story by David Dobkin and Nick Schenk
- Director of Photography
- Janusz Kaminski