Film details

They Came Together  2014

Film still

Cast

  • Amy Poehler
  • Paul Rudd
  • Christopher Meloni
  • Cobie Smulders
  • Max Greenfield
  • Melanie Lyndsky
  • Ellie Kemper
  • Jason Mantzoukas
  • Ed Helms
  • Kenan Thompson
  • Jack McBrayer

Synopsis

David Wain is possibly the true definition of a modern cult filmmaker, a writer and director who has a hardcore of truly dedicated fans, praising to the skies absolutely anything he is involved in, and while constantly working, on films such as Wet Hot American Summer ('01), a summer camp film with a now-remarkable cast but also being regarded as a truly hysterical comedy fatally hampered by that title, Role Models ('08) and Wanderlust ('12), Wain really has little in the way of name recognition outside his fanbase. They Came Together is a skewering of modern rom-coms, with two strong leads in the form of Wain regular Paul Rudd and Amy Poehler (TV's Parks And Recreation), sending up all the expected cliches of today's romantic comedies, with Nora Ephron's You've Got Mail, itself based on the 1940 romantic comedy The Shop Around The Corner, seemingly being the inspiration, as loving couple Joel (Rudd) and Molly (Poehler) regale their friends at a dinner party just how they met, when Joel was a PR man for a multinational candy company, and Molly was a New York sweetshop owner, trying to stop being taken over by Joel's employers. Of course they fall for each other and Wain dutifully supplies all the cliches expected, including a montage of the two arm-in-arm meandering through Manhattan, making hand-made pasta together, kicking up piles of autumn leaves and generally acting like annoying children, but while Wain captures these perfectly, just seeing such scenes perfectly replicated, down to being backed by a Norah Jones soundtrack, isn't actually particularly funny, and unless one has been tipped the wink that this is actually a send-up rather than being sappy and sincere, even if an aerial establishing shot of the city is repeated so often as to become the film's longest recurring joke. Critics have noted that what actual laughs are to be had here come from the quite remarkable supporting cast Wain has managed to accrue, showing his two decades in comedy, with virtually every player being a noted comedian either in film or TV, including (deep breath) Cobie Smulders (TV'S How I Met Your Mother), Christopher Meloni, a stand-up before his years on Law & Order: SVU, Max Greenfield (TV's New Girl), Melanie Lynskey (TV's Two And A Half Men), Bill Hader and Kenan Thompson (both TV's Saturday Night Live), Ellie Kemper (US TV's The Office), Jason Mantzoukas (The Dictator), Ed Helms (The Hangover) and Jack McBrayer (TV's 30 Rock), a remarkable line-up and one which perhaps should have graced a rather less subtle, more obviously humorous film. Wain may be sending up the rom-com conventions here, but appears to have done it so subtly, and with such painstaking attention and devotion to detail, that nobody noticed.

Production

Director
David Wain
Producer
Michael Showalter
Art Director
Anastasia White
Editor
Jamie Gross
Music
Matt Novack and Craig Wedren
Screenplay
Michael Showalter and David Wain
Director of Photography
Tom Houghton