Film details

Third Person  2014

Cast

Synopsis

In recent years amid all the arguments about the Oscars one which seems to be the most persistent is the idea that Paul Haggis' 2004 winner Crash was probably the most ill-deserved recipient of recent years, Academy voters being blindsided by Haggis' film dealing with the hot-button topic of race, despite the fact it was in the crudest, most obvious and polemical way possible. Interestingly a 2009 TV series based on the film (yes, honestly), and on which he was a producer, rather - er - crashed and burned, lasting only one barely-watched series. Haggis also doesn't seem to have really capitalised on his high-profile, his contributions to the scripts of two Craig Bond film being largely rewritten by series scribes Wade and Purvis, and his latest feature, Third Person, despite a genuinely impressive cast, with a couple of obvious exceptions, and shooting in New York, Paris and Rome, being a major flop, receiving some truly derisive reviews and earning just over a million dollars at the US box-office. Once again, as with Crash, his film is another ensemble drama about the intersecting lives of troubled characters, each riven by guilt of some kind, intercutting between three parallel stories happening in those cities. In Paris, novelist Michael (Liam Neeson, for once not knocking seven shades of shitake mushrooms out of people) work on his latest tome, having left his wife, Elaine (Kim Basinger - L.A. Confidential) for his young protégé, Anna (Olivia Wilde - Rush), but the relationship seems already to be in trouble. In Rome, an obnoxious American businessman, Scott (Adrien Brody - The Pianist) is involved with single mother Monika (Moran Atias - Mother Of Tears) who is trying to get her son back, and in New York, former actress Julia (Mila Kunis - Black Swan) is battling her ex, Rick (James Franco - 127 Hours), now a famous artist, employing a high-profile lawyer, Theresa (Maria Bello - A History Of Violence), to try to get joint custody after recklessly endangering their son. As one can see the overwhelming theme here is guilt, with all the couplings having something to feel guilty about, the film, all two and a quarter hours of it, have them endlessly warble on about their feelings of angst, pain, culpability, self-reproach, contrition, all those jolly things, and as The AV Club put it so neatly, 'Those who groaned through Crash will find plenty to groan about here, too,' particularly at the terrible and actually quite predictable final 'twist' Haggis throws in just to dispense with any residual goodwill the audience may still have. What almost all the critics have noted is that one of the real problems with Haggis is his heavy-handedness, his thumping directorial style, when attached to one of his own, over-emphatic, overly simplistic scripts, just bludgeons the audience with sheer obviousness and an utter lack of any restraint on the melodrama.

Production

Director
Paul Haggis
Producer
Paul Breuls, Paul Haggis and Michael Nozik
Art Director
Luca Tranchino (supervisor)
Editor
Jo Francis
Music
Dario Marianelli
Screenplay
Paul Haggis
Director of Photography
Gianfranco Corticelli