Film details

Critical Care  1997

Still unavailable

Cast

Synopsis

After Felicia and Connie Potter's elderly father is admitted into a private clinic, they are horrified to discover that to keep the old man alive is costing $112,800 a month, which is eating into the wealthy man's considerable estate. The sisters find themselves arguing whether his life should be unnaturally prolonged by medicines and machines, leading to rifts between the two, not knowing that the seemingly sympathetic young doctor, Dr.Werner Ernst, is manipulating the two siblings against each other, hoping to keep the patient hooked up to the clinic's machinery and keeping the dollars rolling in.

Production

Director
Sidney Lumet
Producer
Sidney Lumet and Steven Schwartz
Art Director
Philip Rosenberg
Editor
Tom Swartwout
Music
Michael Covertino
Screenplay
Steven S. Schwartz, based on the book by Richard Dooling
Director of Photography
David Watkin

Review

The American health system is such a grotesque mess that to satirise it often brings directors up short. Robert Altman failed with his dismal Health, and director Sidney Lumet (Prince of the City / Dog Day Afternoon) also has a rare misfire with this black comedy which lurches into both heavy-handed satire and misplaced melodrama. That the American medical system runs on money rather than compassion or sympathy should really come as no surprise, and a fine cast, including Albert Brooks (Lost In America),,/i> Edward Herrmann (Down), Helen Mirren (Teaching Mrs.Tingle) and Wallace Shawn (Prick Up Your Ears) are left struggling with the awkward script. The worst miscasting comes in the case of James Spader (Crash / Secretary), who seems to be playing a part written for a man considerably older. Fans of those concerned will be interested, but virtually everybody, from the director through the cast, have done much better previously.