Film details

The Scarlet and the Black  1983

The Vatican Story
Still unavailable

Cast

Synopsis

As the Second World War erupts and the Germans invade Italy, a deal is done between the Vatican and the Nazis, meaning that the Vatican City is declared a neutral zone, even though the Nazis have invaded Rome itself. Monsignor Hugh O'Flaherty, an Irish priest appointed to serve in the Vatican, uses his status and the neutrality of the Vatican in order to establish an escape network for Allied prisoners, POW camp escapees being helped to make their way to the Vatican then being aided in passage out of the country. Colonel Hubert Kappler, the SS officer in charge of Rome knows that O'Flaherty is somehow helping Allied escapees, but is wary of upsetting the delicate concordance between the Third Reich and the Vatican, knowing that the Nazis need the Church on their side. Kappler tries to break the network, but cannot. O'Flaherty manages to keep the network intact, but as the Allies storm into Rome, O'Flaherty performs an act which is above and beyond his calling.

Production

Director
Jerry London
Producer
Bill McCutchen
Art Director
John Stoll and Pier Luigi Basile
Editor
Benjamin A. Weissman
Music
Ennio Morricone
Screenplay
David Butler, based on the original book by J.P.Gallagher
Director of Photography
Giuseppe Rotunno

Review

Based on the true story of Irish priest Hugh O'Flaherty, inevitably to be described as the Vatican's Oscar Schindler, The Scarlet and the Black does take liberties with the details of the priest's story, but remains true to what he did, up to and including the final acts as the Allies were moving into Rome, which it would be unfair to reveal here. A 'Euro-pudding' of various European TV interests, the production quality is impressive and the cast is of high quality in depth, even if little of the casting has sympathy with the actual character's nationality - American Gregory Peck playing an Irishman, Canadian Christopher Plummer as a German, British John Gielgud as the duplicitous and devious Pope Pius XII, etc. Slicky directed by TV veteran Jerry London, with an eye for a composition if no sense of pace, this is Sunday afternoon viewing with little to offend.