Film details

Author: The JT LeRoy Story  2015

Film still

Cast

  • Laura Albert
  • Bruce Benderson
  • Dennis Cooper
  • Panio Gianopoulos
  • Ira Silverberg

Synopsis

A documentary which has echoes of Orson Welles' superb F For Fake ('73), one should also be ready for what Jeff Feuerzeig's film may dabble in, notably, and particularly apt in the case of author JT LeRoy, an unreliable narrative from an equally untrustworthy narrator, telling the story of the reclusive author who became a literary sensation in 1999 with the publication of their first two novels, Sarah and The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things, having previously written over the previous three years for such literary magazines as Nerve and Shout NY. The novels, dark and brooding works delving into the world of abuse, abandonment, homelessness, drugs and addiction, LeRoy was very rarely seen, except in a publicity photograph behind dark glasses, wearing a wig and a hat. In the few personal details published, they claimed to be 'gender-fluid', just nineteen years old, and that the books were highly autobiographical in nature, having turned to writing as a form of therapy. Jeremiah 'Terminator' LeRoy, to give them their full moniker, became feted by the literary world, turning up in multiple anthologies, writing liner notes and biographies for a number of rock artists and musicians, as well as being credited as writer of the original screenplay for Gus Van Sant's 2003 film Elephant, despite it being largely improvisational, and being an associate producer for the film version of The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things, made in '04, directed by and starring Asia Argento, and both Winona Ryder and Argento are seen in archive footage giving LeRoy hugely fulsome praise and adoration in scenes which must now make them simply cringe. The reason was simple. JT LeRoy simply didn't exist. The entire persona was the creation of a forty-year-old mother, Laura Albert, who narrates here and explains how and why, at least in her own version of the story, she created the character, and the bizarre twists it took, Albert persuading her sister-in-law, Savannah Knoop, to play the androgynous LeRoy in public appearances, behind the hat, wig and glasses, whilst she herself pretended to be JT's British best friend, Speedie, despite the fact that her accent was ridiculously unconvincing yet no one called her out on it, another aspect of the sheer weirdness of the story. Jeff Feuerzeig's wants to confront the idea of what a literary 'celebrity' actually is, and if the literary world accepts the writer and their work as what they present, then why shouldn't 'JT LeRoy' be accepted as a 'genuine' writer, but as said, Albert is an unreliable narrator, and in certain scenes, such as playing recorded phone calls with the likes of Courtney Love, Gus Van Sant and her psychiatrists, Albert seeming to have recorded all of her phone calls for reasons never explained, and when she talks of LeRoy 'communicating through her' one doesn't know whether this is evidence of some sort of mental illness manifesting itself or just another diversionary tactic. Author since the beginning of time have written behind pseudonyms for a number of reasons, such as Stephen King writing sci-fi as Richard Bachman, John D. McDonald penning books far more brutal and violent than his otherwise relatively genial crime stories as Richard Stark, and Booker Prize-winner Julian Barnes writing the adventures of private eye Duffy under the name Dan Kavanaugh, but many took exception at Albert's deception by claiming the books were autobiographical, where clearly they were nothing of the sort, and a thread of the 'character' having HIV was quickly dropped when 'LeRoy' started to become more and more high-profile. The touchstones for this sort of thing remain Welles' peerless F For Fake or Bart Layton's The Imposter ('12), focusing on a genuine missing child case, and the story behind LeRoy / Albert is certainly interesting, even if one wishes there were a few more diverse, and dissenting, contributors.

Production

Director
Jeff Feuerzeig
Producer
Jim Czarnecki, Danny Gabai, Brett Ratner and Molly Thompson
Editor
Michelle M. Witten
Music
Walter Werzoka
Screenplay
Jeff Feuerzeig
Director of Photography
Richard Henkels