Film details

The Birth Of A Nation  2016

Cast

  • Nate Parker
  • Armie Hammer
  • Jayson Warner Smith
  • Jackie Earle Haley
  • Aja Naomi King
  • Tony Espinosa
  • Gabrielle Union
  • Tom Proctor
  • Roger Guenveur Smith
  • Katie Garfield

Synopsis

Many will remember that Nate Parker's The Birth Of A Nation, with the director also playing the lead as Nat Turner, who led a brief slave revolt in Virginia in 1831, attracted almost hysterically ecstatic reviews at the 2016 Sundance Film Festival and was eventually bought by Fox for a record-breaking, and eyebrow-raising, $17.5m (£13.61m), but after the hype and confident predictions of multiple Oscars subsided, came the off-screen controversy around the 17-year-old rape accusation and subsequent actions, made against filmmaker and star Nate Parker and co-writer Jean McGianni Celestin, accused of raping a Pennsylvania State University classmate while she was unconscious. Parker stood trial and was acquitted while Celestin was initially convicted for sexual assault, but later received an appeal. Their accuser committed suicide 12 years later.

After these revelations many said it would have a hard time meeting expectations raised by that huge rights payment, especially after some felt that Parker's subsequent media interviews and PR statements failed to apologise for or even fully acknowledge his part in the events, but it very much seems the film was boycotted by US cinemagoers, the film opening to less than half it's already modest predictions, with a disappointing $7m (£5.67m) in sixth position, causing Fox to their scale back their plans for a wider release in the US and re-evaluate their overseas release plans. To their credit most serious US critics very much stuck to reviewing the film rather than the events surround it, and Parker's film was very found wanting on a number of levels, seeming very much to the victim of a certain sort of word-of-mouth escalation which happens in film festivals, particularly one were there are few stand-outs, with several scribes, not doubting Parker's sincerity, questioned his judgement at times, saying the film simply isn't particularly well made, The Wall Street Journal noting 'What Mr. Parker has committed to the screen is a righteously indignant, kinetic and well-acted film – Mr. Parker, as Turner, delivers a fierce, complex performance. At the same time, his film is remarkably conventional. The framing and the camera movements are all very routine, even dated; one would have said it looks like television, before television gained its current lustre,' The Globe And Mail (Toronto) finding 'The director's pedestrian tactics are most evident in his command, or lack thereof, over his cast.

While Parker knows how to expertly play to the camera – he all but winks at the audience, so confident is he in his admittedly captivating lead performance - he abandons his fellow actors, allowing them to exploit their worst instincts: hammy accents, wild gesticulating, uneasy line readings.' The Chicago Tribune advised 'Parts of The Birth Of A Nation are bluntly effective and beautifully acted, though one of the drawbacks, ironically, is Parker's own performance. Even the rape victims of the screenplay have a hard time getting their fair share of the screen time; everything in the story, by design, keeps the focus and the anguished close-ups strictly on Parker.' The New York Times said the film marks 'a collision of Must-See and Won't-See'. Parker's film ended it's run with $15.85m (£19.55m) in the US, and has been released very selectively in certain territories, having played a number of festivals including the London FF, and recieved mixed to positive reviews, but the predictions of Parker's film going on to become an arthouse 'crossover' hit and awards magnet, much in the style of 2013's 12 Years A Slave, are now long abandoned. In analysing just why the film flopped, The Washington Post beleved 'While some moviegoers may have been put off by the controversy, middling reviews for the movie itself probably didn't help. Meanwhile, historic dramas can be a hard sell: It's possible a lot of multiplex visitors just plain weren't interested.'

Production

Director
Nate Parker
Producer
Jason Michael Berman, Aaron L. Gilbert, Preston L. Holmes, Nate Parker and Kevin Turen
Art Director
Geoffrey Kirkland
Editor
Steven Rosenblum
Music
Henry Jackman
Screenplay
Nate Parker, from a story by Nate Parker and Jean McGianni Celestin
Director of Photography
Elliot Davis