Film details

Indignation  2016

Film still

Cast

  • Sarah Gadon
  • Tracy Letts
  • Ben Rosenfield
  • Joanne Baron
  • Bryan Burton
  • Danny Burstein
  • Noah Robbins
  • Philip Ettinger
  • Pico Alexander
  • Susan Varon

Synopsis

The novels of Philip Roth have always been notoriously difficult to transfer to the big screen, with such works as Goodbye Columbus ('69), Portnoy's Complaint ('72), The Human Stain ('03) and, only last month, American Pastoral, making difficult and unsatisfactory cinematic productions, but Indignation, directed by and adapted from Roth's 2008 novel by James Schamus, former head of Focus Pictures and long time collaborator with director Ang Lee, making his directorial debut, has been called the best adaptation of Roth to date, in many ways simply because it sticks to the original narrative, helped by the fact that the book is not one of Roth's tricksier, more convoluted pieces of work and that Schamus has cut a lot of the novel's extraneous material. Largely autobiographical, and to be watched accepting Roth's usual degree of exaggeration in such books, Logan Lerman (the Percy Jackson films / 3.10 To Yuma remake) is his surrogate here, playing Marcus Messner, one of the few Jewish freshmen in the class of 1955 at the (fictional) Winesburg College in Ohio, in a coming-of-age drama in which Messner is struggling to rid himself of the burden of his family and his Jewish background, trying to re-invent himself, as did Roth, but the framing of the story, opening with an unexpected prologue, suggests just how successful he is in his quest. Schamus has had long experience dealing with actors, and it is here where Indignation is most successful, the three main roles being very well cast, with Lerman showing far more ability then he needed to in the Percy Jackson CGI fests, Sarah Gadon showing the icy intensity which made her a favourite of both David Cronenberg, casting her in A Dangerous Method ('11), Cosmopolis ('12) and Maps To The Stars ('14) and his son Brandon, she starring his hugely underrated Antiviral ('12), and a powerful performance from playwright / actor Tracy Letts (Killer Joe / TV's Homeland) as Marcus' emergent nemesis. Schamus shows ambition by tackling a potentially difficult book for his debut but directs with authority, also showing skill in trimming the original prose, and the whole ironical framing of the piece, one of the darkest twists, dealing with Roth's usual themes of guilt and remorse, is both clever and blackly comic.

Production

Director
James Schamus
Producer
Anthony Bregman, James Schamus and Rodrigo Teixeira
Art Director
Derek Wang
Editor
Andrew Marcus
Music
Jay Wadley
Screenplay
James Schamus, based on the novel by Philip Roth
Director of Photography
Christopher Blauveit