Film details

Collateral Beauty  2016

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

It has to be said that it's been quite a while since the once-unchallengeable box-office star Will Smith was in anything like a critical or commercial hit, with films such as After Earth ('13) Winter's Tale ('14) and Suicide Squad ('16), and his weirdly accented dramatic turn in the sports drama Concussion ('15) was dismissed by many as a transparent Oscar-bait grab. So it also seems with Collateral Beauty, Written by Allan Loeb, responsible for the comedies The Switch ('10) and The Dilemma ('11), are already bad omens, Collateral Beauty was originally going to be Me And Earl And The Dying Girl helmer's Alfonso Gomez-Rejon's next project, to star Hugh Jackman, Jason Segel and Rooney Mara. After Will Smith replaced Jackman due to scheduling conflicts with the upcoming Logan, Gomez-Rejon left and the whole cast was rejigged, to be now under the direction of David Frankel (Marley & Me / The Devil Wears Prada), and interestingly after the casting of Smith the budget was nearly doubled, from under $20m (@£16.33m) to $38m (£30.94m) switching from a small-scale indie drama to a full-on Hollywood star vehicle.

Helmed by David Frankel (The Devil Wears Prada / Marley And Me), the pic boasts a truly terrific cast including the venerable Helen Mirren; Kate Winslet (Titanic); Keira Knightley (The Imitation Game); Daniel Craig's Miss Moneypenny, Naomie Harris; Michael Peña (End Of Watch) and Enrique Muricano (TV's Without A Trace) but, in a year which has seen certain pics, such as London Has Fallen and Gods of Egypt, get an absolute critical shellacking, Collateral Beauty joined their ranks, being absolutely savaged by the critics, most of whom complained not only for the waste of talent and a plot verging on insanity, but the sheer emotional manipulation involved. The Village Voice helpfully explained - 'Here's a promise few movies can make. If you sink two hours into Collateral Beauty now, it's guaranteed that for the rest of your life, when conversation stalls, you can save the night by asking, 'Did you ever see that movie where Will Smith plays an ad executive so shut down with grief over the death of his daughter that his business partners - played by Edward Norton, Kate Winslet, and Michael Peña - hire actors to confront him in public in the roles of Death, Time, and Love, the abstract concepts to whom he has been penning and mailing angry letters?'

In a blistering review The New York Post noted 'This must be the first movie ever made in which the death of a child is presented as a pesky obstacle to a corporate sale,' while Newsday saw it as 'An excellent cast, immersed in a hot tub of self-pity and false sentiment … None of these characters feels real; each one is a teardrop waiting to be wrung from your duct. And given this film's air of yuppie magic realism, it's no surprise that some of them turn out to be angels, or fictions, or something equally vague.' And those were actually some of the milder ones, The Guardian ruthlessly exclaiming 'This horrifyingly yucky, toxically cutesy ensemble dramedy creates a Chernobyl atmosphere of manipulative sentimentality, topped off with an ending which M Night Shyamalan might reject as too ridiculous.' And he isn't joking either, one of the final twists being one which can perhaps be guessed, given the ridiculous nature of the entire enterprise, while a major revelation is not so much a surprise as a blatant case of hiding vital information from the audience. Of course if the Academy would just send Smith one of the damn things in the post then perhaps we wouldn't have any more of those painfully obvious Oscar-grabs.

Production

Director
David Frankel
Producer
Anthony Bregman, Brad Dorros, Kevin Frakes, Allan Loeb, Will Smith and Michael Sugar
Art Director
Scott Dougan
Editor
Andrew Marcus
Music
Theodore Shapiro
Screenplay
Allan Loeb
Director of Photography
Maryse Alberti