Film details

Loving  2016

Cast

  • Joel Edgerton
  • Ruth Negga
  • Michael Shannon
  • Marton Csokas
  • Nick Kroll
  • Alano Miller
  • Jon Bass
  • Bill Camp
  • Terri Abney
  • David Jensen
  • Sharon Blackwood
  • Michael Abbott Jr.

Synopsis

Caroline County, Virginia, the mid-1950s. Richard Loving, a white construction worker falls in love with Mildred Jeter, a local black woman and friend of the Lovings. Mildred Jeter. When Mildred finds she is pregnant, they decide to marry, but know that they cannot marry in Virginia due to the state's Racial Integrity Act of 1924, prohibiting marriage between people classified as 'white' and people classified as 'coloured'. After they wed in Washington DC, they return and Richard starts on plans to build a house for them less than a mile from her family, but the pair are arrested when Sheriff's deputies raid their home, Sheriff R.Garnett Brooks telling them their marriage licence, proudly displayed on the wall of their home, is not valid in Virginia and both are jailed.

At trial they plead guild guilty to breaking the anti-miscegenation law and are both sentenced to one year in prison, but Judge Leon M. Bazile suspends the sentence on the proviso they leave Virginia and not return for at least twenty-five years. Reluctantly they move to Washington, but return to Caroline Country so that their child can be delivered by Richard's mother, a midwife, After the birth of their son, Sidney, the pair are arrested again, but are cleared when their lawyer says he advised them they could return in error. They return to Washington and have two more children together, Donald and Peggy, but Mildred is frustrated at not being able to return to her childhood home, and after seeing the March on Washington civil right march writes to Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy, asking for his help.

He refers them to Bernard S. Cohen, a civil rights lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union, who consults constitutional law expert Phil Hirschkop and then accepts their case, believing their situation could be taken before the Supreme Court and be a catalyst to overturning similar anti-miscegenation laws across the country. As their case comes to court they are profiled in an extensive article in Life Magazine by photographer Grey Villet. Cohen warns them that the state's defence argues that people of different races were never intended to live together, and going so far as to suggest the Lovings' children are illegitimate and without any standing in law. Virginia's Supreme Court refuse to set aside the Lovings' conviction, but Cohen and Hirschkop appeal to the federal Supreme Court, and prepare to take the case, Loving v. Virginia, to the very highest level.

A remarkable and in many ways shameful tale, which has already been the subject of a well-regarded TV movie, Mr & Mrs Loving (1996), and the 2011 documentary The Loving Story, directed by Nancy Buirski, and on which Jeff Nicholls largely based his script, the changes which Richard and Mildred Loving eventually caused in racial and matrimonial laws in the US were genuine landmarks, and one has to remind oneself that his happened in the mid-60s, and not hundreds of years ago as one would expect.

Featuring strong performances across the board, with Joel Edgerton (The Gift / Black Mass) and British actress Ruth Negga (TV's Agents Of SHIELD / Preacher), surprisingly earning the film's only Oscar nomination, as the central couple, Nicholls, previously known for more esoteric fare such as Take Shelter ('11), Mud ('12) and the sci-fi drama Midnight Special ('16), emphasises that these ordinary Virginian were just that, very ordinary, and not in a detrimental way, but some critics noted that the script actually simplified and in some cases tempered the details of the case itself, with the Lovings themselves being made just a little too sweet and caring, wherein real life Richard Loving was certainly willing to defend himself and his wife, to whom he was utterly devoted, by any means.

Nicholls seems determined to play fair with most of the other character, Sheriff Brooks (Marton Csokas – The Lord Of The Rings trilogy), who could be a broad racist stereotype in other, lazier films, is portrayed as a man who has vowed to uphold the law, and thus carry out what the Virginia lawmakers have decreed in their anti-miscegenation statuettes, and Nicholls apparently met with Brooks' daughter, who described him as a decent, loving father who was nevertheless a dedicated law officer, carrying out his job without fear or favour. The idea that the Lovings are eventually 'exiled' by Judge Bazile (David Jensen – The Last Exorcism Part II), told not to return at least twenty-five years, only emphasised the bizarrely medieval feel of the prevailing attitudes at the time.

After more brushes with the law, the case eventually comes to American Civil Liberties Union lawyer Bernie Cohen (Nick Kroll – Dinner For Schmucks) and firebrand civil rights lawyer Phil Hirschkop (Jon Bass - TV's The Newsroom) while their case is brought to the attention of the public when freelance photographer Grey Villet (Michael Shannon, since it wouldn't be a Jeff Nicholls film without him) is commissioned to capture the Lovings' home life for a national magazine shoot, and was generally accepted to have captured the sympathy of most of the nation. The script includes some of the gentle, warm touches which made the Lovings so genuine, such as having their marriage certificate framed and hung on the wall, and the photography by Nicholls' regular DoP Adam Stone shows the beauty of the state even when focused against the ugliness of the state laws.

Stories like this usually end with a 'happy ever after' which didn't quite happen in the case of the Lovings themselves, who were hit by tragedy only a few years later, but their struggle and the stand they took not only helped countless couples, but threw a light on a particularly invidious practise which, sadly, some would like to reintroduce today.

Production

Director
Jeff Nichols
Producer
Nancy Buirski, Ged Doherty, Colin Firth, Sarah Green, Peter Saraf and Marc Turtletaub
Art Director
Chad Keith
Editor
Julie Monroe
Music
David Wingo
Screenplay
Jeff Nichols
Director of Photography
Adam Stone