Film details

The Mercy  2017

Deep Water

Cast

  • Rachel Weitz
  • Ken Stott
  • Mark Gatiss
  • Andrew Buchan
  • Anna Madeley
  • Jonathan Bailey
  • Genevivre Gaunt
  • Kit Connor
  • Oliver Maltman
  • Richard Teverson

Synopsis

1968, and The Sunday Times newspaper launches its Golden Globe Race, offering major cash prizes for the first ever single-handed, around-the-world, non-stop sailing voyage, and open to all comers. The first and the fastest competitors will win £5,000 each, a huge prize for a sailing competition.

Donald Crowhurst, an amateur sailor with four young children and mounting debts caused by his failing business, signs up to enter the race believing his sailing skill can put him in contention and also to publicise his latest business venture, a radio direction finder called the Navicator. Needing to raise funds to build an innovative triple-hulled 40 ft yacht, he enters into a funding deal with businessman Stanley Best, and starts work on the boat, to eventually be called the Teignmouth Electron, mortgaging house to raise further funds.

His wife, Clare, has severe reservations, as secretly does Crowhurst, and early tests on the boat do not go well, but he realises he cannot afford to pay back Stanley Best, and has to enter the race. He also hires Rodney Hallworth, a former Fleet Street crime reporter, as his press and publicity agent.

In late October he sets off to sea but almost immediately things start to go wrong for him, and the boat falls far behind the rest of the field. Days pass and he realises that, even at this early stage, he has no possible chance of winning. Becoming desperate he decides to abandon the race, lingering off the South American coast, falsifying his journey logs and reporting false positions, pretending the boat has made great progress.

He sails to Argentina and goes ashore, breaking one of the strictest rules of the race, considering admitting what has happened and flying home, but instead goes back to the boat and recommences his voyage. Weeks pass, and Crowhurst knowns that should he return he will be both humiliated and financially ruined. By early June '69 Crowhurst's journals have taken a bizarre turn, he having suffered a complete mental breakdown, writing abstract, morbid and quasi-religious passages, referring to a vague 'Creator' and the futility of man's existence.

His last log book entry is dated 1st July. On July 10th 1969 the unmanned Teignmouth Electron was found intact and adrift in the Atlantic. No body was ever found.

Production

Director
James Marsh
Producer
Graham Broadbent, Scott Z. Burns, Peter Czernin, Nicolas Mauvernay and Jacques Perrin
Art Director
Andrew Munro (supervisor)
Editor
Jinx Godfrey and Joan Sobel
Music
Jóhann Jóhannsson
Screenplay
Scott Z. Burns
Director of Photography
Eric Gautier

Review

The story of the doomed sailor Donald Crowhurst is a fascinating one, and deeply tragic, but it isn't exactly one that hasn't already been covered. As well as two very good documentaries, Alone ('79) and Deep Water ('06), there have been several fictionalised versions, or at least based on the Crowhurst story, including a 1975 TV movie, Horse Latitiudes; a French film, Les Quarantines Rugissants / The Roaring Forties ('82), and a Russian production, Race Of The Century ('86), as well as stage plays, art installations, several novels and factual books, and even an opera, entitled Ravenshead, and a book-length narrative poem The Wake Of The Electron. And 2017 brought a low budget production, simply entitled Crowhurst, directed by the always interesting Simon Rumley, who apparently takes a more abstract approach to the story, treating it more as a psychological semi-thriller, and interestingly The Mercy co-producers StudioCanal have also bought the rights to Rumley's film, planning to release it soon after their bigger-budget version plays theatrically.

Helmed by James Marsh, director of The Theory Of Everything and Oscar-winner for the breathtaking documentary Man On Wire, The Mercy, the title being a reference to an 'entity' in one of his later journal entries, has had a slow path to the screen, originally announced in 2013 to star Colin Firth (The King's Speech / the Bridget Jones series) and Kate Winslet as Crowhurst and his wife Clare, but by the time filming started, back in June '15, Rachel Weitz (The Constant Gardener / The Lobster) had replaced Kate Winslet, and Marsh's film went through period of reshooting after initial photography and a rumoured premiere at the 2017 London Film Festival came and went.

Of course one of the problems with filming the story is that, once Crowhurst sails away on what would become his last voyage, apart from a brief spell ashore in Argentina, little is truly known of what happened to him, the only remaining evidence being his faked sailing journals and progress reports, and increasingly strange and bizarre personal writings, pointing to the sailor having a major nervous breakdown and, realising that to return home would have him exposed as a cheat, and facing absolute bankruptcy, he probably killed himself rather than face what awaited him.

Unfortunately as several critics have noted, watching a man sailing alone in a small boat for several months, as he gradually crumbles mentally, isn't the most cinematic of stories, although Firth, as always, has been attracting plaudits for his performance, even though is he twenty years older than the real sailor was at the time, as have Weitz, in very much a second-fiddle role as the seemingly dutiful wife, the excellent Ken Stott (The Hobbit trilogy / TV's Rebus) as entrepreneur Stanley Best, who had a major investment in Crowhurst, and David Thewlis (Naked / Wonder Woman) as Rodney Hallworth, the former crime reporter who became Crowhurst's PR man, and Marsh and writer Scott Z. Burns (Contagion / Side Effects) structure the story to include conversations with Crowhurst, his family and friends, showing how, even before he set off, the sailor secretly didn't believe he could manage the voyage, the Sunday Times race being unique in accepting all competitors, where other similar competitions demanded that entrants demonstrated their single-handed sailing ability prior to being accepted, but Burns' script also blames the sponsors, Crowhurst's business partners and the media for being complicit in his dilemma, when in reality he should not have attempted the voyage at the first place.

Marsh is a fine director, with an equally impressive cast at his disposal, but the story of Donald Crowhurst is a mystery which will probably never be solved, leaving The Mercy a drama with a ending which is known but inexplicable.