Film details

Maudie  2016

Maud

Cast

  • Sally Hawkins
  • Kari Matchett
  • Gabrielle Rose
  • Zachery Bennett
  • Billy MacLerllan
  • Marthe Bernard
  • Lawrence Barry
  • Nik Sexton
  • Greg Malone
  • David Feehan
  • Brian Marler

Synopsis

The 1930s, Marshalltown, Nova Scotia. Maud Dowley, suffering from severe arthritis, lives with her Aunt Ida and brother Charles, and is shocked to learn that Charles has sold their family home, which their parents had bequeathed to him. Ida berates her for visiting a local nightclub, calling them dangerous immoral places, and reminding Maudie of a terrible incident in her life years earlier, when she had become pregnant and given birth to a child, and how the child was born terribly deformed and quickly died.

Maud sees Everett Lewis, the local fish seller, an inarticulate and rough-hewn man, place an advertisement for a cleaning lady in the local store and applies, taking the position in exchange for room and board. Everett's house is little more than a small shack and the two are forced to share a bed, causing the gossips in the town to claim that Maud is available for sexual services. Lewis is often sullen, unpredictable and occasionally violent towards her. Wanting to brighten up the shack, Maud paints a shelf. Pleased with the results, she then begins painting flowers and birds on the walls.

One of Everett's customers, Sandra, who lives in New York City, is intrigued by Maud's paintings and buys some of the cards Maud has decorated. Sandra later returns to Maud to commission her for a larger painting for $5. As Maud manages to persuade Everett to marry her, her paintings and art start to receive more exposure in papers and magazines and she starts to sells paintings from the house, the Lewises even being contacted by US Vice President Richard Nixon, who wants to buy one. The pair appear on the TV news, but Everett is disturbed afterwards that he seems to be regarded as detached and cruel by the locals, who have taken Maud to their hearts, while she is contacted by Ida, who is seriously ill, and wants to see Maud one last time.

They meet, Ida telling her that she is the only one in the Dowley family who ever found happiness, and confesses that Maud's baby girl did not die, Charles, believing Maud could never care for a child, adopted the baby out to a family, making some money on the side for himself. Maud is devastated by the news, and Everett starts to believe that their relationship seems only to have brought pain and anguish, forcing the pair to separate.

Reconciling after a period apart, Everett tells Maudie he has something for her, but as he arranges for her to meet her grown-up daughter for the first time, it's is obvious that Maud's physical condition is quickly deteriorating.

Production

Director
Aisling Walsh
Producer
Bob Cooper, Mary Young Leckie, Mary Sexton and Susan Mullen
Art Director
Owen Power
Editor
Stephen O'Connell
Music
Michael Timmins
Screenplay
Sherry White
Director of Photography
Guy Godfree

Review

Shot on what look to be pretty inhospitable locations in and around Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada, near where the actual fascinating story of Maud Dowley played out, this is one of those biographical pics in which one is constantly remind that real life is indeed more extreme and bizarre as any fiction, Dowley having a troubled and difficult life before settling into a very strange relationship with local fish dealer Everett Lewis, acting as his housekeeper but also sharing a bed with him for purely practical reasons, at least according to this version of events, directed by Aisling Walsh (TV's Fingersmith / Loving Miss Hatto) from a script by Sherry White (TV's Saving Hope / Rookie Blue).

Walsh's film has been receiving some good notices, mostly for the central performance of Sally Hawkins, one of Britain's most underrated actresses, best known for roles in Mike Leigh films such as Happy Go Lucky before breaking out into bigger, international films, including Woody Allen's Blue Jasmine and an acclaimed role in Guillermo Del Toro's The Shape Of Water, although even she couldn't make much of an impact in Godzilla being given so few lines, while the photography of the rugged locations by Guy Godfree (Lovesong / Nocturne) also drew praise.

But where many found fault was not only the miscasting of the otherwise very fine Ethan Hawke (Gattaca / the Beyond Sunrise trilogy) as fish dealer Everett Lewis, but also in the way that many aspects of the bizarre central relationship, that Lewis was an unpredictable, controlling and violent man who often hit Maud, despite her constant ill health, and which makes the film's shift from the story of an artist fighting everything around her, from her own family to her own body to a rather unlikely love story all the more regrettable. The pair made for an odd coupling, Lewis telling Maud at one point that his farm animals were more important to him than her, and yet, despite all this and the domestic violence, she clung on, which shows perhaps just how bad her life in the family home with her Aunt Ida (Gabrielle Rose – A Dog's Purpose / TV's The Man In The High Castle) and truly cruel and rotten brother Charles (Zachary Bennett – Cube Zero / Still Mine) was, coming to a head when a tragic event in Maudie's past is revived and becomes the final, emotionally engineered twist.

Hawkins has been widely praised for her affecting performance, and Maud Dowley's life, fighting for most of her life against not only a ruthless, manipulative family and agonising infirmity but a society in which women were expected to be wives and mothers and nothing else, finding her true voice through her art, which brings her fame and a certain independence, makes it all the more surprising that Walsh's film instead chooses to focus on a somewhat romanticised version of her relationship with Everett Lewis, which in reality was seemingly cold and abusive.